Atlas›Domain I · Psychodynamic & depth psychology›Guide 001
Guide I-001

Breuer's cathartic method and abreaction

Josef Breuer, Sigmund Freud1893
A 21 · L 38 · M 4116 interventions in the Trinity explorer1 described for recognition only
Client cardCompare
[source: …] where a claim comes from[uncertain] not confirmed in a primary source[synthesis] the writer's reconstruction

1. Introduction

Version followed: Breuer & Freud, Studies on Hysteria (1895), using the Preliminary Communication (1893) and the case histories (Anna O., Emmy von N., Lucy R., Katharina, Elisabeth von R.) in A. A. Brill's translations (1909, 1936/37). The full text of Freud's closing chapter, "The Psychotherapy of Hysteria" (Standard Edition [SE] 2: 253–305) is not drawn on here. Points that rest on it are marked [source: SE 2, not re-verified].

The book contains two versions of the method. Breuer's version (Anna O.) works in hypnosis, including the patient's own spontaneous hypnotic states. Freud's version (1892–95) gives up hypnosis and works in the waking state, using concentration and the pressure technique. Both are given below. Changes needed for use today are marked [synthesis].

The method treats a symptom as the residue of a specific forgotten event whose emotion was never discharged. In Brill's rendering, "The hysteric suffers mostly from reminiscences" [source: Preliminary Communication, Brill 1909, p. 5]. Change comes through two routes:

  • Abreaction. The patient recovers the originating memory, re-lives its affect, and puts the event into words in as much detail as possible. This discharges the "strangulated" affect.
  • Associative correction. Bringing the memory into normal consciousness lets other ideas modify it.

Recollection without affect is called "almost utterly useless" [source: Brill 1909, p. 4]. Anna O. named the procedure the "talking-cure" and, as a joke, "chimney-sweeping" [source: Brill 1936, p. 20].

2. Framework

The sources give no formal phase model. The phases below are reconstructed from the procedures in the cases [synthesis].

Phase 0: Selection and preparation.

  • Goal: confirm that the method fits the patient, and obtain their informed cooperation.
  • Source basis: Freud states that the pressure method depends on the patient's full cooperation and voluntary attention [source: Elisabeth von R., Brill 1909]. He also sets conditions on the patient's intelligence, consent and trust [source: SE 2, not re-verified].
  • Today [synthesis]: rule out medical causes of the symptom. Screen for dissociation, suicidality and limited capacity to tolerate affect. Agree how sessions will be closed down.

Phase 1: Access.

  • Goal: reach a state in which the originating memories become available.
  • Breuer: hypnosis, often the patient's own evening self-hypnosis, which Anna O. called "clouds" [source: Brill 1936, p. 19].
  • Early Freud: hypnosis induced by command [source: Emmy von N., Brill 1936, p. 34].
  • Freud from about 1892: lying down with eyes closed, plus pressure of the hand on the forehead [source: Lucy R., Elisabeth von R., Brill 1909].

Phase 2: Symptom tracing.

  • Goal: follow one symptom at a time back through each of its occurrences, in reverse chronological order, to the first one [source: Anna O., Brill 1936, pp. 23–24].

Phase 3: Reproduction with affect (abreaction).

  • Goal: narrate the first occurrence fully, with its emotion. The symptom often intensifies while the event is being told, then disappears [source: Brill 1936, pp. 23–25].

Phase 4: Working over (associative correction).

  • Goal: bring the recovered memory into ordinary consciousness, link it with the rest of the patient's ideas, and discuss it [source: Preliminary Communication, sec. V].

Phase 5: Repetition and ending.

  • Goal: repeat Phases 2–4 for each symptom, then end the treatment.
  • Anna O.: she set the end date herself, the anniversary of her move to the country, and a final session reproduced the originating hallucination [source: Brill 1936, p. 27].
  • Elisabeth von R.: treatment ended once the causes of the pain had been discussed [source: Brill 1909].

Session count and format.

  • Anna O.: visits almost every evening, at times paired with a morning session, over about 18 months [source: Brill 1936].
  • Emmy von N.: hypnosis "twice almost daily" for seven weeks [source: Brill 1936, p. 34, fn.].
  • Lucy R.: nine weeks [source: Brill 1909, p. 28].
  • Format: individual sessions, patient reclining, often daily.
  • Today [synthesis]: a weekly or twice-weekly 60–90 minute session is the practical equivalent, with roughly one target symptom per one to three sessions. This is uncertain [uncertain]: no modern manual exists.

Criteria for moving on.

  • Move from 3 to 4: the first occurrence has been narrated in detail with affect, and the symptom has flared and then subsided in session [source: Anna O.].
  • Stay in Phase 2–3: a recalled picture keeps returning, or the symptom "joins in the discussion" (flares while a topic is being talked about) [source: Elisabeth von R., Brill 1909, p. 44]. Freud held that a picture which persists has not been fully described [source: SE 2, not re-verified].
  • Symptom finished: repeated pressure brings nothing new and the patient's face is calm [source: SE 2, not re-verified].
  • Ending: the target symptoms are gone, or an end date agreed in advance has arrived.

3. Guiding principles

  • Memory, affect and words together. Recall without feeling, or feeling without words, is not enough. Keep the patient in the scene until all three are present [source: Preliminary Communication].
  • One symptom at a time. Work on a single named symptom, not the life story [source: Anna O.].
  • Go backwards in time. Trace each occurrence of the symptom in reverse order to the first occasion [source: Anna O., Brill 1936, pp. 23–24].
  • Everything must be told. Material that has not been spoken keeps acting on the patient. Ask for the complete account [source: Brill 1936, p. 21].
  • No censorship. The patient reports whatever comes, even if it seems irrelevant or is unpleasant to say [source: Elisabeth von R., Brill 1909, p. 48].
  • Let the patient lead the narrative. Questioning too much interrupts the account. Emmy von N.'s protest about this is reported in the SE 2 text [source: SE 2, not re-verified]. In practice: ask once, then listen.
  • "Nothing" is information. For Freud, "nothing came" meant withholding or resistance, not a failure of the method [source: Brill 1909, p. 48]. Today, treat it as a cue to explore. Do not press for content [synthesis].
  • The symptom is a compass. Freud used pain that flared in session to steer the inquiry [source: Brill 1909, p. 44]. Track the body in the room.
  • Expect resistance to grow nearer the core. Material is layered around a nucleus [source: SE 2 p. 288–289 via secondary]. Work from the edge inward, and don't force the centre.
  • Symptoms have several causes (overdetermination). One memory rarely explains everything [source: secondary, nosubject]. Expect several scenes per symptom.
  • Cooperation is essential. The method fails without the patient's voluntary attention [source: Brill 1909]. Explain the method and make the patient a co-investigator.
  • The relationship can become a symptom. A new symptom that appears through transference is treated like the old symptoms [source: SE 2: 303, via secondary]. Name feelings about the therapist and trace them in the same way.
  • Modest aim. Freud claimed the method removes symptoms but not the underlying disposition [source: SE 2, not re-verified]. Agree on symptom-focused goals.
  • Today: safety ahead of discharge [synthesis]. Dose affect so the patient stays able to observe. Treat recovered material as experience, not as verified fact.

4. Intervention inventory

The historical source for each item is named. Example wording is labelled (illustrative); it is mine, not the founders'. Hypnosis is described only at the level of professional training. Use it only if you are trained and credentialed in clinical hypnosis.

4.1 Preparing and enlisting the patient

  • Purpose and when to use: at the start of treatment, to obtain cooperation and voluntary attention, without which Freud says the procedure fails [source: Elisabeth von R., Brill 1909]. The screening and consent steps are modern additions [synthesis].
  • Steps:
    1. Take a symptom inventory: each symptom, when it began, and when it gets worse.
    2. Explain the model: symptoms may be tied to specific events whose feelings were never expressed.
    3. Explain the rules: say everything, including what seems irrelevant.
    4. Agree a stop signal, and how each session will be closed down.
    5. Choose the first target symptom, preferably a recent and circumscribed one.
    6. Obtain informed consent. State plainly that recovered memories can be mistaken.
  • Example language (illustrative):
    • "We'll take one symptom at a time and look for the moments it is connected to. Your job is to tell me whatever comes up, even if it seems beside the point."
    • "What we find isn't automatically a fact about the past. We'll treat it as something to understand, not as proof."
  • Watch for and signs it is working: the patient can name a target symptom and repeat the rules back to you. Rule out medical causes before treating bodily symptoms as psychogenic [synthesis].

4.2 Hypnotic access (Breuer; early Freud)

  • Purpose and when to use: to reach memories that waking recall cannot. The Preliminary Communication argues that the pathogenic memories are absent from ordinary memory and available in hypnosis [source: Brill 1909, secs. I and III]. Use it only with patients who are hypnotisable and willing. Freud found that many patients were not, and dropped hypnosis for that reason [source: Freud 1910, Lecture II].
  • Steps (training level):
    1. Induce with a standard method from your hypnosis training. Freud's own induction was abrupt and directive: he held up a finger and gave the command to sleep [source: Emmy von N., Brill 1936, p. 34]. A modern permissive induction is preferable [synthesis].
    2. Deepen only as far as is needed for clear recall.
    3. Ask about the target symptom (4.5).
    4. Re-orient the patient fully before ending.
    5. Discuss the material in the waking state (4.10).
  • Example language (illustrative): "As you settle, let your attention go to the first time you noticed [symptom]. Tell me what you see."
  • Watch for and signs it is working: detailed, scene-like recall and visible affect. Watch for spontaneous dissociation and for amnesia afterwards; Emmy von N. showed "perfect somnambulism" [source: Brill 1936, p. 34]. Hypnosis raises suggestibility, so ask open questions only [synthesis].

4.3 Using spontaneous altered states ("clouds")

  • Purpose and when to use: when a patient drifts on their own into absorbed or trance-like states. Breuer timed his visits to Anna O.'s evening self-hypnosis [source: Brill 1936, pp. 19–20].
  • Steps:
    1. Notice when absorbed states recur, and at what times.
    2. Schedule work to coincide with them, if that is clinically safe.
    3. Invite the patient to speak from within the state.
    4. Close with grounding.
  • Example language (illustrative): "You seem to have gone somewhere. Can you tell me what's there?"
  • Watch for and signs it is working: the patient talks freely and feels relief afterwards. Breuer reports she became calm and lucid after talking [source: Brill 1936]. Recurrent spontaneous absences can signal a dissociative disorder; assess for it and use a trauma-informed approach [synthesis].

4.4 Repeating the patient's words as a cue

  • Purpose and when to use: to open up material from fragments the patient produces in altered states. Breuer repeated words Anna O. had muttered during her absences, and she then elaborated stories around them [source: secondary, Encyclopedia.com "Cathartic Method"] [uncertain: not checked against the case text].
  • Steps:
    1. Note the exact words or phrases the patient uses during absorption.
    2. Later, in a focused state, repeat them back neutrally.
    3. Let the patient elaborate.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Earlier you said 'the glass.' Stay with that. What comes?"
  • Watch for and signs it is working: an associated scene emerges. Give back only the patient's own words. Never add content of your own [synthesis].

4.5 Reverse-chronological symptom tracing

  • Purpose and when to use: the core technique for any persistent symptom. Each occurrence is related in reverse order until the first occasion is reached [source: Anna O., Brill 1936, pp. 23–24].
  • Steps:
    1. Name one symptom.
    2. Ask for the most recent time it occurred.
    3. Get a brief account.
    4. Ask for the time before that.
    5. Continue backwards until the patient reaches an occurrence they cannot get beyond, or a scene that feels like the first.
    6. Narrate that scene fully (4.7).
    7. Write down the chain as you go. Breuer noted down the occasions she named [source: Brill 1936, p. 24].
  • Example language (illustrative): "When was the last time your throat closed up like that? ... And before that? ... Go back further. Is there an earlier time?"
  • Watch for and signs it is working: the occasions become older and more emotionally charged. A long list of trivial repetitions means you are staying on the surface; ask for the earliest occasion [synthesis].

4.6 Two-stage procedure: identify, then narrate

  • Purpose and when to use: when a symptom has many occurrences. Breuer hypnotised Anna O. in the morning to collect the occasions, then had her narrate them in detail in the evening [source: Brill 1936, p. 24].
  • Steps:
    1. In a short first session, or the first half of a session, list the occasions with dates or ages.
    2. In a later block, take them one by one in reverse order for full narration.
    3. Today, both halves can be done in the waking state [synthesis].
  • Example language (illustrative): "Let's first make a list of the times this happened, no detail yet. Next time we'll go through them one by one."
  • Watch for and signs it is working: the list structures the work and keeps the patient from flooding. Material often surfaces between sessions; ask about it.

4.7 Full narration with affect (abreaction proper)

  • Purpose and when to use: the active ingredient of the method. Use it once a first or key occasion has been reached. The memory must be reproduced with its affect and described in detail [source: Preliminary Communication, Brill 1909, pp. 2–4].
  • Steps:
    1. Ask the patient to describe the scene in the present tense: setting, people, sensations, words spoken, and what they felt and wanted to do but didn't.
    2. Slow down at the moments of peak feeling.
    3. Invite the action or words that were held back, such as crying, anger or protest, expressed verbally.
    4. Continue until the scene has been told completely.
    5. Let the affect settle before moving on.
  • Example language (illustrative):
    • "Stay right there. What do you see? What does your body want to do?"
    • "What did you not say then? Say it now."
  • Watch for and signs it is working: in Anna O.'s case the symptom flared while it was being related, then disappeared [source: Brill 1936, p. 25]; when she told the dog-and-glass memory, her aversion to drinking ended [source: Brill 1936, p. 23]. Calm after the affect has peaked suggests discharge. A flat, reporting tone means the affect has not been reached, so return to sensory detail [synthesis]. Escalating panic or dissociation means overwhelm (see 5.3).

4.8 Concentration in the waking state

  • Purpose and when to use: Freud's substitute when a patient could not be hypnotised. Lucy R. did not reach somnambulism and was treated in a light state [source: Brill 1909, p. 15]. With Elisabeth von R., Freud simply asked her to lie down with her eyes closed [source: Brill 1909, p. 35].
  • Steps:
    1. Have the patient recline or sit comfortably with eyes closed, free to open them.
    2. Ask them to concentrate on the symptom, or on when it began.
    3. Ask them to report whatever image or thought comes up.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Close your eyes if that's comfortable. Put your attention on the pain in your leg, and on when it started. Tell me whatever comes, picture or thought."
  • Watch for and signs it is working: images arrive. Freud's patient reported scenes "as if she read from a long picture book" [source: Brill 1909, p. 48].

4.9 The pressure technique

  • Purpose and when to use: Freud's method for getting past "I don't know" in the waking state [source: Lucy R., Brill 1909, pp. 17–18; Freud 1910, Lecture II].
  • Original form:
    1. Freud announced that a picture or idea would come when he pressed.
    2. He placed his hand on the patient's forehead.
    3. He then asked for whatever had appeared, whether or not it seemed relevant.
    4. If the patient said nothing came, he insisted that something had and repeated the pressure, sometimes three times [source: Brill 1909, pp. 18, 48].
    5. Brill's translation renders the instruction as "Under the pressure of my hand it will come into your mind" [source: Brill 1909, pp. 17–18].
  • Adapted form for today [synthesis]: physical touch now requires explicit, revocable consent, and many settings forbid it. A non-touch equivalent is a timed cue: "when I say 'now'", or the patient's own hand on their forehead. Replace insistence with a confident expectation that the patient may decline.
  • Example language (illustrative): "In a moment I'll say 'now.' Notice the first picture or thought that comes, whatever it is, and tell me, even if it seems unrelated."
  • Watch for and signs it is working:
    • Freud claimed the method "had never failed" [source: Brill 1909, p. 48]. Treat that as historical overconfidence [synthesis].
    • A cue that comes with insistence is suggestive and can produce compliant or confabulated material. Never insist about specific content [synthesis].
    • When the method is working, the content is unexpected to the patient, carries affect, and connects to the symptom.

4.10 Associative working-over (waking discussion)

  • Purpose and when to use: the second mechanism, after any recovered memory. Bringing the memory into normal consciousness lets associative correction happen [source: Preliminary Communication, sec. V].
  • Steps:
    1. With the patient fully alert, review what emerged.
    2. Link it to the symptom: "so the cough began when..."
    3. Let the patient relate it to present knowledge and values.
    4. Note what still feels unfinished.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Now that you're back here, how do you make sense of what came up? What do you know now that you couldn't know then?"
  • Watch for and signs it is working: the patient spontaneously makes the connection and the memory loses its charge. In Lucy R.'s case, insight into her feelings ended her symptom [source: Brill 1909, p. 28].

4.11 Following the symptom as a compass

  • Purpose and when to use: to steer moment by moment. With Elisabeth von R., the pain flared whenever relevant memories came near, so Freud used the reawakened pain as a guide; her legs began to "join in the discussion" [source: Brill 1909, p. 44].
  • Steps:
    1. Ask the patient to report every change in the symptom during the session.
    2. When it intensifies, ask what was just being thought.
    3. Stay with that thread until the symptom eases.
    4. If the pain persists, assume something has not yet been said.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Your hand just went to your neck. What were you thinking about a second ago?"
  • Watch for and signs it is working: the symptom flares and then eases in step with the material. If pain remains at the end of the session, plan to return to it; don't push to finish [synthesis].

4.12 Working the layers from the periphery inward

  • Purpose and when to use: for complex symptoms with several determinants. Freud describes the material as stratified in at least three ways [source: SE 2: 288–289, via secondary (nosubject.com, Encyclopedia.com)]:
    • in reverse chronological files;
    • in concentric layers of increasing resistance around a nucleus;
    • along zig-zag threads of thought that cross the layers.
  • Steps [synthesis from that model]:
    1. Start with accessible, less-charged memories.
    2. Follow thematic threads where they lead, even across time.
    3. Expect each layer to be harder to reach. Do not aim straight at a presumed central trauma.
    4. Keep a written map of themes and scenes.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Let's stay with what's available today. The rest tends to come when it's ready."
  • Watch for and signs it is working: threads converge on recurring scenes, and resistance rises as you get close. A rise in resistance signals proximity, not failure [source: SE 2 via secondary] [uncertain: Freud's exact instruction not re-verified].

4.13 Conversational catharsis without hypnosis (Katharina)

  • Purpose and when to use: for a single, brief encounter in which the patient can talk directly. Freud interviewed Katharina in one conversation, without hypnosis [source: secondary, victorianweb.org] [uncertain].
  • Steps:
    1. Ask directly about when the symptom began.
    2. Ask what had happened just before.
    3. Let the patient tell the event.
    4. Name the link between the event and the symptom.
  • Example language (illustrative): "When did these attacks first start? What was happening in your life just before?"
  • Watch for and signs it is working: relief and a coherent account within one session. Don't promise a cure from a single conversation [synthesis].

4.14 Treating feelings toward the therapist as a symptom

  • Purpose and when to use: when feelings toward the therapist interrupt the work. Freud describes the patient's false connection to the physician, and says a new symptom produced this way should be treated like the old ones [source: SE 2: 303, via garrygillard.net; Paideia/redalyc article]. He describes three kinds of relationship disturbance [source: SE 2, not re-verified] [uncertain: details not checked in this session].
  • Steps:
    1. Notice a halt in recall that coincides with a relational cue.
    2. Ask openly about feelings toward you.
    3. Trace the feeling back with 4.5 and 4.7 ("When have you felt this before?").
    4. Discuss it in the waking state.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Things went quiet after I mentioned ending early today. Did something about that land with you?"
  • Watch for and signs it is working: recall resumes once the relational feeling has been named.

4.15 Historical only: suggestion, stroking, massage and "wiping away"

  • What was done: with Emmy von N., Freud combined hypnosis with suggestions that removed symptoms. He stroked her over the eyes and stomach, prescribed baths and massage, and called his therapy "wiping away these images" [source: Brill 1936, pp. 34–37].
  • Status: Freud later moved away from these practices [source: Freud 1910].
  • Use today [synthesis]: not recommended. Touch beyond a consented forehead cue is a boundary risk, and erasing memories by suggestion is not cathartic. Listed here only so the inventory is complete.

4.16 Ending ritual and final reproduction

  • Purpose and when to use: to close treatment. Anna O. set the end date herself and, in the final session, reproduced the scene at the root of the illness [source: Brill 1936, p. 27].
  • Steps:
    1. Agree an ending date in advance.
    2. Schedule the most central remaining scene before that date, if the patient is ready.
    3. Review each symptom and its scenes.
    4. Plan what to do if symptoms return.
  • Example language (illustrative): "We have four sessions left. Is there anything you want to make sure we've gone through before then?"
  • Watch for and signs it is working: the symptoms resolve and the patient can describe the links in their own words. Elisabeth von R. relapsed when she was pressed about her love life, then was reported well [source: Brill 1909, pp. 54–55]. Plan booster sessions [synthesis].

5. Handling problems

The sources address only resistance, withholding and the relationship disturbance. Everything else in this section is [synthesis].

5.1 Stuck: "nothing comes"

  • Source: Freud took "nothing" to be withholding. He repeated the pressure, assured the patient that something had come, and asked for it regardless of relevance [source: Brill 1909, p. 48].
  • Today [synthesis]:
    1. Ask about the content that was rejected: "Did anything come that you dismissed?"
    2. Ask about any wish not to say it.
    3. Switch to a fresh entry point: a sensory detail or a more recent occurrence.
    4. Accept a genuine blank, and work with the present feeling instead.

5.2 Resistance and withholding

  • Source: Freud named two motives: the patient judges the idea unimportant, or finds it too disagreeable to say [source: Brill 1909, p. 48]. He took resistance as a sign of repression [source: Freud 1910].
  • Today [synthesis]:
    1. Name the reluctance without judgement.
    2. Explore what saying it would mean, and to whom.
    3. Let the patient approach it at the edges first.
    4. Never imply that you already know the content.

5.3 Overwhelm and dysregulation [synthesis]

  • Signs: shaking, panic, a blank stare, loss of contact, or flooding with several scenes at once.
  • Responses:
    1. Stop the narration.
    2. Open the eyes, orient the patient to the room, slow the breathing, and talk in the present tense.
    3. Resume only with a smaller piece, such as one sentence of the scene.
    4. In later sessions, dose the work: a set time limit, and the work ending well before the session ends.
  • Referral: if overwhelm recurs, move to stabilisation-first trauma work.

5.4 Abreaction without change [synthesis]

  • Pattern: repeated catharsis that brings temporary relief while the symptom returns.
  • Responses:
    1. Check for an earlier occurrence (4.5).
    2. Check for other determinants (4.12).
    3. Check whether the waking discussion (4.10) has been skipped. The Preliminary Communication's two mechanisms both matter.
  • Note: emotional discharge alone is not the goal. Stop seeking more intensity if the symptom isn't changing.

5.5 Non-adherence [synthesis]

  • Pattern: missed sessions, not telling what came up between sessions, or refusing to close the eyes or lie down.
  • Responses:
    1. Make all format elements optional.
    2. Ask what makes coming difficult, which is often anticipatory dread of the next scene.
    3. Shorten the exposure.
    4. Re-agree the goals.

5.6 Ruptures and transference [synthesis built on 4.14]

  • Pattern: the patient feels pushed (from insistence), pressures the therapist, becomes dependent, or develops erotic feelings.
  • Responses:
    1. Name the rupture and own your part, for example pressing too hard.
    2. Treat the feeling as material and trace it (4.14).
    3. Keep boundaries explicit.
    4. Consult a supervisor about erotic transference.

5.7 Modality-specific risks [synthesis]

  • False memory and suggestion: hypnosis, insistence and expectation can produce confident but inaccurate memories. Use open questions only. Don't confirm or interpret recovered abuse memories as fact. Keep careful notes. Do not use the method to investigate legal matters.
  • Dissociation: patients with spontaneous trance states, like Anna O., may have dissociative disorders. Assess first and work phase-oriented.
  • Touch: obtain explicit consent for the pressure cue, or use a verbal cue.
  • Medical symptoms: get a medical work-up before treating a bodily symptom as psychogenic.
  • Iatrogenic symptom worsening: symptoms intensify during recall [source: Brill 1936, p. 25]. Warn the patient in advance, and end the session only after the symptom has settled.

Sources

Next · I-002 →Janet's psychological analysis