Magic-trick hand therapy (Breathe Magic)

1. Introduction

Version followed: the Breathe Magic Intensive Therapy Programme (BMITP) as Breathe Arts Health Research describes it on its current programme page (10-day, non-residential summer camp in London plus three follow-up "Breathe Magic clubs"). Variants are named where they differ: the 2013 UK/Israel multi-site camps (Green et al., 2013), the Israeli day-camp and home-outreach versions (Weinstein et al., 2015), the 78-hour London protocol described by Fancourt et al. (2020), and an Australian magic-themed HABIT that Fancourt et al. call a modified, unaffiliated version (Hines et al., 2019). [source: Breathe programme page; Green 2013; Weinstein 2015; Fancourt 2020; Hines 2019]

What it is. BMITP is an arts-in-health occupational-therapy programme, not a psychotherapy and not a disease treatment. It is a magic-themed form of hand-arm bimanual intensive therapy (HABIT) for young people with hemiplegia (weakness or movement difference on one side of the body after brain injury, cerebral palsy or stroke). Highly specialist occupational therapists work alongside Magic Circle magicians. Over a two-week group camp with one-to-one support, young people learn close-up magic tricks and practise individual daily-living goals, and then perform a magic show on the last day. [source: Breathe programme page; LSBU story; Fancourt 2020]

Status within care. It is an adjunct to the child's ongoing NHS or private occupational therapy and physiotherapy and to their medical care. It does not replace medical management of hemiplegia or cerebral palsy (for example neurology follow-up, spasticity management, orthotics or seizure care), and it makes no claim to cure the underlying condition. [source: Breathe programme page (positions it as "therapy for young people with hemiplegia" delivered by OTs); medical-care boundary is synthesis]

How change is thought to happen. The motor mechanism is intensive, repetitive, task-specific, goal-directed practice of two-handed actions, based on motor-learning principles. Magic tricks built around two-handed actions draw the affected (assisting) hand into use. The theme supplies an internally meaningful goal (becoming a magician who performs), which sustains high-repetition practice. Fancourt et al. (2020) add psychosocial mechanisms, mapped with the COM-B behaviour-change model: reflective motivation (confidence, determination, self-esteem), social opportunity (friendships, feeling "not alone"), automatic motivation (fun, pride, less frustration) and gains in physical capability and independence. Parents valued that it felt like "therapy without being therapy". [source: Novak commentary; Bolt Burdon Kemp article; Fancourt 2020]

Professional frame. The hand-therapy content is planned and supervised by occupational therapists (Joint Clinical Lead OTs). Magicians teach the magic and performance. Magic Trainers, some of them volunteer OT students supervised by a Clinical Lead and trained beforehand in paediatric hemiplegia, give one-to-one support. In the UK the title occupational therapist is protected and practitioners must be registered with the Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC). Magic is not a regulated profession. A psychotherapist should not run the hand-therapy component without an occupational therapist or physiotherapist experienced in paediatric neurology leading it. The current programme page names OTs, not physiotherapists. [source: Breathe programme page; taster workshop page; LSBU story; HCPC point and the restriction on psychotherapists are synthesis]

Evidence status, as the sources give it. Breathe reports that the programme is "clinically effective". It cites a systematic review giving a "Green Light" to intensive bimanual therapy, NICE guideline CG145 and a WHO report, and reports its own figures: 83.1% of young people made significant progress on COPM performance and 78.3% on satisfaction; 92.9% of goals were achieved or exceeded; caregiver help fell by 16% and use of the assisting hand rose by 26.5%. These are figures reported by the provider. The published studies of the magic-themed version are uncontrolled:

Green et al. (2013): 23 children aged 7 to 15 at three camps, within-participant design. Assisting Hand Assessment (AHA) and Children's Hand-use Experience Questionnaire (CHEQ) improved, and CHEQ gains were maintained at 3 months. Severity did not limit progress.
Weinstein et al. (2015): 12 children, preliminary MRI study. 11 of 12 improved on at least one measure.
Hines et al. (2019): 28 children, pre-post design. COPM, Box and Blocks, ABILHAND-Kids and the CHEQ grasp subscale improved, with no significant change on the AHA.
Fancourt et al. (2020): qualitative study with no comparison group.

The broader evidence for bimanual training is rated in Novak et al.'s 2020 "traffic lights" systematic review, but the rating is not confirmed [uncertain]. Novak's 2013 commentary recommends at least 30 hours of practice, with 60 preferred. No randomised controlled trial of the magic-themed version is described in the sources. [source: Breathe programme page; KCL Pure record of Green 2013; Weinstein 2015; Hines 2019 record; Fancourt 2020; Novak commentary; Novak 2020 record] [uncertain: NICE CG145 and the WHO report are cited by Breathe, not drawn on here]

2. Framework

The programme is a fixed-format block, not an open-ended therapy. The phases below follow the current programme page unless marked otherwise.

Phase 0 – Referral. Families refer through Breathe's referral form or by contacting the charity. NHS occupational therapists have also helped identify candidates. Funding is discussed after acceptance: part-funded places for any young person in the UK or Northern Ireland, bursaries, NHS commissioners and individual funding requests, short-breaks funding, and commissioned places (for example Gloucestershire CCG in 2018 and fully funded Wandsworth places). [source: Breathe programme page; NR Times]

Phase 1 – Taster day and screening. This is an in-person workshop in a non-clinical setting. The young person learns a specially designed trick with Magic Circle magicians, meets a past participant and their parent, and the family talks to the Joint Clinical Lead OTs and the funding team. It screens clinical eligibility and whether the programme suits the young person "at this point in their lives". [source: taster workshop page; Breathe programme page]

Eligibility on the current programme page: aged 7 to 18 with hemiplegia or a one-sided movement difference; learning at mainstream (or equivalent) level; able to follow 3 to 4 multi-step instructions; able to work in a group; keen to learn magic. Young people with significant learning or behavioural difficulties, or with aphasia, are not accepted. Special-school pupils with specific needs should contact the Programme Manager first. [source: Breathe programme page]
[uncertain] The age range differs between sources: 7 to 18 on the programme page, 6 to 18 on the 2025 taster page, and "seven to 19" in an OT clinical lead's interview. Green 2013 also included MACS level III children. Check the current criteria with Breathe.

Phase 2 – Pre-camp clinical assessment and goal setting. A Clinical Lead OT assesses each young person before the camp. Individual goals are set, including self-care and daily-activity goals. The published versions measure outcomes with the AHA and CHEQ (Green 2013) and with the COPM, Box and Blocks Test and ABILHAND-Kids (Hines 2019). Breathe reports COPM results. [source: Bolt Burdon Kemp article; Breathe programme page; Green 2013; Hines 2019] [uncertain: the exact current assessment battery is not published in the sources]

Phase 3 – Intensive camp. The camp runs for 10 days over two consecutive weeks, Monday to Friday, 10am to 4pm, usually in August in London. It is a non-residential group camp with one-to-one Magic Trainer support where possible. Attendance at every session is required. The current page states "over 60 hours" of therapy. Fancourt 2020 describes 78 hours of intensive therapy (90 hours of clinical time) once the follow-up clubs are included. Each cohort has up to 16 young people. Content covers bimanual close-up magic with cards, cups, balls and rubber bands, performance and communication skills, and individual functional goals. [source: Breathe programme page; taster page; Fancourt 2020; NR Times] [uncertain: the hour-by-hour daily timetable is not published]

Phase 4 – Show (day 10). The young magicians perform a professional magic show alongside the magicians, in a professional venue, for family and friends. [source: Breathe programme page; Bolt Burdon Kemp article]

Phase 5 – Post-camp assessment. Clinical assessments are repeated at the end of the camp. Green 2013 assessed on the last day. [source: Bolt Burdon Kemp article; Green 2013]

Phase 6 – Consolidation clubs. The current version has three Breathe Magic clubs, two virtual and one in person, held around October, November and December. Earlier versions differ: three bi-monthly full-day clubs over six months (Fancourt 2020), therapy every two months for six months (Exeter page), or monthly consolidation workshops for six months (HRA summary). The clubs encourage home practice and peer support. A reunion event also runs (2025). [source: Breathe programme page; Fancourt 2020; Exeter Culture and Health page; HRA summary]

Phase 7 – Follow-up assessment. Studies reassessed at 6 weeks (Weinstein 2015), 3 months (Green 2013) and 3 and 6 months (Hines 2019). Breathe reports gains maintained at 6 months. [source: as cited]

Criteria for moving between phases. To enter, the young person must meet the screening eligibility and be accepted by the clinical leads. During the camp, full attendance is required. The camp's fixed endpoint is the day-10 show. For the period after the clubs, the sources state no discharge criteria; ongoing care returns to the local therapy team [synthesis].

3. Guiding principles

Two hands, not one. The programme trains both hands together (bimanual); it does not restrain the stronger hand. Choose and adapt activities so the assisting hand has a necessary job. [source: Bolt Burdon Kemp article; Green 2013]
Intensity and repetition. Practice is massed: at least 30 hours, preferably 60. In practice, keep the young person doing many repetitions rather than talking about doing them. [source: Novak commentary; Breathe programme page]
Goal-directed and task-specific. Practice the actual tasks the young person wants to do, such as tying shoelaces, serving lunch, sewing a costume waistcoat, dressing for school or opening a packet of crisps. [source: Breathe programme page; NR Times; Bolt Burdon Kemp article]
Child as active learner. The therapist guides "hands-off"; the child is "an active learner not a passive recipient". In practice, cue and adjust the task rather than moving the child's hand for them. [source: Novak commentary]
Intrinsic motivation through a meaningful end goal. Link every repetition to the trick and the show rather than to "exercise". [source: Novak commentary; Fancourt 2020]
Non-clinical framing. The programme is designed to feel non-clinical and non-educational, as "therapy without being therapy". Use magic and performance language, not medical language, in front of the young person. [source: Fancourt 2020]
Tailored to strengths and needs. Grade each trick and goal to the individual; one-to-one support sits inside the group. [source: Breathe programme page; Fancourt 2020]
Whole-person skills. The tricks also train sequencing, short- and long-term memory, visual perception, communication and performance. Support these as well as the hand skills. [source: NR Times]
Peer community. Peers working together create a safe place to explore goals, and friendships are an active ingredient. Build in peer pairing and celebration. [source: NR Times; Fancourt 2020]
Consolidation and transfer. Gains need to be carried into home and school, so plan home practice and use the follow-up clubs. [source: Fancourt 2020; Breathe programme page]
Family partnership. Parents see progress at the show, support home practice and form their own peer networks. Involve them in setting goals and in follow-up. [source: Fancourt 2020; Breathe programme page]
Protect the magic. The tricks are specially designed by OTs and magicians, and their methods are taught only within the programme. This guide describes only the motor demands and formats that the programme publishes. [source: Bolt Burdon Kemp article; taster page; non-disclosure stance is synthesis]
Adjunct, not replacement. Coordinate with the young person's own OT or physiotherapist and medical team, and never present the programme as treating the condition itself. [synthesis]

4. Intervention inventory

The programme publishes its components, not a session-by-session manual. Items 4.1 to 4.10 are what Breathe and the studies describe. Items 4.11 to 4.13 cover how a psychotherapist or another clinician refers into the programme, works alongside it and keeps it safe; most of their content is synthesis and is marked as such. Magic-trick methods are not given here. The guide describes only the published formats (close-up tricks with cards, cups, balls and rubber bands, built around two-handed actions). [source: Fancourt 2020; Bolt Burdon Kemp article]

4.1 Referral and coordination with the young person's hand therapist

Purpose: get a suitable young person into the programme at the right time, with their local OT or physiotherapist and medical team informed and on board. Use it when a client (or a client's child) has hemiplegia and wants to work on hand use, independence or confidence, and when an interest in magic or performance is present (desirable, not essential). [source: Breathe programme page]
Steps: (1) Check the published eligibility (age, mainstream-level learning, following 3 to 4 step instructions, group working; exclusions for significant learning or behavioural difficulty and for aphasia). (2) With the family's consent, contact the young person's treating OT or physiotherapist to confirm that intensive bimanual work fits their current plan; ask about recent surgery, botulinum toxin injections, casting or orthoses, and about seizures. (3) The family submits Breathe's referral form or contacts Breathe; NHS OTs can also nominate candidates. (4) Book the taster day. (5) Raise funding early (part-funded places, bursaries, NHS commissioner or individual funding request, short-breaks funding). (6) With consent, share the relevant psychological context (for example anxiety, low mood or peer difficulties) with the Breathe clinical leads. [source: Breathe programme page; NR Times; steps 2 and 6 are synthesis]
Example language (illustrative): "There's a two-week magic camp run by occupational therapists and professional magicians, built around two-handed tricks. Would you like me to check with your OT whether the timing works for your hand?"
Watch for: a young person being pushed into the programme by others; cost and travel worries (named as barriers in Fancourt 2020); clashes with planned medical treatment. It is working when the family has made an informed choice, the local therapist knows, and the screening is booked. [source: Fancourt 2020; synthesis]

4.2 Taster day and clinical screening

Purpose: let the young person try a specially designed trick, meet magicians, a past participant and a parent, and be screened by the clinical team in a non-clinical setting. It checks both eligibility and whether this is the right time. [source: taster workshop page; Breathe programme page]
Steps (as published): learn one designed trick with tips from Magic Circle magicians; hear a young magician and their parent describe the experience; talk to the Joint Clinical Lead OTs about clinical questions; talk to the Programme Manager and fundraising team about funding and bursaries. Places are small (6 per published workshop). [source: taster workshop page]
Example language (illustrative, for the clinician preparing the child): "Today is just to try one trick and meet the team. It's fine to find it tricky; they want to see how you learn, not how good you are already."
Watch for: the young person's response to learning in a group and to instruction from unfamiliar adults; frustration tolerance; parents' expectations. The published pages give no detail on how screening decisions are made [uncertain].

4.3 Pre-camp assessment and individual goal setting

Purpose: set a measurable baseline and the young person's own functional goals, which the camp then works towards. [source: Bolt Burdon Kemp article; Breathe programme page]
Steps: (1) The Clinical Lead OT assesses the young person before the camp. (2) The young person (with the family) chooses self-care and daily-activity goals; published examples include tying shoelaces, serving lunch, sewing a waistcoat costume, getting dressed for school, preparing a snack and opening a crisp packet. (3) Measures in the published versions include the COPM (performance and satisfaction ratings of self-chosen goals), the AHA (spontaneous use of the assisting hand in two-handed play), the CHEQ and ABILHAND-Kids (parent or child reports of everyday two-handed tasks), the Box and Blocks Test (one-handed dexterity) and, in one study, a modified Jebsen-Taylor test. These are licensed or trained instruments, and AHA scoring requires certified training. Their items are not reproduced here. [source: Green 2013; Hines 2019; Weinstein 2015; Breathe programme page; NR Times; Bolt Burdon Kemp article; the AHA certification point is synthesis]
Example language (illustrative): "If this camp went really well, what's one thing you'd love to be able to do on your own by the end, at home or at school?"
Watch for: goals that belong to the parent rather than the child; goals that are too big for two weeks. It is working when the young person can say their goal in their own words and it is specific and observable. [synthesis]

4.4 Bimanual close-up magic-trick practice (the HABIT core)

Purpose: the main active ingredient. Intensive, structured, task-specific practice of two-handed actions, delivered through tricks that need both hands. It is used throughout the camp and the clubs. [source: Bolt Burdon Kemp article; Fancourt 2020; Green 2013]
Steps: (1) The OTs and magicians co-design the tricks to develop hand and arm function. (2) Each trick is matched to the young person's needs and goals. (3) The young person learns the trick in steps and repeats it many times, mostly guided hands-off, with the trainer adjusting the demand. (4) Repetition is driven by the aim of performing, not by exercise targets. (5) The young person progresses to harder tricks or harder versions as the assisting hand's role grows. Steps 3 to 5 follow HABIT and motor-learning principles as the sources describe them; the programme's own grading rules for individual tricks are not published [uncertain]. [source: Bolt Burdon Kemp article; Breathe programme page; Novak commentary; NR Times]
Example language (illustrative): "Your helper hand has the most important job in this one: it holds the secret steady. Show me again, and this time let it do the holding."
Watch for: the young person doing the trick one-handed or with the assisting hand only as a passive prop; fatigue; frustration. It is working when the assisting hand is used spontaneously and actively in the trick, and when the trick becomes smoother and faster over repetitions. Green 2013 reported that use of the affected hand in bimanual activities rose from about 25% to 93%. [source: Green 2013; Fancourt 2020 for fatigue]

4.5 One-to-one Magic Trainer coaching within the group

Purpose: give each young person individual, intensive coaching while keeping the motivation and peer benefits of a group. [source: Breathe programme page; Fancourt 2020]
Steps: (1) A Magic Trainer (often a trained OT student or volunteer) is paired with the young person each day where possible. (2) Clinical Lead OTs supervise; trainers receive preliminary training in paediatric hemiplegia and the programme's approach. (3) Magicians teach the tricks and performance; the trainer keeps the young person practising and reports to the OTs. [source: Breathe programme page; LSBU story; steps 1 and 3 partly synthesis]
Example language (illustrative): "Let's do five more runs, then you can show the magician."
Watch for: the trainer doing too much for the young person. Novak's hands-off principle applies: cue and set up the task rather than moving the hand. [source: Novak commentary]

4.6 Functional and self-care goal practice

Purpose: carry two-handed gains into the daily tasks the young person chose in 4.3. [source: Breathe programme page; NR Times]
Steps: (1) Practise the chosen tasks within the camp day, sometimes woven into the show theme (for example sewing a waistcoat costume, or serving lunch). (2) Use the same repetition and hands-off cueing as in the magic practice. (3) Check progress against COPM ratings at the end of the camp and at follow-up. [source: Breathe programme page; Hines 2019; step structure is synthesis]
Example language (illustrative): "Magicians need costumes. Your helper hand holds the fabric while your other hand sews."
Watch for: hygiene with food; needles and scissors; dressing practice that involves personal care (follow an intimate-care policy, use same-gender staff where requested, and keep practice over clothing where possible [synthesis]). It is working when parents report the task being done at home without supervision, as in the published parent reports of dressing and opening packets. [source: Bolt Burdon Kemp article; safety points synthesis]

4.7 Performance, communication and cognitive skill building

Purpose: the tricks also train sequencing, short- and long-term memory, visual perception, communication and performance; these build confidence. [source: NR Times]
Steps: practise patter (the magician's talk), eye contact and audience handling alongside each trick; rehearse sequences until they are automatic; rehearse in front of peers before the show. Breathe calls these "high-quality magic and performance skills". [source: Breathe programme page; NR Times; rehearsal sequence is synthesis]
Example language (illustrative): "Tell the audience what they're about to see, then let your hands do the talking."
Watch for: performance anxiety and speech or language load. Young people with aphasia are not accepted, so check language demands in adapted versions. [source: Breathe programme page; synthesis]

4.8 The day-10 magic show

Purpose: a public, meaningful end goal that motivates the camp's repetitions and lets the family see the change. [source: Breathe programme page; Novak commentary]
Steps: the young magicians perform alongside Magic Circle magicians, in a professional venue, for parents, family and friends. [source: Breathe programme page; Bolt Burdon Kemp article] Before the show, agree with each young person and their parent what will be filmed or photographed and how it will be shared, and offer roles (for example a shorter routine, or performing with a partner) so no one is forced to perform [synthesis].
Example language (illustrative): "You choose which trick you're proudest of. That's the one you open with."
Watch for: severe performance anxiety; a trick failing on stage. Prepare a rehearsed recovery line. It is working when the young person takes part in the way they chose and describes pride afterwards (pride is a reported mechanism). [source: Fancourt 2020; synthesis]

4.9 Home practice and parent involvement

Purpose: keep the gains after the camp through practice at home and family support. [source: Fancourt 2020]
Steps: (1) The young person keeps practising the tricks and goal tasks at home; Weinstein 2015 notes that children "were encouraged to keep practicing". (2) Parents support practice. Fancourt 2020 reports that the need for parents to keep reminding children is a barrier. (3) A home-based outreach version (weekly clinic visits plus about two hours of daily bimanual practice logged in a diary, 60 hours over 6 weeks) was used in Israel. [source: Weinstein 2015; Fancourt 2020]
Example language (illustrative, to a parent): "Ask for a show rather than a practice: 'Can you show Grandma the new one?'"
Watch for: practice turning into a source of conflict between parent and child. It is working when the young person practises without being prompted. [synthesis]

4.10 Consolidation clubs and follow-up reassessment

Purpose: refresh skills, add new tricks, re-check goals and keep the peer networks going. [source: Breathe programme page; Fancourt 2020]
Steps: three clubs (in the current version, two virtual and one in person, around October to December), with reassessment at the follow-up points the programme uses. A reunion event is also held. Published follow-up points are 6 weeks, 3 months and 6 months. [source: Breathe programme page; Green 2013; Hines 2019; Weinstein 2015]
Example language (illustrative): "At the club you'll show us what you've kept practising, and learn one new trick to take home." [synthesis]
Watch for: the young person dropping out after the camp; the virtual format being harder for hand-skills coaching [synthesis]. It is working when gains are kept at follow-up (Green 2013: CHEQ gains maintained, affected-hand use 86% at follow-up).

4.11 Psychosocial support alongside the programme (for the psychotherapist)

Purpose: support the psychological mechanisms the programme activates (confidence, self-esteem, emotion regulation, friendship, reduced frustration and self-punishing behaviour) and address problems that are outside the programme's remit. [source: Fancourt 2020 for the mechanisms; the psychotherapist's role is synthesis]
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Before the camp, explore hopes, fears, body image and any history of exclusion, using a measure the young person can complete. (2) During the camp, do not run separate therapy sessions inside the programme unless Breathe asks you to; keep your work in your own setting. (3) After the camp, use the young person's own account of mastery ("I learned it, I performed it") as material for work on self-efficacy and on difficult-to-change self-beliefs. (4) Keep the boundary clear: the camp is an occupational-therapy programme delivered through an art form; it is not psychotherapy, and its magicians are not therapists.
Example language (illustrative): "What did it feel like when the audience gasped? Where else have you felt even a bit of that?"
Watch for: a low mood or anxiety that needs its own treatment. Don't treat it as a reason to avoid the programme; plan both. [synthesis]

4.12 Consent, assent and safeguarding procedure

Purpose: make participation voluntary and safe. Breathe's pages do not describe their safeguarding procedures; ask the provider for its safeguarding policy and named lead. [source: Breathe programme page (no safeguarding detail); Fancourt 2020 for research consent]
Steps: (1) Obtain written consent from the parent or carer for the programme, and for any research; in Fancourt 2020, parents gave written consent and children gave verbal assent under NHS REC approval 16/NW/0296. Young people aged 16 to 17, and younger children who are competent to decide, give their own consent [synthesis]. (2) Seek the young person's own agreement again before each assessment, before any filming, and before any physical facilitation; tell them they can stop at any time [synthesis]. (3) Use separate, specific consent for photographs, video, press coverage and the show [synthesis]. (4) Confirm that staff and volunteers working with children have enhanced DBS checks and safeguarding training, that there is a named safeguarding lead, and how concerns are referred to the local authority children's services under local safeguarding-partnership procedures [synthesis]. (5) Hands-off guidance is the programme's principle (Novak). Where touch is needed (for example to position a hand or help with an orthosis), explain it first, ask, keep it brief and functional, and offer a way to stop; personal-care tasks follow an intimate-care policy [synthesis].
Secrets: magicians keep their methods secret. Tell children plainly that a magic secret is the only kind of secret adults here will ask them to keep, and that they must never keep a secret about being hurt, touched or made to feel unsafe [synthesis].
Example language (illustrative): "The only secret we keep here is how the tricks work. If anything ever makes you feel unsafe, you tell one of us, and that's never breaking a rule." [synthesis]
Watch for: disclosures, which may happen in a playful, trusting atmosphere. Follow the setting's procedure and local reporting duties; don't investigate yourself [synthesis].

4.13 Materials and physical safety

Purpose: prevent injury during prop handling and daily-living practice [synthesis throughout].
Steps: (1) Check for latex allergy before using rubber bands, and use latex-free bands where needed. (2) Keep small balls and other small props away from younger siblings at the show and in clubs, because they are a choking risk. (3) Watch for eye injury from snapping bands. (4) Supervise needles and scissors in sewing and costume work. (5) Follow food-hygiene rules and check allergies before serving lunch or preparing snacks. (6) Hold each young person's medical and seizure plan, and know their orthotic routines. (7) Build rest breaks into the 10am to 4pm days; fatigue is the main physical concern participants raised (Fancourt 2020). (8) If pain, new stiffness or loss of skill appears, stop and refer to the young person's OT or physiotherapist or doctor.
Example language (illustrative): "Before we use the bands, has anyone ever had a rash from rubber gloves or balloons?" [synthesis]
Watch for: tiredness late in the day, small props left on the floor, and any new pain in the hand or arm; it is working when the camp runs with no injuries and rest breaks are taken without prompting [synthesis].

5. Handling problems

Fancourt et al. (2020) report the barriers that participants and families named: fatigue, travel and cost, weekend timing, and the need for parents to keep reminding children to practise. Everything else in this section is synthesis unless a source is given.

Fatigue during the 10am to 4pm days. Break tricks into short practice runs separated by rest or performance-only activities. Change between demanding and lighter tasks. Tell the OT lead if fatigue persists, because it can mask the motor effect. [source: Fancourt 2020 (barrier); responses synthesis]
The young person won't use the assisting hand (stuck). Make the assisting hand's role necessary but achievable: reduce the demand on it (for example a stabilising role first), then build up. Never restrain the stronger hand; this is a bimanual programme. Ask the OT to re-grade the trick. [source: Green 2013 and Bolt Burdon Kemp article on the bimanual approach; responses synthesis]
Frustration when a trick fails. Normalise failure as part of how magicians learn. Go back to the last step that worked, and celebrate the effort as well as the result. Fancourt 2020 reports that frustration and self-punishing behaviour decreased over the programme; frustration that keeps escalating calls for the clinical lead and, if it continues, for psychological support. [source: Fancourt 2020; synthesis]
Resistance: "this is just more therapy". Keep to the magic framing, so that the young person meets a trick to learn rather than an exercise. Let them choose between tricks. [source: Fancourt 2020 ("therapy without being therapy"); synthesis]
Performance anxiety and overwhelm before the show. Offer graded options: performing with a partner, a shorter routine, or another role. Give rehearsal in front of peers, a rehearsed recovery line for a failed trick, and a calm space. No one is forced on stage. [synthesis]
Non-adherence to home practice after the camp. Ask for a show rather than practice; set short daily routines; involve siblings or grandparents as an audience; use the clubs as deadlines; have the local OT reinforce practice. [source: Fancourt 2020 (parental reminding as a barrier); synthesis]
Gains fading after the camp. This is expected without consolidation; Green 2013 notes open questions about the intensity and duration needed for longer-term gains. Make sure the local therapy plan picks up where the camp left off. Novak's commentary suggests home programmes run by parents in partnership with the therapist where camps are not possible. [source: Green 2013; Novak commentary]
Rupture with a trainer or a peer. Swap the pairing if needed, repair openly, and keep the group norm that everyone is a magician learning. Tell the clinical lead. [synthesis]
Eligibility exclusion (learning or behavioural difficulty, aphasia). Explain the reason sensitively. Ask the Programme Manager about special-school pupils, and offer local intensive bimanual or home-programme options through the young person's OT. [source: Breathe programme page; Novak commentary; synthesis]
Pain, increased spasticity or new loss of function. Stop the activity and refer to the young person's OT or physiotherapist or doctor. Medical problems are managed by the medical team; the programme does not treat the condition. [synthesis]
Cost and travel barriers. Signpost bursaries, part-funded places, NHS commissioner or individual funding requests, short-breaks funding, and locally commissioned places. [source: Breathe programme page; NR Times]
Unrealistic expectations (a "cure"). Restate what the evidence shows: uncontrolled studies report improvements in two-handed use and independence, and the condition itself is not cured. Agree specific goals instead. [source: Green 2013; Hines 2019; synthesis]
Mixed findings across versions. Hines 2019 found no significant change on the AHA, against improvements on other measures, in a version Fancourt describes as modified and unaffiliated. Measures and versions should therefore be named when describing outcomes to families. [source: Hines 2019; Fancourt 2020]
The young person wants to know or reveal trick methods outside the programme. Respect the magicians' convention of secrecy, but never at the cost of a safety disclosure (see 4.12). [synthesis]
Using magic tricks in your own psychotherapy sessions (adapted use). This is a derived application, not the Breathe programme. Without an OT or physiotherapist leading, do not claim any hand-therapy benefit. Use simple, published commercial tricks only as a rapport or mastery activity. [synthesis]

Sources

Sources:

Papers cited:

Green, D., Schertz, M., Gordon, A. M., Moore, A., Schejter Margalit, T., Farquharson, Y., Ben Bashat, D., Weinstein, M., Lin, J.-P. & Fattal-Valevski, A. (2013). A multi-site study of functional outcomes following a themed approach to hand-arm bimanual intensive therapy for children with hemiplegia. Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology, 55(6), 527–533. doi:10.1111/dmcn.12113.
Weinstein, M., Myers, V., Green, D., et al. (2015). Brain plasticity following intensive bimanual therapy in children with hemiparesis: preliminary evidence. Neural Plasticity, 2015, 798481.
Hines, A., Bundy, A. C., Black, D., Haertsch, M. & Wallen, M. (2019). Physical & Occupational Therapy in Pediatrics, 39(4), 404–419. doi:10.1080/01942638.2018.1505802.
Fancourt, D., Wee, J. & Lorencatto, F. (2020). BMC Pediatrics, 20, 363.
Novak, I., Morgan, C., Fahey, M., et al. (2020). Current Neurology and Neuroscience Reports, 20(3). doi:10.1007/s11910-020-1022-z.

Further reading (not drawn on) [uncertain]: Breathe's own research page for the programme; NICE CG145 and the WHO report cited by Breathe; Gordon et al. (2007) HABIT trial; the full text of Novak et al. (2020).

← Previous · VIII-205Prison arts (Koestler)Next · VIII-207 →Art and music therapy in Brazil's public health system