Humanistic integrative counselling

1. Introduction

Version followed: the three-stage skills-based model of Stafford & Bond, Counselling Skills in Action (4th ed., 2020; the successor to Culley & Bond's Integrative Counselling Skills in Action), used as the procedural spine. Erskine's Integrative Psychotherapy (Erskine & Moursund 2004/2022; Erskine 2011) supplies the relational methods of inquiry, attunement and involvement. Clarkson's five-relationship model (2003) is the map of the therapeutic relationship.

What it is. "Humanistic integrative counselling" is not one manualised therapy. It is a training tradition, mainly in the UK, that teaches a person-centred relational base and a staged process model. It then integrates methods from other humanistic sources (Gestalt, transactional analysis, body-oriented and developmental work) according to what the client needs. No single founder or treatment manual exists. This guide therefore follows the three published bodies of work named above, which are the most widely taught. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 contents; Erskine & Moursund 2022 prelims] [uncertain: how far any particular training institute's curriculum matches this combination]

How change happens. The relationship is both the context and the main mechanism of change. When relational needs go unmet, a person forms protective patterns, which Erskine calls the "life script". These patterns narrow contact with self and others. A consistently attuned, contactful therapeutic relationship lets the client notice and loosen these patterns, reintegrate split-off experience, and make new choices. Erskine defines healing as an increased capacity to move between internal and external contact. On the skills-model side, change is supported by a clear alliance (goals, tasks, bond), client-owned goals and a planned ending. [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022, Introduction pp. xviii–xx; Şahin 2019 p. 150, summarising Erskine; Erskine interview 2012/Spanish trans., pp. 116–117; Stafford & Bond 2020 ch. 4 pp. 58–59]

2. Framework

Format. Individual, usually weekly, with fixed-length sessions. Time, place, frequency, fee, cancellation, holidays and between-session contact are agreed in the contract. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 ch. 4 p. 78]

Session count. None of the sources specifies one. In UK practice, the model is delivered both as time-limited contracts (often about 6–12 sessions in agency and primary-care settings) and as open-ended work. Erskine-style work with cumulative relational trauma is described as needing a longer process. [uncertain: typical counts are synthesis from practice, not from a primary source; long-process point from Erskine interview p. 123]

Stage A: Beginning (theme: focusing and connection)

Goals: (1) establish the therapeutic alliance (Bordin's goals, tasks, bond); (2) carry out an assessment; (3) agree a working therapy contract. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 ch. 4 p. 58]
Typical length: session 1 to roughly session 3 in short-term work. Assessment continues throughout and is reviewed in supervision. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 59; length = synthesis]
Erskine's parallel: "Beginning the work" opens with a therapy contract built around four questions (see 4.19). [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 ch. 7 and Introduction p. xix]
Move on when [synthesis]: the client can name at least one priority concern in their own words; the contract (type of help, focus, practicalities, confidentiality limits) is agreed; risk has been assessed and any referral made; and the client shows enough trust to bring material without heavy testing of the relationship.

Stage B: Middle (theme: exploring and deepening)

Goals: maintain the alliance while exploring the client's issues in depth. Tools include an empathic stance, purposeful self-disclosure, here-and-now work (immediacy), and the therapist's trustworthiness and resilience under pressure. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 ch. 5 companion-site outline] [uncertain: the full text of ch. 5]
Earlier editions: Culley & Bond framed the middle stage around reassessing the problem, challenging, and keeping a focus. [uncertain: from Culley & Bond 2004/2011]
Erskine's parallel: "Moving in" means deepening awareness and working with fear and resistance. It is followed by specific interventions (experiments, enactments, regression, behavioural work, interpretation) and by explicit focus on the relationship itself (transference and countertransference). [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 contents, chs. 8–10]
Şahin's four-step sequence of Erskine's process: (1) phenomenological inquiry and validation; (2) historical inquiry that links past, present and future; (3) recognising old choices as coping, normalising them, and exploring new options, where clients may feel stuck or worse before they improve; (4) fuller contact and integration. [source: Şahin 2019 pp. 159–165, secondary]
Move on when [synthesis]: the client reports and shows change against the agreed goals or sub-goals; script beliefs are named and less automatic; the client can apply new responses outside sessions; and the relationship carries less archaic testing.

Stage C: Ending (theme: reflection and transition)

Goals: review and consolidate change, build resilience for life after therapy, and end the relationship well. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 ch. 6 companion-site outline] [uncertain: full chapter]
Erskine: termination is a phase of its own. The therapist is also changed by the relationship. [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 ch. 11; Şahin 2019 p. 165]
Earlier editions: Culley & Bond placed action planning and implementing change in the ending stage. [uncertain]
Timing: in a time-limited contract, name the ending from the start and flag it again about a third of the way before the final session. [synthesis]

Cross-cutting. The stages are not strictly linear. Misattunement and repair, and returning to earlier stage tasks (for example, re-contracting), are expected. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 pp. 58–59, 65–66]

3. Guiding principles

Empathy, not sympathy. Reflect this client's specific experience, not what people "usually" feel. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 p. 61]
Acceptance without collusion. Value the person while not agreeing with everything they say or do. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 62]
Behaviours as creative adaptations. Treat symptoms and defences as once-sensible solutions, not pathology. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 62; Erskine interview pp. 124–126 on normalization]
Genuineness. Track your own internal responses and separate them from the client's. Disclose only with a purpose. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 64; Erskine interview p. 118]
Misattunement plus repair is normal. Expect to get it wrong; repairing it is therapeutic work. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 65–66; Erskine 2011 p. 13]
Assessment is ongoing. Hold formulations provisionally, tolerate not knowing, and review them in supervision. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 59, 67–68]
Client-owned goals and shared power. Negotiate goals, tasks and practicalities rather than imposing them. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 74–78]
Therapy is not magic. Gently reality-test unrealistic hopes during contracting. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 77]
The relationship heals. Techniques add effectiveness, but the fully contactful relationship is what repairs relational wounds. [source: Erskine interview pp. 116–117]
Listen with, not just to. Observe from inside the relationship and convey empathy, don't just feel it. [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 p. xix]
Not-knowing inquiry. Assume you do not know the client's experience. Ask, so the client discovers meaning rather than receives it. [source: Erskine interview p. 117; Şahin 2019 p. 152]
Attunement first. Inquiry, validation and normalization only work when they rest on sustained affective attunement. [source: Erskine 2011 p. 14]
Respond to archaic needs; don't try to gratify them. Meet old unmet needs with attunement, acknowledgement, explanation and validation, while helping the client tell current needs from archaic ones. [source: Erskine 2011 p. 10]
Own your errors. Stay sensitive to your misattunements and take responsibility for them. [source: Erskine 2011 p. 13]
Presence and decentring. Set aside your own agenda and centre on the client's process, including silences. Stay calm when the client's affect is strong. [source: Erskine 2011 pp. 14–15; Erskine interview p. 126]
Vitality and mutual enjoyment. The relationship should have life in it, not only careful technique. [source: Erskine 2011 p. 13]
Contract and consent for everything. Nothing is done without the client's agreement and cooperation, and every exchange sits inside the contract. [source: Şahin 2019 p. 151]
Relationship before technique. Expressive, regressive or physical work happens only inside a relationship of full contact that exists before, during and after it. [source: Erskine interview p. 124]
Know which relationship is in play. Move deliberately among Clarkson's five modes (working alliance, transferential, reparative, person-to-person, transpersonal). The working alliance comes first. [source: Clarkson 2003 via Counselling Tutor]
Integrate by client need, not therapist preference. Choose a method because this client, at this point, needs it, and be able to say why. Use supervision to check integration is coherent rather than eclectic drift. [synthesis]

4. Intervention inventory

The inventory is grouped as: A. foundation skills (all stages); B. beginning-stage procedures; C. middle-stage skills; D. Erskine's relational methods; E. Erskine's specific interventions; F. relationship-mapping and ending. All example wording is illustrative unless quoted and cited.

A. Foundation skills

4.1 Expressing warmth and care

Purpose / when: to build the bond part of the alliance and help the client feel safe enough to speak. Use from the first contact onward. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 ch. 3 resource list; ch. 4 pp. 60–62]
Steps: (1) Greet the client by name and help them settle (for example, ask about their journey). (2) Keep an open, unhurried posture and voice. (3) Acknowledge any effort or courage it took to come. (4) Let warmth come through tone and attention rather than reassurance or praise.
Example language (illustrative): "It's good to meet you. Take a moment to settle; there's no rush."
Watch for: warmth sliding into rescuing or sympathy. Clients from backgrounds where warmth was a prelude to harm may mistrust it, so watch for guardedness and slow down. Working looks like the client's shoulders dropping, speech slowing and more personal disclosure. [synthesis]

4.2 Active listening and attending

Purpose / when: the base of every stage; it gathers assessment data and conveys empathy. [source: Stafford & Bond ch. 3 resources; ch. 4 p. 67]
Steps: (1) Attend to words and to non-verbal cues (tone, pace, posture, what is avoided). (2) Notice the story's structure: what is foreground, what is missing, what repeats. (3) Hold back from preparing your reply while the client speaks. (4) Use minimal encouragers and silence to let the client continue.
Example language (illustrative): "Mm… go on." / "You paused just then."
Watch for: your own urge to fix things. It is working if the client goes further without being prompted.

4.3 Reflecting, paraphrasing and summarising

Purpose / when: to check understanding and convey empathy (reflecting, paraphrasing), and to pull threads together, mark transitions, open and close sessions, and prepare for prioritising (summarising). [source: Stafford & Bond ch. 3 video 3.3 title; ch. 4 p. 61 on reflecting specific experience]
Steps: (1) Reflect: return a key word or feeling, using the client's own language where possible. (2) Paraphrase: give the core of what was said in fresh, briefer words, with tentative framing. (3) Summarise: every so often, and at session ends, gather several themes in a few sentences, then invite correction. (4) Use a summary to offer a choice of focus.
Example language (illustrative): "So you're exhausted, and underneath that there's something like resentment — is that close?" / "Let me pull together what you've said today: work, your father's illness, and not sleeping. Which feels most pressing?"
Watch for: parroting, which feels mechanical, and summaries that slip in your interpretation. It is working when the client corrects or extends your reflection; that shows they are engaged, not just agreeing.

4.4 Open-ended questions and probing statements

Purpose / when: to open areas for exploration and get concrete detail. [source: Stafford & Bond ch. 3 video 3.4 title] [uncertain: Culley & Bond's grouping of questions and statements as "probing skills" is from earlier editions]
Steps: (1) Prefer "what / how / when" over "why", which can feel accusatory. (2) Ask one question at a time. (3) Use a statement form when questions start to feel like an interrogation. (4) Ask for a specific instance rather than a generalisation.
Example language (illustrative): "What happens in you when he raises his voice?" / "Tell me about the last time that happened."
Watch for: strings of questions, or closed questions that steer the client. It is working when vague accounts become concrete, with episodes, feelings and meanings.

B. Beginning-stage procedures

4.5 Pre-session preparation and first-contact listening

Purpose / when: to prepare the ground before the first session. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 pp. 79–80, 83–84]
Steps: (1) Note your own expectations and fantasies about the client, including those raised by referral information. (2) At first contact (phone or email), listen to how the client speaks and what they ask. (3) Where it helps, give a light pre-session task, such as noticing when they feel stressed. (4) Run through a pre-session checklist covering room, time, paperwork and your own state.
Example language (illustrative): "Before we meet, you might jot down any moments this week when the anxiety spikes — only if that's useful."
Watch for: referral labels shaping your view before you meet.

4.6 Structuring the first session

Purpose / when: session 1, to give safety through clarity. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 80–82]
Steps: (1) Welcome and settle the client. (2) Outline the session's structure, time boundary and aims. (3) Mention any referral information or prior contact openly. (4) Invite the client to begin in their own words, with specific prompts if they are unsure. (5) Explain how you work in plain, jargon-free terms. (6) Agree a provisional agenda, broad aim and interim sub-goals. (7) Give a time warning, confirm the next session, agree where to start next time and any interim task.
Example language (illustrative): "We have fifty minutes. I'd like to hear what brings you, tell you a bit about how I work, and toward the end we'll see whether this feels right and what we'd focus on." / "We've about ten minutes left."
Watch for: front-loading admin so much that the client never gets to speak, or the reverse: a session with no frame. A poor first session is one where you confront too early. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 82]

4.7 Five-area assessment

Purpose / when: to understand the client and decide whether and how you can help. Do it formally in the beginning stage and keep it under review afterwards. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 66–71]
Steps: cover five areas, using a mix of narrative listening, a semi-structured interview, observation, intuition and, if you use them, questionnaires:
1. Presenting issue: its meaning to the client, the beliefs around it and its impact. Tolerate not knowing rather than rushing to define the problem.
2. Context: culture, circumstances, supports, resources, coping and relevant history.
3. Motivation: why now, expectations, previous attempts, and signs of self-sabotage.
4. Risk: whether the client is in an at-risk group, their stress level and protective factors (see 4.8).
5. Your competence: the knowledge and skills needed, your limits, personal factors and the client's preferences.
Example language (illustrative): "What made now the time to come?" / "Who or what helps when things are hard?" / "What have you tried already, and what happened?"
Watch for: assessment turning into a checklist that breaks contact. Weave it into the conversation. It is working when you can write a short provisional formulation and the client recognises themselves in your summary.

4.8 Risk assessment and onward referral

Purpose / when: at assessment and whenever risk indicators appear. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 68–70]
Steps: (1) Ask directly and calmly about thoughts of self-harm or suicide, harm to others, and harm from others. (2) Explore current intent and plans, past history, stressors and protective factors, following your service's risk policy and current standard practice. Where suicide risk is present, agree a collaborative safety plan, including means safety (restricting access and safe storage), and the limits of confidentiality. (3) Suggest a medical or psychiatric referral for unexplained physical symptoms, persistent anxiety or depression, self-harm or suicidal ideation, without implying the client is "ill". (4) Record and take it to supervision. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 68; safety-planning detail = synthesis from standard practice]
Example language (illustrative): "Sometimes when people feel this low they think about ending their life. Has that been in your mind?"
Watch for: avoiding the question for fear of breaking rapport. Asking directly does not put the idea in someone's head, and it usually brings relief.

4.9 Contracting

Purpose / when: to set up the working alliance and the frame; done in the beginning stage and revisited when the work shifts. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 72–78]
Steps: cover three components:
1. Type of help: what counselling is and is not, the nature of the relationship, its boundaries, and the limits of confidentiality. Explain the "circle of confidentiality", for example supervisor and administrative staff.
2. Focus, process and direction: the goals (see 4.10) and the tasks (see 4.11).
3. Practicalities: time, place, frequency, fee, cancellations, holidays and contact between sessions. Negotiate rather than impose terms, and name the power imbalance.
Example language (illustrative): "What you say here stays between us and my supervisor, except where I'm seriously worried about your safety or someone else's — then I'd talk with you first wherever I can."
Watch for: the client agreeing to everything (which may be compliance). Check: "Is there anything in that you'd want to change?"

4.10 Goal setting and prioritisation

Purpose / when: to give the work direction; set goals during contracting and review them in the middle stage. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 74–77]
Steps: (1) Help the client state goals in their own words, without imposing them. (2) Test the goals against SMART criteria (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, timely). (3) If there are several concerns, prioritise using four questions: which hurts most, which would make the biggest positive difference, which could be dealt with quickly, and which needs another service. (4) Break a broad aim into interim sub-goals. (5) Gently reality-test miracle expectations; Stafford & Bond's example therapist says "therapy can't turn miracles" (p. 77).
Example language (illustrative): "If things were a bit better in six weeks, what would you notice first?"
Watch for: goals that belong to someone else, such as a partner or an employer, and "dead person" goals (not doing something). Reframe these as something the client would be doing. [synthesis] It is working when the client refers back to the goals on their own.

4.11 Agreeing tasks and ways of working

Purpose / when: to agree how you will work together. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 76]
Steps: agree who leads (client-led or more structured), how directive you will be, how much challenge the client wants, and whether there will be any between-session tasks or reflection. Revisit this if the work feels stuck.
Example language (illustrative): "Some people like me to stay quiet and follow; others want me to push a bit. What suits you?"
Watch for: a mismatch between the stated preference and the client's actual response, for example asking for challenge and then withdrawing when challenged. Name it collaboratively (4.14).

4.12 Exploring expectations and fantasies about therapy

Purpose / when: first sessions, to bring hidden expectations into the open. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 79]
Steps: ask what the client imagined therapy and the therapist would be like, what others have told them, and what they fear or hope. Correct misconceptions and note hopes as material for goals.
Example language (illustrative): "What did you imagine coming here would be like?"
Watch for: expectations of advice or diagnosis, which can lead to disappointment and dropout if they go unnamed. [synthesis]

C. Middle-stage skills

4.13 Sustained empathic stance (exploring and deepening)

Purpose / when: the main way of deepening exploration in the middle stage. [source: Stafford & Bond 2020 ch. 5 video 5.1 title; ch. 4 pp. 60–61] [uncertain: ch. 5 text]
Steps: (1) Follow the client's most alive edge: the feeling or meaning that has energy. (2) Reflect at a slightly deeper level than the client has put into words (implicit feeling, unspoken meaning), offered tentatively. (3) Stay with one theme long enough for it to unfold rather than moving across many topics. (4) Check whether the client wants to go further.
Example language (illustrative): "You say it's 'fine' that she left, but your voice dropped. I wonder if something about it isn't fine at all."
Watch for: going deeper than the client can bear. Signs include going blank, intellectualising or changing the subject; then return to safer ground (4.24). It is working when the client brings new material or makes new connections.

4.14 Immediacy: bringing things into the here-and-now

Purpose / when: to work with the client's in-the-moment experience and with what is happening between you. Use it when a pattern from outside seems to be appearing in the room, or when the alliance feels strained. [source: Stafford & Bond ch. 5 video 5.3 description; Erskine interview p. 119 on transference in current relationships]
Steps: (1) Notice a shift in the room: in the client, in you, or between you. (2) Name it tentatively and descriptively, without blame. (3) Invite the client's experience of it. (4) Explore any link to their wider relational patterns, only if the client is curious. (5) Thank them for engaging.
Example language (illustrative): "Right now, as you tell me this, what's happening inside you?" / "I notice we've both gone quite careful in the last few minutes. How is it for you, talking with me about this?"
Watch for: immediacy used to vent your own feelings, or timed so it shames the client. It is working when the relationship becomes a live place to explore and try out patterns.

4.15 Purposeful self-disclosure

Purpose / when: to deepen genuineness, normalise, or model; use sparingly. [source: Stafford & Bond ch. 5 description and video 5.2; ch. 4 p. 64]
Steps: before disclosing, ask yourself: Whose need does this meet? Is it brief? Will it bring the focus back to the client? Then (1) disclose briefly, either your here-and-now response or, more rarely, relevant personal experience; (2) return the focus to the client at once; (3) later, check how it landed.
Example language (illustrative): "I felt moved hearing that." / "I know a little of what a long illness in the family does to everyone. How has it been for you?"
Watch for: frequent or lengthy disclosure, and disclosure that invites the client to look after you. It is working when the client feels less alone and goes on with their own material.

4.16 Challenging

Purpose / when: to invite the client to notice discrepancies, blind spots, unhelpful beliefs or unused strengths. Use it only once the alliance is established and the client has agreed to a level of challenge (4.11). [uncertain: challenging is a named stage-two skill in Culley & Bond's earlier editions; the 2020 edition's treatment is not drawn on; Stafford & Bond p. 82 warns against confronting in a first session]
Steps: (1) Ground the challenge in the client's own words or goals. (2) Describe the discrepancy rather than judging it ("on the one hand… on the other…"). (3) Offer it tentatively and invite the client's view. (4) Follow with empathy for how it landed. (5) Point out strengths and resources as well as problems.
Example language (illustrative): "You've said you want more closeness with your sister, and you've also said you've stopped answering her calls. How do those fit together for you?"
Watch for: shame responses such as averted gaze, collapse or a sudden flash of anger. These call for repair (4.39). It is working when the client takes the challenge up and reflects on it rather than complying or defending.

4.17 Reviewing and reassessing

Purpose / when: to keep the work aligned with the contract. Do it at agreed points (for example every 4–6 sessions) and whenever progress stalls. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 59, 67 (assessment is ongoing)] [synthesis: review interval]
Steps: (1) Revisit the goals and sub-goals. (2) Ask what has changed, what hasn't, and what has emerged that you had not foreseen. (3) Re-prioritise and re-contract the focus or tasks if needed. (4) If the problem now looks different, for example new risk or a different underlying issue, reconsider your competence and referral (4.7).
Example language (illustrative): "We're halfway through our twelve sessions. Shall we look at where you are with what you came for?"
Watch for: reviews done only by you. It is working when the client contributes their own judgement of progress.

4.18 Trustworthiness and resilience under testing

Purpose / when: when a client unconsciously tests whether the therapist will repeat an old relationship, for example through lateness, provocation, withdrawal or idealisation. [source: Stafford & Bond ch. 5 videos 5.4–5.5 titles; Erskine interview p. 119 on clients testing whether the current relationship repeats childhood] [uncertain: Stafford & Bond's text on this]
Steps: (1) Keep the frame steady (time, boundaries, consistency). (2) Don't retaliate or withdraw. (3) Stay curious about what the behaviour communicates. (4) When the alliance can hold it, name the pattern with immediacy (4.14) and link it to the client's history (4.21).
Example language (illustrative): "I'm still here, and I'm still interested. I wonder if part of you expects me to give up on you."
Watch for: your own countertransference (irritation, rescuing). Take it to supervision. It is working when the testing lessens and the client risks more openness.

D. Erskine's relational methods: inquiry, attunement, involvement

Erskine pictures these as a "keyhole": attunement is the foundation, with inquiry and involvement on either side, and the client's contact interruptions are the focus in the middle. [source: Şahin 2019 pp. 152–153, secondary]

4.19 The four contract questions

Purpose / when: to open "Beginning the work" in Erskine's integrative psychotherapy; they fit alongside 4.9–4.10. [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 p. xix]
Steps: across the first sessions, work through four questions, which Erskine & Moursund give as: "How are you?"; "How would you like things to be different?"; "How did things get to be the way they are?"; and "How will we know when you have accomplished your goals?" Answer them together, as part of the conversation rather than as a form.
Watch for: the third question turning into an intellectual history. Keep it tied to felt experience.

4.20 Phenomenological inquiry

Purpose / when: to help the client become aware of present experience (sensations, feelings, beliefs, fantasies, expectations, emerging memories). It is the usual starting point and runs throughout. [source: Erskine interview p. 117; Şahin 2019 pp. 152, 159]
Steps: (1) Take a not-knowing position. (2) Ask open, respectful questions about what is happening now, in the body, in feeling and in thought. (3) Follow each answer with the next layer down (sensation, then feeling, then meaning). (4) Let the client discover rather than confirm your hypothesis. (5) Pace the questions to the client's rhythm (4.24).
Example language: Şahin renders Erskine's typical questions in Turkish; in English they amount to "What's happening for you right now?" and "What are you experiencing?" (illustrative rendering). Further: "Where do you feel that?" / "And as you notice the tightness, what comes with it?" (illustrative)
Watch for: inquiry that feels like interrogation; it must rest on attunement (Erskine 2011 p. 14). It is working when the client's awareness widens and they report experience they had not noticed before.

4.21 Historical inquiry

Purpose / when: to connect present reactions with past relational experience and with feared or hoped-for futures. Use it once present experience is well in focus. [source: Şahin 2019 pp. 152, 159–160; Erskine interview pp. 121–122 (Conrad case)]
Steps: (1) From a present feeling or reaction, ask when it is familiar from. (2) Treat strong hopes and fears as echoes of the past that invite this question. (3) Follow the emerging memory in its sensory and emotional detail, not only the facts. (4) Ask what the client concluded about self, others and life at that time.
Example language (illustrative): "When have you felt this small before?" / "What did that boy decide about asking for help?"
Watch for: flooding. If arousal climbs steeply, slow down, ground, and return to the present (4.24). It is working when present reactions start to make sense to the client as understandable continuations of the past.

4.22 Inquiry into coping, choices and vulnerability

Purpose / when: to bring into awareness the decisions and coping strategies (often made outside adult awareness) that keep the script going. [source: Şahin 2019 pp. 159–160, 164; Erskine interview pp. 119–121 on script levels]
Steps: (1) Ask how the client managed back then, and what they did with the feeling. (2) Identify the protective function of the strategy. (3) Distinguish its three levels. Erskine describes the script at three levels: explicit decisions (conscious conclusions that can be put into words); implicit experiential conclusions (pre-verbal, built from many small relational events); and physiological survival reactions (bodily tension, holding back). (4) Explore what the strategy costs now. (5) Attend to the fragility that surfaces when protections loosen.
Example language (illustrative): "What did you do with all that fear when there was no one to tell?" / "Keeping quiet kept you safe then. What does it cost you now?"
Watch for: the client feeling stuck or worse at this point. Şahin notes this is expected (p. 162). It is working when coping is seen as a choice that can be revised rather than as "who I am".

4.23 Affective attunement

Purpose / when: to respond to the client's emotion with a reciprocal emotion, not just to name it. Use it constantly. [source: Erskine interview p. 118; Şahin 2019 pp. 153–157]
Steps: match the response to the affect: sadness is met with compassion, fear with protection and safety, anger by taking it seriously, and joy with shared vitality. Let your response be genuine, not a technique.
Example language (illustrative): with fear: "You're safe here with me right now. Take your time." With anger: "That was wrong, what was done to you."
Watch for: performing emotion you don't feel; clients detect it. It is working when the client's affect is able to complete (tears flow, then ease) rather than being suppressed.

4.24 Rhythmic attunement

Purpose / when: to match the client's internal pace, which differs between clients and changes within a session. [source: Erskine interview p. 118; Şahin p. 155]
Steps: (1) Notice the client's tempo of speech, thought and feeling. (2) Slow down to it, often by leaving longer silences. (3) Once you are matched, help the client find their own rhythm. (4) Slow down further when emotional material needs integrating.
Example language (illustrative): "There's no hurry. Let's just stay with this a moment."
Watch for: your own urge to fill silence. It is working when the client's processing deepens during the pauses.

4.25 Developmental attunement

Purpose / when: to recognise when the client is experiencing from an earlier age (regression) and respond as a capable adult would to a child of that age. [source: Erskine interview pp. 118–119; Şahin pp. 154–155]
Steps: (1) Notice cues of an age shift, such as voice, vocabulary, posture or a sense of smallness. (2) Gauge roughly what age is present. (3) Simplify your language, add warmth and protection, and speak to the younger part while keeping the adult self engaged. (4) Help the client return to the adult self before the session ends.
Example language (illustrative): "It sounds like a very little part of you is here now. I'm here too. And you, the grown-up you, can hear me as well."
Watch for: losing the adult connection, which leads to disorientation at the end of the session. It is working when the client can tolerate young feelings while staying oriented.

4.26 Cognitive attunement

Purpose / when: to track how the client reasons and the core beliefs and meanings that organise their experience. [source: Erskine interview p. 119; Şahin p. 155]
Steps: (1) Listen for script beliefs; Erskine's example amounts to "you can't trust people". (2) Meet the client in their way of thinking (logical, associative, concrete) before offering anything different. (3) Reflect the belief and its logic so the client can see it.
Example language (illustrative): "So if you let anyone close, the logic is they'll eventually let you down — and that's been true more often than not."
Watch for: debating the belief too early. It is working when the client can step back and observe the belief.

4.27 Attunement to relational needs

Purpose / when: to recognise which relational need is in the foreground and respond to it. [source: Erskine 2011 pp. 10, 13–14]
The eight needs (Erskine 2011, p. 13): security; validation, affirmation and significance; acceptance by a stable, dependable, protective other; confirmation of personal experience; self-definition; having an impact on the other; having the other initiate; expressing love.
Steps: (1) Notice the need that is being sought or frustrated in the client's narrative and in the room. (2) Respond in a way that acknowledges and honours it. For example: provide consistency and protection for security; show you share or understand the experience for confirmation; respect difference and disagreement for self-definition; let yourself be visibly affected for impact; reach out first sometimes for initiation; receive gratitude or affection graciously for expressing love. (3) Help the client distinguish a present need from an archaic, unmet one. (4) Respond to archaic needs with acknowledgement, explanation and validation rather than trying to gratify them. [source: Erskine 2011 p. 10; the mapping of responses to individual needs is synthesis, since the article does not specify it]
Example language (illustrative, impact): "What you just said really reached me."
Watch for: promising to meet needs the relationship cannot meet, for example unlimited availability. It is working when the client can name their needs and seek them in current relationships.

4.28 Acknowledgement (recognition)

Purpose / when: to recognise each verbal and non-verbal communication, and the needs and feelings within it. [source: Erskine interview pp. 124–126; Erskine 2011 p. 10]
Steps: notice and name, briefly, what the client communicates, including gestures, silences and tone.
Example language (illustrative): "Your hand went to your chest just then."
Watch for: over-commenting on the body, which can feel exposing.

4.29 Validation

Purpose / when: to affirm that the client's feelings, thoughts, fantasies and behaviour have meaning and a cause, even when they seem senseless. [source: Erskine interview p. 125; Şahin 2019 p. 160]
Steps: (1) Link the reaction to its cause or context. (2) Say that it makes sense. (3) Don't argue or reassure.
Example language (illustrative): "Of course you freeze when voices are raised — that's what kept you safe in that house."
Watch for: validating the experience versus endorsing harmful behaviour. Keep the two separate. [synthesis]

4.30 Normalization

Purpose / when: to reframe old defensive conclusions as normal responses to abnormal situations, and to remove pathologising labels. [source: Erskine interview pp. 125–126; Şahin 2019 pp. 161–162]
Steps: (1) Identify the client's self-pathologising ("I'm crazy", "I'm broken"). (2) Place the reaction in its original context. (3) Convey that it was the best choice available then. Şahin notes this works better than simple reassurance.
Example language (illustrative): "Anyone who grew up never knowing which mood would walk through the door would become watchful. That's not madness; it's adaptation."
Watch for: normalising so quickly that the client's distress feels dismissed.

4.31 Presence

Purpose / when: the overall quality of involvement: the therapist's attitude, behaviour and communication respect and enhance the client's integrity. [source: Erskine 2011 pp. 14–15; Erskine interview p. 126]
Steps: (1) Decentre from your own aims and needs. (2) Stay receptive to strong affect without becoming anxious, depressed or angry. (3) Periodically use vicarious introspection (Kohut) to sense what it is like to be the client, and let that guide your next inquiry. (4) Use your own reactions, history and knowledge as part of your presence.
Example language: mostly non-verbal; steady attention and calm. (illustrative) "I'm with you."
Watch for: fatigue or burnout eroding presence; this is a self-care and supervision issue.

E. Erskine's specific interventions

Erskine & Moursund list these as the interventions of Integrative Psychotherapy (ch. 9). Only their names and one-line descriptions are drawn on, so the step detail below is drawn from the interview case material where noted, and otherwise marked [synthesis]. All of them sit inside an already-established, fully contactful relationship (Erskine interview p. 124).

4.32 Experiments and enactments

Purpose / when: to test script beliefs in the safety of the relationship, for example trying a new behaviour or expressing something never said. Use in the middle stage, once a script belief is clearly named. [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 pp. xx, 176]
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Name the belief to test ("if I say no, I'll be abandoned"). (2) Design a small in-session experiment with the client, such as saying no to the therapist about something minor. (3) Get explicit consent and agree a stop signal. (4) Do it, then use phenomenological inquiry (4.20) on what happened. (5) Compare the outcome with the prediction. (6) Consider a version to try outside the session.
Example language (illustrative): "Would you be willing to try something? Tell me one thing you don't like about how we've been working, and let's both notice what happens."
Watch for: experiments that are too big and confirm the old belief. It is working when the client experiences a different outcome from the one the script predicts.

4.33 Supported regression

Purpose / when: to reach walled-off memories, feelings and beliefs from earlier ages, so that reparative relational experience and new decisions can happen there. Erskine is clear that regression is not always needed. [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 pp. xx, 179; Erskine interview p. 119; Şahin 2019 pp. 154–155]
Contraindications and safety [synthesis from standard trauma-informed practice; uncertain how Erskine screens]: avoid it with clients who have limited capacity to stay grounded (frequent dissociation, psychosis, current crisis, active self-harm or substance misuse) and early in therapy. Obtain explicit consent. Leave enough session time to reorient. Seek specialist training and supervision.
Steps: (1) Follow a present feeling or bodily sensation back toward its earliest felt version (4.21). (2) Use imagery: "be there" in the scene, in the present tense, keeping the adult self in contact. (3) Attune developmentally (4.25) and provide the protective, attuned responses the child lacked; the therapist is a protective presence. (4) Allow unexpressed feelings and needs to be voiced. (5) Make sure the client returns fully to the adult self, and spend time integrating meaning. In the Conrad case, phenomenological inquiry led to a memory at age five, and imagery let him speak to his mother from that scene. [source: Erskine interview pp. 121–122]
Example language (illustrative): "Let yourself be five again, in the tree. What do you see? What do you want to say to her?" and at the end "Now come back to this room, today, with me. Feel the chair under you."
Watch for: dissociation, panic, loss of adult contact, and fragile states that persist after the session. Stop, ground and reorient. It is working when affect completes and new meaning emerges without the client being retraumatised.

4.34 Redecision

Purpose / when: to revise an explicit childhood decision (for example "I'm not good enough") once its origin has been felt. Erskine places this at the level of explicit decisions, drawing on the Gouldings' redecision work. [source: Erskine interview pp. 119–122]
Steps (based on the Conrad case): (1) Identify the decision and the scene in which it was made. (2) Re-experience the scene with the affect it carried, such as anger or grief. (3) Express directly, within the imagery, what was not said. (4) Invite the client to make a new decision from their current resources. (5) Anchor it with concrete changes in current life. Conrad decided to feel his own feelings, meet his own needs, and be a child rather than a parent to his mother.
Example language (illustrative): "Knowing what you know now, what do you decide for yourself?"
Watch for: a redecision that is only intellectual. Erskine notes that implicit and bodily levels of the script need relational and physiological work too, so a single cognitive redecision is not enough. It is working when the new decision changes behaviour and bodily state over the following weeks.

4.35 Physiological and body-oriented work

Purpose / when: to address the physiological level of the script, such as chronic muscular tension and holding back, and to support affect expression. [source: Erskine interview pp. 120, 123–124; Erskine & Moursund 2022 p. xx]
Steps: (1) Inquire into bodily sensation (4.20). (2) Use metaphor and gentle activity, for example inviting the client to place their own hand where it hurts, to imagine supportive holding, or to locate anger in the body and let it move. Erskine also describes bioenergetic exercises. (3) Explore what the body expresses. Erskine uses direct touch only selectively, for example holding during pre-verbal regression, and only inside an established relationship.
Safety [synthesis]: in most counselling settings, do not use therapeutic touch unless you are specifically trained, your service permits it, and you have explicit, revocable consent discussed in advance, with supervision. Choose client-controlled alternatives (self-touch, imagery) by default.
Example language (illustrative): "Would you put your hand where you feel that ache? What does it want?"
Watch for: touch being experienced as intrusive, sexualised or coercive, especially by clients who have been abused. It is working when bodily tension lets go and comes with emotional meaning.

4.36 Transference and countertransference work

Purpose / when: to recognise and work with archaic relational patterns brought into the therapy or into current relationships, and with the therapist's own reactions. Erskine treats the relationship itself as a focus of a whole phase. [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 p. xviii, ch. 10; Erskine interview pp. 119, 122–123; Clarkson 2003 via Counselling Tutor]
Steps: (1) Notice the signs: reactions out of proportion, a sense of being cast in a role, and your own unusual feelings. (2) Use supervision to separate your own material from what the client is inducing. (3) Explore it with immediacy (4.14) and historical inquiry (4.21). (4) Hold the focus on the transference for as long as needed before turning to early memories; Erskine describes doing this for a long period with one client. (5) Look for the same pattern with bosses, partners and children, where Erskine says it most often appears.
Example language (illustrative): "When I was five minutes late, it seemed to land very hard. Does it remind you of anything?"
Watch for: over-interpreting everything as transference, which invalidates real therapist errors (see 4.39).

4.37 Interpretation

Purpose / when: to offer a meaning that links experience, history and pattern. Erskine & Moursund list it among the interventions (ch. 9, p. 172). [uncertain: the chapter text is not drawn on]
Steps [synthesis consistent with the not-knowing stance]: offer it tentatively, after inquiry has brought most of the material to awareness; invite correction; prefer the client's own interpretation.
Example language (illustrative): "I wonder if being the 'sensible one' was how you kept your mother steady."
Watch for: imposing meaning, or an interpretation landing as criticism.

4.38 Behavioural interventions

Purpose / when: to choose concrete behaviour changes that build on the client's strengths while challenging script patterns. Use from the middle stage, and especially in the ending stage. [source: Erskine & Moursund 2022 pp. xx, 187]
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Identify a script-driven behaviour, such as over-functioning. (2) Choose a strength to draw on. (3) Agree a small, specific alternative behaviour to practise between sessions. (4) Review what happened, using inquiry rather than grading.
Example language (illustrative): "This week, would you try asking your partner for one thing, and notice what happens inside you when you do?"
Watch for: tasks set by the therapist that the client complies with to please (a script pattern in itself).

4.39 Repairing therapist errors and misattunements

Purpose / when: whenever you notice, or suspect, that you have misattuned, hurt or failed the client. [source: Erskine 2011 p. 13; Erskine interview pp. 122–123; Stafford & Bond pp. 65–66]
Steps: (1) Notice the signs: withdrawal, sudden politeness, anger, missed sessions, or a drop in energy. (2) Raise it yourself. (3) Take responsibility for your part, without excessive self-blame that the client then has to manage. (4) Inquire into the client's experience of it, including any links to the past. (5) Thank the client and keep the repair going over the following sessions.
Example language (illustrative): "Last week I moved on too quickly when you mentioned your brother. I think I missed something important. How was that for you?"
Watch for: defending yourself, or interpreting the client's reaction as "only transference". It is working when the client feels able to complain and still be met. That experience is reparative in itself.

F. Relationship mapping and ending

4.40 Using Clarkson's five-relationship model

Purpose / when: to map which relational mode is in the foreground, and which is needed, at any point. [source: Clarkson 2003 via Counselling Tutor, secondary]
The five modes: (1) Working alliance: cooperation based on the contract, which must be established first. (2) Transferential and countertransferential: unconscious wishes and fears transferred onto the relationship. (3) Reparative or developmentally needed: the therapist intentionally provides what was missing in development, a parent-like support that fades as the client trusts their own judgement. (4) Person-to-person: a genuine, I–Thou human connection (Rogers, Buber). (5) Transpersonal: the spiritual, "timeless facet" of the healing relationship (Clarkson 2003, p. 187).
Steps [synthesis]: after each session, or when stuck, ask yourself: Which mode were we mostly in? Which does the client need now? Is the working alliance intact? Then consciously shift. For example, repair the alliance before working with transference, or offer person-to-person contact when a client feels like an object of technique.
Watch for: the reparative mode creating dependency or blurring boundaries. Plan with the client how support will be faded [synthesis].

4.41 Reviewing and consolidating change (ending stage)

Purpose / when: in the ending stage, to reflect on what has changed and build resilience for after therapy. [source: Stafford & Bond ch. 6 title and video 6.1 “Resilience”] [uncertain: chapter text is not drawn on; steps are synthesis]
Steps: (1) Revisit the original goals and the four contract questions (4.19). (2) Invite the client to describe changes in their own words, and how they made them. (3) Identify early warning signs of slipping back into old patterns and the client's resources and supports. (4) Name what remains unfinished, without treating it as failure.
Example language (illustrative): "Looking back to when you first came, what's different? What did you do that made that happen?"
Watch for: the client crediting only the therapist. Redirect them to their own agency.

4.42 Action planning for transition

Purpose / when: to turn insight into planned change beyond therapy. [uncertain: action planning is part of the ending stage in Culley & Bond's earlier editions; steps are synthesis]
Steps: (1) Choose one or two priority changes. (2) Generate options with the client. (3) Weigh the supports and obstacles. (4) Agree concrete first steps and how the client will keep them going after therapy.
Example language (illustrative): "What will help you keep saying no when you need to, once we're not meeting?"
Watch for: plans that are too ambitious or are written for the therapist.

4.43 Ending the counselling relationship

Purpose / when: planned endings, to end the relationship as a meaningful relational experience in itself, especially for clients with histories of abrupt loss. [source: Stafford & Bond ch. 6 videos 6.2–6.3 titles; Erskine & Moursund 2022 ch. 11] [uncertain: chapter text is not drawn on; steps are synthesis]
Steps: (1) Name the ending well in advance, and keep returning to it. (2) Explore the client's feelings about it and their history of endings; expect old loss feelings and a temporary return of symptoms. (3) Acknowledge what the relationship has meant, including, briefly and genuinely, what it has meant to you. (4) Agree arrangements after therapy (whether and how the client can return) according to your service's policy. (5) In the final session, review, say goodbye and mark the ending.
Example language (illustrative): "We have four sessions left. I'd like us to give some time to how it is to be ending." / "I've valued working with you."
Watch for: missed final sessions (avoiding the goodbye), and the therapist extending the work for their own reasons. Take both to supervision.

5. Handling problems

Stuck client: diagnose where contact is interrupted. Şahin, summarising Erskine, describes interruptions at four levels: (1) whether a problem exists at all; (2) whether it matters; (3) whether it can be solved; (4) the worth of the self. Locate which level the client is at and work there. Don't push solutions (level 3) when the client still minimises the problem (levels 1–2), and don't argue against a negative self-definition (level 4); attune and validate instead. [source: Şahin 2019 pp. 157–160, secondary] Also check: the goals may not be the client's own (4.10), the tasks may be mismatched (4.11), or you may be in the wrong relational mode (4.40). Review and re-contract (4.17). [synthesis] Şahin notes that clients may feel stuck or worse while old choices are being re-examined. Say this in advance, so it isn't read as failure. [source: Şahin p. 162]

Resistance. Treat it as protection with a history, a creative adaptation, rather than opposition. [source: Stafford & Bond p. 62; Erskine interview pp. 124–126] Responses: inquire into what the protection guards against (4.22); normalise it (4.30); slow down (4.24); and check whether you have pushed ahead of the client's rhythm or misattuned, then repair (4.39). Erskine & Moursund address fear and resistance in the "Moving in" phase (ch. 8), but the chapter is not drawn on. [uncertain]

Overwhelm, flooding and dissociation. Signs include rapid breathing, glazed eyes, a loss of words, and a sense of the client being "far away". Response [synthesis, consistent with Erskine's rhythmic and developmental attunement]: (1) Slow right down and lower your voice. (2) Orient the client to the present: the room, the date, feet on the floor, your voice. (3) Speak to the adult self (4.25). (4) Hold off on historical inquiry or regression until the client can stay grounded. (5) Afterwards, review together what helped and agree a stop signal for next time. Clients with cumulative relational trauma need a longer relational phase before deeper work. [source: Erskine interview p. 123] If dissociation is frequent, assess further and consider specialist referral. [synthesis]

Non-adherence (missed sessions, lateness, tasks not done). First check the contract and practicalities (4.9). Then explore the meaning without blaming: it may be testing (4.18), avoidance of a painful topic or of the ending, or a practical barrier. Use immediacy (4.14). Don't treat a task left undone as failure; inquire into what happened when the client thought about doing it (4.20). Keep cancellation terms consistent but humane. [synthesis; frame elements from Stafford & Bond p. 78]

Ruptures in the alliance. Two kinds: withdrawal ruptures (compliance, going quiet, "everything's fine") and confrontation ruptures (complaint, anger). Stafford & Bond treat misattunement and repair as a normal process, and Erskine treats the therapist's responsibility for errors as a core component of presence. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 65–66; Erskine 2011 p. 13] Response: use the repair sequence in 4.39. Prioritise the working alliance (Clarkson's first mode) before any other work. Don't interpret the rupture purely as transference until you have owned your own contribution. [synthesis] The withdrawal/confrontation distinction comes from the wider alliance-rupture literature (Safran & Muran), not from the sources here. [uncertain]

Shame. Shame often appears after challenge, disclosure or regression. Signs are averted gaze, collapse, self-attack, or sudden anger. Response [synthesis; the sources give no procedure, though shame features in Erskine's Conrad case]: stop challenging; attune affectively with protection and acceptance (4.23); validate and normalise what was exposed (4.29–4.30); acknowledge any part your intervention played; and later, gently inquire into the shame's origin.

The client wants advice, a diagnosis or a technique-led therapy. Explore their expectations (4.12). Explain how you work in plain terms (4.6). Agree how directive you will be (4.11). If the client clearly needs a structured or specialist protocol, consider referral; Stafford & Bond's competence area of assessment covers this (pp. 70–71). [source + synthesis]

Dependency in the reparative relationship. The reparative mode is meant to fade as the client trusts their own judgement. [source: Clarkson via Counselling Tutor] Erskine stresses responding to archaic needs with acknowledgement and validation rather than trying to gratify them. [source: Erskine 2011 p. 10] Response [synthesis]: keep firm boundaries on between-session contact (4.9); help the client distinguish a present need from an archaic one; build supports outside therapy; plan the ending early (4.43).

Regression or body work going beyond safe limits. Stop, reorient the client and reduce intensity. Revisit consent. Don't resume until stabilisation and supervision are in place. Don't use touch without specific training, service permission and explicit consent agreed beforehand. Erskine himself uses touch selectively and only within an established relationship. [source: Erskine interview pp. 123–124; safety stance = synthesis]

Integration drifting into eclecticism. This is a modality-specific risk: techniques get chosen by habit, mood or novelty. Response [synthesis]: before using a method, name to yourself (and to the client, where it helps) which need or script level it addresses. Keep the stage aims and the relational methods as your organising frame. Review in supervision whether your interventions form a coherent pattern.

Therapist countertransference (irritation, rescuing, boredom, over-involvement). Treat it as data and process it in supervision. Use it in presence (Erskine 2011 p. 15) rather than acting it out. Recheck which relational mode you have slipped into (4.40). [source + synthesis]

Risk emerging mid-therapy. Pause the exploratory work and assess risk directly (4.8). Agree a safety plan, including means safety, and use the confidentiality limits agreed in the contract, consulting and referring as needed. Resume deeper work only once the client is stable. [source: Stafford & Bond pp. 68–70; procedure = synthesis from standard practice]

Cultural misattunement. Assessment of context includes culture (Stafford & Bond pp. 68–69). Response [synthesis]: ask about the client's cultural meanings of the problem, of help-seeking and of emotional expression, rather than assuming them. Treat cultural misattunements as ruptures to repair (4.39). Adjust affective attunement to the client's norms of expression.

Endings that go wrong (a missed last session, an abrupt dropout). Where your service allows, send a brief, warm written ending that acknowledges the work and leaves the door open according to policy. Reflect in supervision on what the ending might have repeated. [synthesis]

Sources

Sources:

Books cited:

Stafford, M. R. & Bond, T. (2020). Counselling Skills in Action (4th ed.). SAGE. (Chapter 4; other chapters known by title only.)
Culley, S. & Bond, T. (2004; 2nd ed. 2011). Integrative Counselling Skills in Action. SAGE. (Not drawn on; points from it are marked [uncertain].)
Erskine, R. G. & Moursund, J. P. (2004; reissued 2022). Integrative Psychotherapy: The Art and Science of Relationship. (Prelims only.)
Erskine, R. G., Moursund, J. P. & Trautmann, R. L. (1999). Beyond Empathy: A Therapy of Contact-in-Relationship. Brunner/Mazel. (Not drawn on.)
Erskine, R. G. (2021). A Healing Relationship: Commentary on Therapeutic Dialogues. Phoenix. (Front matter only.)
Clarkson, P. (2003). The Therapeutic Relationship (2nd ed.). Whurr. (Known via secondary source.)
Bordin, E. S. (1979). The generalizability of the psychoanalytic concept of the working alliance. (As cited by Stafford & Bond.)
Kohut, H. (1977). The Restoration of the Self. (As cited by Erskine for vicarious introspection.)

← Previous · III-030Motivational enhancement therapy Next · III-032 →Plantão psicológico