1. Introduction
Version followed: the 21-character incantation (jumun, 주문; also called samchilju, 삼칠주, "three-sevens incantation") as practised in Cheondogyo (천도교, "Religion of the Heavenly Way"), the institutional church organised by Son Byong-hi from 1905–1906, described through the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture (한국민족문화대백과사전) entries on the Five Duties (오관) and on samchilju, Ko Byoungchul's 2007 study of the Cheondogyo Sunday service, and Seong Haeyoung's 2022 study of founder Choe Je-u (Suun). The scripture is the Donggyeong Daejeon (동경대전); an English translation exists (University Press of America, 2007) [uncertain: translation not verified against the text]. Other Donghak-derived groups (for example Suungyo and Cheonjingyo) also recite incantations with different methods; they are not covered here. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관 and 삼칠주; Ko 2007; Seong 2022; SNU Religion and Culture 2017 abstract]
What it is. Cheondogyo is a Korean religion founded as Donghak ("Eastern Learning") by Choe Je-u (1824–1864, honorific Suun). It is an organised church with parishes, officers and training centres, not a therapy or a self-help programme. Recitation of the incantation is the first of the Five Duties (오관) that members observe: incantation (주문), clear water (청수), the sacred day (시일), sacred rice (성미) and prayer (기도). Members learn the incantation when they enter the church, recite it at services, and are encouraged to recite it privately at any time. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관]
Where it comes from, as the tradition tells it. Cheondogyo dates the incantation to Suun's religious experience of 1860, in which, according to the accounts Seong summarises, he felt a sudden chill and trembling and heard a voice naming itself Sangje (the Supreme Being), who gave him a talisman and an incantation to teach to others; the tradition names the Supreme Being Hanullim (한울님) or Cheonju (天主, "Heavenly Lord"). The incantation is held to contain the core of Donghak teaching. The birthplace and holiest site is Yongdamjeong near Gyeongju, where a training centre (수도원) stands today. [source: Seong 2022; Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주; Seoul Shinmun 2007]
Core idea of change, as the tradition states it. The incantation has two parts. The opening eight characters, the gangnyeong jumun (강령주문, "incantation for the descent of the spirit"), ask that the Utmost Energy (jigi, 至氣, the single cosmic vital energy) descend and transform the person. The remaining thirteen characters, the bon jumun (본주문, "root incantation"), centre on sicheonju (侍天主): bearing, or enshrining, Heaven/God within oneself. The tradition teaches that by reciting it, understanding its meaning and living it out, with sincerity (誠), reverence (敬) and faith (信), the practitioner keeps this awareness for life and comes to knowledge that unites understanding and action. Later leaders developed this into innaecheon (人乃天, "the human being is Heaven"), which the church presents as the ground of human dignity. Translators differ on the key verb: "serving", "bearing" or "being identified with" the Lord of Heaven; historian Don Baker cautions that later theology shapes many translations. These are the tradition's claims, reported here without endorsement or dismissal. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주; Baker 2003]
Health claims. The incantation is also called jangsaengju (장생주, "long-life incantation"), because the tradition holds that reciting, understanding and practising it brings long life [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주]. Evidence status: the sources consulted contain no clinical evidence that it treats or prevents physical disease; treat this as a religious teaching, not a health intervention [synthesis].
The text itself. The incantation is published openly in Cheondogyo scripture and reference works. This guide does not reproduce it; clients who practise it will know it, and those wishing to learn it should do so through the church, where members receive it at entry. [synthesis]
2. Framework
This is a religious practice within a church, so there are no therapy phases or session counts. Below is (a) the structure in which Cheondogyo places recitation and (b) a working frame for the psychotherapist alongside it. Counts and times are the tradition's own observance, reported by sources; they are never targets for a client.
(a) The tradition's structure.
- Entry (입교). Members learn the incantation at initiation into the church. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관]
- Daily: nightly clear-water prayer. Each night at 9 p.m. members hold a family prayer before a bowl of clear water (cheongsu, 청수); the water is understood as the basic element of all things and as recalling the blood Suun shed at his execution. Ko reports that on ordinary days believers recite Suun's incantation 105 times as part of this prayer. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관; Ko 2007; Seoul Shinmun 2007]
- Weekly: the sacred day (시일). Members gather at church on Sunday (11 a.m. per a 2007 report) for a collective service. In the current order the congregation sings the thirteen-character root incantation three times to piano accompaniment (earlier orders read the full 21 characters three times). After the service, parishes run sessions in which believers recite the incantation 21 or 105 times; small churches tend to emphasise recitation, the central church doctrine and lectures. On Sunday evening members recite a separate incantation composed by Son Byong-hi. Sources differ on the Sunday-evening detail: Ko describes 105 recitations of the 21-character incantation at 9 p.m. on Sundays [uncertain: sources conflict]. [source: Ko 2007; Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관; Seoul Shinmun 2007]
- Ceremonies. At public ceremonies such as the Sunday service, celebrations and funerals, only the final portion of the verse is recited. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관]
- Special prayer and training. Prayer (기도) includes scheduled special prayers (for example on anniversaries) and irregular ones. Training centres (수도원) and prayer houses host intensive practice; Ko notes that most believers have their strongest emotional and religious experiences in prayer houses rather than at Sunday service. Specific retreat formats are not described in the sources consulted [uncertain: not verified]. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관; Ko 2007; Seoul Shinmun 2007]
- Who teaches. The church is organised with appointed officers at each level, set up by Son Byong-hi's reforms; local parishes (교구) run recitation programmes. No formal teacher-certification scheme is documented in the sources consulted [uncertain: not verified]. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관; Ko 2007]
(b) Working frame for the psychotherapist [synthesis]. Not phases of the religion; a sequence for clinical work.
- Assessment. Spiritual and cultural history; what recitation means to the client; current pattern of practice (described in the client's words); any intensive prayer planned; mental-health risk factors. Move on when you understand the role recitation plays and whether it is a resource, a source of distress, or both.
- Agreement on role. Agree with the client whether and how their practice enters therapy, and who in their church, if anyone, they want involved. Move on when consent is explicit.
- Client-led integration or problem work. Draw on recitation as the client wishes (Section 4), or treat problems around it (adverse experiences, scrupulosity, religious conflict). Review at each session.
- Coordination and ending. Liaise with church officers or a doctor where the client consents; plan how the client will keep a safe relationship to practice after therapy.
Session length and number follow the client's presenting problem and the evidence-based treatment you are delivering, not the practice.
3. Guiding principles
- Describe, attribute, do not adjudicate. Hanullim, jigi, gangnyeong and sicheonju are the tradition's concepts. Practical meaning: speak of them as "in Cheondogyo teaching" or in the client's words, neither affirming nor debunking. [synthesis]
- Client-led, in the client's language. Practical meaning: use the Korean terms the client uses (주문, 한울님, 청수); ask before translating or paraphrasing sacred words. [synthesis]
- The church holds the teaching. Practical meaning: you do not teach the incantation, correct recitation, or prescribe counts; refer to the client's parish or church officers. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관] [synthesis]
- Counts belong to the tradition, never to the treatment plan. Practical meaning: you may note that the tradition recites 21 or 105 times; you never set or track repetition goals as homework. [synthesis]
- Meaning before technique. Practical meaning: the tradition stresses understanding and living the words, not only saying them; ask what the words mean to the client before using recitation clinically. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주]
- Sincerity, reverence, faith as the client's frame. Practical meaning: when exploring a client's practice, these three attitudes, which the tradition names as basic, are useful entry points for conversation. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주]
- Dignity as a shared value. Practical meaning: innaecheon's emphasis on human dignity can support self-compassion and anti-shame work if the client brings it. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주] [synthesis]
- Respect strong experience without missing illness. Practical meaning: spirit-descent experiences have an honoured place in the tradition (the founder's own involved chill and trembling and alarmed his family); assess function, risk and context before calling anything a symptom. [source: Seong 2022] [synthesis]
- No health claims. Practical meaning: do not present recitation as treating physical disease; route physical complaints to the client's doctor. [synthesis]
- Stay in role. Practical meaning: you are not a church officer, teacher or confessor; avoid dual relationships with members of the client's congregation. [synthesis]
- Consent for every collaboration. Practical meaning: contact church officers only with written consent and an agreed purpose. [synthesis]
4. Intervention inventory
Part A gives the practices as Cheondogyo publicly describes them (outline only; the church teaches them). Part B is the psychotherapist's own work alongside them. Repetition counts are reported as the tradition's observance only.
A1. Jumun recitation (the practice as the tradition describes it)
- Purpose (tradition's statement): to ask for the descent of the Utmost Energy and transformation of the person, and to keep sicheonju, Heaven borne within, in mind for life and live it out. Suun called it a text for the utmost devotion to God and, in a hymn the encyclopedia cites, valued the thirteen characters above "ten thousand books". [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주 and 오관]
- Public outline: learned at entry to the church; chanted aloud, with its meaning understood and its teaching carried into conduct; recited at services and privately at any time; the tradition reports 105 recitations in the nightly prayer and 21 or 105 in post-service parish sessions; believers hold that the words carry sacred power as well as meaning. Whether silent recitation is also taught is unclear [uncertain: not verified]. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주 and 오관; Ko 2007]
- Who teaches: the client's parish and church officers. Refer there for instruction. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관]
- Example language (illustrative): "You mentioned you say the jumun most nights. Tell me what it's like for you, in whatever words fit."
- Watch for: the clinician teaching, correcting or counting recitation (out of role); a client using counts compulsively (see B7).
A2. Nightly clear-water prayer (청수)
- Purpose (tradition's statement): a family prayer at 9 p.m. before a bowl of clear water, which stands for the basic element of all things and recalls Suun's death; clear water is set out at every ceremony. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관; Seoul Shinmun 2007]
- Public outline: household members gather before the water at the fixed hour and pray, including recitation. The detailed order of the rite is not given here [uncertain: not verified].
- Example language (illustrative): "Is the nine o'clock prayer something you do alone or with family? What happens in the household around it?"
- Watch for: family conflict over attendance; the prayer as a protective routine (sleep, structure, belonging) worth preserving in scheduling [synthesis].
A3. Sunday service (시일식) and parish recitation sessions
- Purpose (tradition's statement): collective worship on the sacred day, designed by Son Byong-hi's reforms around the seven-day week. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관]
- Public outline: congregation sings the root incantation three times; sermon or lecture; optional post-service recitation sessions run by parishes. [source: Ko 2007]
- Example language (illustrative): "What does church on Sunday give you that you don't get elsewhere?"
- Watch for: social isolation if attendance stops; community as a resource for isolated or bereaved clients [synthesis].
A4. Special prayer, training centres and prayer houses
- Purpose (tradition's statement): prayers on anniversaries and other occasions; intensive training at training centres (수도원) such as the one at Yongdamjeong and at prayer houses, where believers report their strongest religious experiences. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관; Ko 2007; Seoul Shinmun 2007]
- Public outline only: formats and any dietary or sleep arrangements are not described in the sources consulted [uncertain: not verified]. Clients considering intensive prayer should ask the organising church for the programme in advance.
- Example language (illustrative): "Before you go, would it help to find out from the training centre what a day there looks like, so we can think about how you'll look after yourself?"
- Watch for: intensive periods coinciding with clinical risk (recent psychosis, mania, severe insomnia, recent trauma); see B4–B6.
A5. Sacred rice (성미) and other duties (context only)
- Purpose (tradition's statement): a spoonful of rice set aside per person from each meal and given to the church, funding its work. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관; Seoul Shinmun 2007]
- Example language (illustrative): "These daily duties sound like they connect you to the church even on busy days. Is that right?"
- Watch for: observance becoming a source of guilt or perfectionism (see B7).
B1. Spiritual and cultural assessment
- Purpose and when: at intake for any client who identifies with Cheondogyo or Donghak heritage, or mentions recitation; to understand the practice's role, supports and risks.
- Steps: (1) Ask open questions about religious identity and practice. (2) Use the DSM-5-TR Cultural Formulation Interview, including its supplementary module on spirituality, religion and moral traditions, to explore meaning, community and coping [uncertain: module wording not verified]. (3) Ask what the incantation means to the client, how and when they recite, and any experiences during recitation. (4) Ask about intensive prayer or training planned. (5) Screen for psychosis, bipolar disorder, dissociation, trauma, OCD and suicide risk as in any intake. (6) Ask whom in the church they trust and whether they would want contact. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "Some people find their faith is a strength, some find it complicated, many both. Where is it for you right now?" / "When you recite, what tends to happen inside — in your body, your thoughts, your feelings?"
- Watch for / working: the client uses their own terms freely; you can state the practice's role back accurately; risks are documented.
B2. Exploring meaning: sicheonju and innaecheon in the client's life
- Purpose and when: when the client draws on their faith to make sense of suffering, worth or relationships; can support work on shame, self-worth and respect for others.
- Steps: (1) Ask what sicheonju or innaecheon means to the client personally. (2) Reflect back links to the therapy goal in the client's words. (3) Invite the client to identify how the teaching bears on the current problem (e.g. self-criticism). (4) Do not supply doctrine; where the client is unsure, suggest they discuss it with a church officer. [source for concepts: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주] [synthesis for steps]
- Example language (illustrative): "You said your faith teaches that Heaven is carried within each person. How does that sit next to the harsh things you say to yourself?"
- Watch for / working: the client generates their own links; avoid using doctrine to argue with the client; stop if the client feels the faith is being used as a lever.
B3. Client-led integration of recitation as a coping resource
- Purpose and when: when a client already recites and wishes to draw on it for distress tolerance, sleep routines or connection to faith between sessions. Spiritually integrated psychotherapy approaches (see Domain VII) frame this as working within the client's own practice; secular repetition-based methods exist elsewhere (for example the Mantram Repetition Program, entry 310; see also 296, chanting; mindfulness programmes, Domain II) and are not the same as a sacred practice [synthesis].
- Steps: (1) Ask whether the client wants their practice in therapy at all. (2) Ask when recitation has helped and when it has not. (3) Agree with the client how they might use their existing practice in hard moments, in their own way and amount; you do not add counts or new methods. (4) Pair it with ordinary skills (paced activity, contacting support). (5) Review its effect each session. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "You said reciting at night steadies you. Would you like to think about whether it could help in the moments before a panic, or would you rather keep it separate from our work?"
- Watch for / working: the client reports steadiness, sense of connection, better routine. Stop or adjust if recitation becomes avoidance of feared situations, a ritual to neutralise intrusive thoughts (B7), or brings up distressing experiences (B5–B6).
B4. Screening before intensive prayer or training
- Purpose and when: before a client attends an intensive prayer period, training-centre stay or extended recitation session.
- Steps: (1) Ask what is planned and get the programme from the church if possible. (2) Review history of psychosis, mania, dissociation, severe trauma, current insomnia, recent bereavement or crisis. (3) If risk factors are present, discuss with the client options such as a shorter or later participation, attending with a companion, or telling the organisers about health needs. (4) Agree warning signs and a plan for contacting you or emergency services. (5) Where physical health is relevant (sleep loss, restricted eating, chronic illness), route to the client's doctor. [synthesis] Adverse effects can occur in meditators with no previous mental-health history, so screening is not only for those with a history. [source: Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica]
- Example language (illustrative): "I'm glad this matters to you. Because intense practice can stir things up for anyone, can we plan what you'll do if you start feeling unlike yourself while you're there?"
- Watch for / working: a written or agreed plan; client feels respected rather than discouraged.
B5. Assessing unusual experiences during recitation (spirit descent)
- Purpose and when: when a client reports trembling, strong bodily sensations, voices, visions, energy or a felt presence during or after recitation. In the tradition, the opening part of the incantation asks for the spirit's descent, and the founder's own experience involved chill and trembling that frightened his family. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주; Seong 2022] How commonly such experiences occur in present-day Cheondogyo practice is unknown [uncertain: not verified].
- Steps: (1) Listen without labelling; ask how the client and their community understand the experience. (2) Assess function: sleep, eating, work, relationships, safety. (3) Assess features suggesting illness: experiences continuing outside practice, loss of insight, persecutory content, command voices, grandiosity with reduced need for sleep, marked disorganisation, dissociative gaps, suicidal ideation. (4) Ask whether church elders regard the experience as expected within the tradition. (5) If there are risk features, arrange urgent psychiatric assessment. If not, note that DSM-5-TR lists a religious or spiritual problem as a focus of clinical attention, code Z65.8. (6) Agree with the client whether to adjust practice (B6) and whether to involve a church officer. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "In your tradition, what does it mean when the body trembles during the jumun?" / "Has anything like this carried on when you weren't praying?"
- Watch for / working: the client feels understood, not pathologised; red flags are checked and recorded; mental illness is not missed. Published typologies of challenging contemplative experiences (Lindahl et al. 2017, PLOS ONE, "Varieties of Contemplative Experience") can help structure the enquiry [uncertain: not verified].
B6. Grounding and reducing practice intensity after adverse experiences
- Purpose and when: when recitation or intensive prayer is followed by anxiety, low mood, depersonalisation, insomnia or other distress. Anxiety, depression and cognitive anomalies are the adverse events most reported in meditation research (pooled prevalence about 8%, with wide variation by study design). [source: Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica] This evidence comes from meditation, not specifically from Cheondogyo recitation [synthesis].
- Steps: (1) Validate and normalise that intense practice can be unsettling. (2) Offer grounding: eyes open, feet on floor, naming objects in the room, ordinary activity, contact with others. (3) With the client, consider reducing the length or intensity of private practice for a time while keeping community participation if that feels safe; the decision rests with the client, ideally talking with their church. (4) Protect sleep and regular meals. (5) Monitor; escalate to medical or psychiatric care if symptoms persist or risk rises. Specialist support for meditation-related difficulties exists (Britton's Cheetah House) [uncertain: not verified]. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "Let's bring you back into the room first. What can you see right now? ... Would it make sense to talk with someone at your church about easing off for a little while until you feel steadier?"
- Watch for / working: symptoms settle over days to weeks; the client does not feel they have failed religiously; persistent or worsening symptoms prompt referral.
B7. Scrupulosity around recitation (religious OCD)
- Purpose and when: when recitation becomes compulsive: repeating until it feels "just right", fear of a mispronounced or skipped character offending Hanullim, anxious counting, repeated reassurance-seeking from church officers, or avoiding services for fear of error. The IOCDF describes repeating prayers until they feel right, rewriting or checking prayers, purifying rituals and reassurance-seeking from clergy as typical presentations, and notes that scrupulous behaviour often goes beyond what the religion requires and causes impairment. [source: IOCDF, What is OCD & Scrupulosity?]
- Steps: (1) Assess for OCD with standard tools; distinguish devout observance from compulsion by distress, rigidity and impairment. (2) Explain that treatment aims to separate OCD from the client's values so they can live by those values. (3) With consent, consult a church officer the client trusts about what the tradition actually expects (for example, whether an imperfect recitation is a problem in Cheondogyo teaching); the IOCDF notes that faith leaders may help clarify the institution's position. (4) Build an exposure hierarchy that targets the OCD, not the faith: e.g. reciting once without re-doing, tolerating uncertainty about whether it was "right", reducing checking and reassurance-seeking. The client's ordinary religious observance is not an exposure target. (5) Response prevention for re-recitation, counting rituals and reassurance-seeking. (6) Medication questions go to the prescriber. [source: IOCDF] [synthesis for Cheondogyo application]
- Exposure safety and consent: obtain informed consent for each exercise; never ask the client to do something they regard as sacrilegious; agree a stop signal; build gradually. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "We're not trying to take your faith away. We're trying to take OCD out of your prayer, so the jumun can be what your church means it to be."
- Watch for / working: falling distress and time spent on rituals; the client reports recitation feeling more like devotion than checking. Watch for reassurance-seeking shifting onto you.
B8. Trauma-sensitive adaptation of the client's practice
- Purpose and when: for clients with trauma histories whose recitation brings up flashbacks, dissociation or bodily overwhelm. Treleaven's trauma-sensitive mindfulness (2018) is a published adaptation for meditation generally [uncertain: not verified]; the options below are general principles offered for the client to choose and, if they wish, to check with their church [synthesis].
- Steps: (1) Identify what in practice triggers distress (closed eyes, a dark room, bodily sensations, long sessions, a particular place). (2) Offer choices: eyes open, a lit room, shorter periods, reciting aloud with others rather than alone, pausing whenever needed, attending to the meaning of the words rather than bodily sensations. (3) Stabilise first: trauma processing comes after the client can regulate. (4) Review with the client after each change. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "You're always in charge of your practice. If opening your eyes or stopping partway helps you stay present, that's a choice you can make, and you might want to ask your church how they see it."
- Watch for / working: fewer dissociative episodes during practice; client retains a sense of agency and faith.
B9. Scheduling and treatment accommodation
- Purpose and when: to fit therapy around observance and preserve protective routines.
- Steps: (1) Avoid booking over Sunday service or the 9 p.m. family prayer where possible. (2) Plan for major anniversaries and special prayers the client names. (3) Where sleep is a target (e.g. CBT-I), work the nightly prayer into the routine rather than against it. (4) For inpatient or residential settings, ask whether a bowl of clear water and quiet time can be accommodated. [source for observance times: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관; Seoul Shinmun 2007] [synthesis for steps]
- Example language (illustrative): "Which times in the week are fixed for your faith, so I can plan around them?"
- Watch for / working: attendance improves; client feels respected.
B10. Grief, ritual and community support
- Purpose and when: bereavement in a Cheondogyo family, or loss of community. The incantation's final portion is recited at funerals and other ceremonies. [source: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관]
- Steps: (1) Ask how the funeral and remembrance were observed and what was meaningful or missing. (2) Explore the client's beliefs about the dead as the client holds them. (3) Encourage use of community and ritual supports the client values. (4) Watch for complicated grief and treat as indicated. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "What was it like to hear the jumun at the funeral?"
- Watch for / working: client reconnects with supports; grief moves rather than freezes.
B11. Collaboration with and referral to church officers
- Purpose and when: when the client wants input on doctrine or practice, needs instruction, or when scrupulosity treatment requires clarification of what the tradition expects.
- Steps: (1) Clarify the question and the client's goal. (2) Obtain written consent stating what will be shared. (3) Contact the officer the client names (parish leadership; the church has officers at each level). (4) Keep clinical decisions with the client and you, and religious teaching with the church. (5) Feed back to the client. [source for church structure: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관] [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "Would it help to ask someone at your parish whether a recitation that felt imperfect counts as a fault? You choose who, and what I share."
- Watch for / working: clear division of roles; no pressure on the client from either side.
B12. Group dynamics, leaving and religious trauma
- Purpose and when: when the client describes pressure, exclusion, conflict over leaving or harm in any religious group. Independent reports of coercive practices or teacher misconduct in Cheondogyo: none found in the sources consulted; this item is general.
- Steps: (1) Ask about freedom to question, to reduce involvement and to leave; control of finances, relationships, information or sleep; threats or shaming. (2) Respect continued membership, leaving, or changing practice as the client's choice. (3) For religious trauma, use standard trauma-focused care with attention to the client's spiritual losses. (4) If a crime or safeguarding issue (including children) emerges, follow local reporting duties. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "If you decided to step back from church for a while, what do you imagine would happen?"
- Watch for / working: the client makes choices freely; avoid labelling any group without evidence.
B13. Role, boundaries and the therapist's own stance
- Purpose and when: throughout.
- Steps: (1) Do not act as religious teacher or interpreter of doctrine. (2) Avoid dual relationships with members of the client's congregation, including if you belong to the same church. (3) Consider self-disclosure of your own beliefs only if it serves the client. (4) Build religious and spiritual competence through training and consultation; Vieten et al. (2013) proposed a set of spiritual and religious competencies for psychologists [uncertain: not verified]. (5) Follow your professional ethics code on competence, respect for religion and culture, multiple relationships and informed consent [synthesis].
- Example language (illustrative): "I'm not the right person to say what the scripture means, but I can help you think about how this is affecting you."
- Watch for / working: client does not look to you for religious rulings; you seek consultation when out of your depth.
5. Handling problems
Sources on Cheondogyo do not address clinical problems; all guidance below is [synthesis] except where a source is named.
- Client wants you to teach or correct the incantation. Decline warmly and refer to their parish; the church teaches it at entry. (illustrative) "That's something your church holds, and I'd hate to get it wrong. Who there could you ask?" [source for teaching at entry: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 오관]
- Client asks you to set a number of recitations as homework. Do not. Counts reported in sources (21, 105) are the tradition's observance [source: Ko 2007]. Set goals about the clinical problem (sleep, panic, avoidance) instead, and let the client decide practice with their church.
- Stuck client who uses recitation to avoid feelings or tasks. Explore function without criticising the faith: when does recitation help, when does it postpone? Agree on facing the avoided task first and reciting afterwards if they wish. Watch for compulsive patterns (B7).
- Ambivalence or resistance to bringing faith into therapy. Respect it; keep faith out unless the client invites it. Revisit only if it becomes clinically central.
- Rupture: client feels faith was dismissed or pathologised. Acknowledge directly, apologise for the impact, ask what felt dismissive, restate that their beliefs are theirs and that your job is their wellbeing. Consider consultation with a culturally informed colleague.
- Overwhelm during or after intensive prayer. Grounding and reduced intensity (B6); urgent assessment if psychotic, manic, dissociative or suicidal features appear (B5). Coordinate with the church only with consent.
- Spirit-descent experience vs. illness is unclear. Hold both possibilities: monitor closely, protect sleep, involve psychiatry early if function declines, and invite the client's view of what their tradition would expect. The founder's family feared his experience was madness [source: Seong 2022]; families may disagree now too, so ask whose concern brought the client in.
- Non-adherence to clinical treatment because of faith. Ask what the client fears treatment would mean for their faith; with consent, ask the church whether there is any conflict. Medication questions go to the prescriber.
- Scrupulosity resists ERP because exposures feel sinful. Re-anchor in values (B7); check targets with a trusted church officer; never use religious acts the client regards as sacrilegious as exposures [source for leader involvement: IOCDF].
- Family conflict over observance (e.g. the nightly prayer, or a member leaving the church). Family sessions focused on respect and communication; avoid taking sides on doctrine.
- Health claims (long-life teaching) used instead of medical care. Respect the belief; encourage medical care alongside it; involve the client's doctor. [source for the teaching: Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 삼칠주]
- Fasting, sleep loss or exertion during intensive prayer. No specific practices of this kind are documented in the sources consulted [uncertain: not verified]; if a client reports them, describe risks qualitatively and route to their doctor.
- Minors. If children take part in intensive practice and show distress, assess their wellbeing and assent, involve parents, and follow local safeguarding procedures where harm is suspected.
- Therapist shares or differs from the client's faith. Seek supervision; avoid dual relationships; keep self-disclosure purposeful.
- Language and translation. Translations of key terms differ ("serving", "bearing", "identified with" the Lord of Heaven) [source: Baker 2003]; use the client's own term and ask what it means to them rather than choosing a translation.
Sources
Works cited:
- 오관 (五款) — 한국민족문화대백과사전 (Encyclopedia of Korean Culture), entry by 최동희
- 삼칠주 (三七咒) — 한국민족문화대백과사전 (Encyclopedia of Korean Culture), entry by 조용일
- Ko Byoungchul (2007). The Religion of the Heavenly Way's Sunday Service in Korea: Its Meaning and Structure. The Review of Korean Studies 10(1), 33–49
- Seong, Haeyoung (2022). The Unique Concept of God in Donghak: An Emanation of the Religious Experiences of Suun Choe Jeu. Religions 13(6), 531. doi:10.3390/rel13060531
- Baker, Don (2003, 14 December). The God of Tonghak. Korean Studies mailing list
- [서울신문 (2007, 27 June). 종교건축 이야기 천도교 발상지 경주 ‘용담정’](https://www.seoul.co.kr/news/2007/06/27/20070627023003)
- 한국 신종교의 주문 수행: 동학계와 증산계 신종교를 중심으로 (2017). 종교와 문화 32, 123–164 (SNU repository record; author not listed)
- Chondogyo Scripture: Donggyeong Daejeon (Great Scripture of Eastern Learning). University Press of America, 2007 (publisher listing)
- Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica: Adverse events in meditation practices and meditation-based therapies: a systematic review, 142(5):374–393 (PubMed)
- IOCDF — What is OCD & Scrupulosity?
Also cited:
- Lindahl et al. 2017, PLOS ONE: Varieties of Contemplative Experience [uncertain: not verified].
- Treleaven (2018). Trauma-sensitive mindfulness [uncertain: not verified].
- Vieten et al. (2013). Spiritual and religious competencies [uncertain: not verified].
- American Psychiatric Association. DSM-5-TR, Cultural Formulation Interview and the code for a religious or spiritual problem.
- ICD-10-CM Z65.8, Other specified problems related to psychosocial circumstances (includes 'Religious or spiritual problem'), https://www.unboundmedicine.com/icd/view/ICD-10-CM/945432/all/Z65_8___Other_specified_problems_related_to_psychosocial_circumstances
- Cheetah House (Britton) resources [uncertain: not verified].