Atlas›Domain XV · Nature, philosophy, social & rites of passage›Guide 003
Guide XV-003

Shepard's developmental ecopsychology

Paul Shepard1982
A 32 · L 41 · M 2721 interventions in the Trinity explorer
Client cardCompare
[source: …] where a claim comes from[uncertain] not confirmed in a primary source[synthesis] the writer's reconstruction

1. Introduction

Version followed: Paul Shepard, Nature and Madness (San Francisco: Sierra Club Books, c1982; reissued Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press, 1998, foreword by C. L. Rawlins), as its thesis is quoted and summarised by Florence R. Shepard and Kathryn Ann Morton (2007), the publisher, and reviewers; derived therapist procedures are marked [synthesis]. [source: University of Southern Indiana library record; UGA Press; Shepard & Morton 2007] (One encyclopedia entry gives the Sierra Club date as 1992 [uncertain: secondary, unverified]; the library record gives c1982.)

Shepard's developmental ecopsychology is a theory, not a therapy. Shepard (1925–1996), a biologist and human ecologist who taught at Pitzer College and Claremont Graduate University, argued that human psychological development evolved in long interaction with the natural world, and that contact with nature from early childhood through adolescence is necessary for healthy emotional and mental maturation [source: Kowinski review, CNPS; Shepard & Morton 2007]. On his account, the individual's bonding moves from the mother or caregiver to the wider earth ("bonding-to-mother to bonding-to-Mother-Nature", in one reviewer's summary) [source: Gable review, Encounters with Nature]. Where modern societies cut that sequence short, he held, people remain in a state of immaturity, which he linked to an "infantile dream" of omnipotence and to the ambivalent, controlling relationship with the earth that underlies the ecological crisis [source: Shepard & Morton 2007, quoting Nature and Madness p. 99; UGA Press]. Secondary summaries describe this as an "arrested development" thesis drawing on the biological idea of neoteny, with many people in post-agricultural societies described as stuck in infantilism or an adolescent state [uncertain: secondary, unverified].

Core idea of change, as attributed to Shepard: the developmental needs are still present and recoverable. The book's publisher quotes the line "There is a secret person undamaged in every individual" and describes the book as proposing ways to "repair broken bonds with the earth, our past, and nature" [source: UGA Press]. Shepard did not write a clinical method. Clinicians and nature-based guides who draw on the theory (for example, developmental nature mentoring, see 009, and Bill Plotkin's nature-based developmental wheel at the Animas Valley Institute) give it practical form; how directly each draws on Shepard is [uncertain: not verified]. Evidence status: Shepard's developmental thesis has not been tested as a clinical model [uncertain: not verified]; separately, a 2021 systematic review and meta-analysis (Coventry et al., 50 studies, 16 RCTs) found nature-based interventions reduced depressive mood and anxiety and improved affect in the RCTs, with weaker evidence for physical health and low-to-moderate risk of bias in the RCTs [source: Coventry et al. 2021, DOAJ record].

2. Framework

Shepard's own framework is a sequence of developmental periods, not treatment phases [source: Shepard & Morton 2007; Gable review; Kowinski review]:

  • Infancy and early childhood: attachment to caregivers. Florence Shepard and Morton describe Paul Shepard as coming to see the "supreme importance" of a child's attachment first to caregivers and then to the earth, as precursors to healthy separation.
  • Childhood: bonding with place, animals and the named natural world. Reviewers describe the shift of bonding from mother to the earth as critical; Shepard wrote of a "deep human need for name learning and classifying" (n. 14, p. 137) and treated place and animals as grounding for identity and cognition [source: Shepard & Morton 2007; Gable review].
  • Adolescence: transition to a new wholeness. Shepard described adolescence as a time to "become whole at a new level of consciousness" (p. 68), and self-identity as requiring "coming to terms with the wild and uncontrollable within" (p. 33) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007]. The role he gave to initiation and mentors in this period is [uncertain: not verified].
  • Maturity. The "dream of omnipotence" of infancy should diminish with maturity (p. 99); its persistence is the sign of incomplete development in Shepard's account [source: Shepard & Morton 2007].

A related but distinct model: Bill Plotkin's eight-stage wheel, arranged by the seasons, assigns each stage a "nature task" and a "culture task" (e.g. in middle childhood, learning "the enchantment of the natural world" through outdoor immersion alongside family and cultural values), and describes "arrested personal development" in Western societies [source: Plotkin 2008 excerpt, Shift]. This is Plotkin's model, not Shepard's.

Using the framework in therapy [synthesis]. No source gives session counts, a session format or criteria for moving between phases. A workable structure for a therapist integrating the ideas into an existing therapy:

  • Phase A, orientation and assessment: screen for suitability and safety; take a developmental nature history; agree how the framework will and will not be used (a lens, never a diagnosis). Move on when the client has a shared formulation and goals.
  • Phase B, re-engagement: graded, client-chosen contact with place, other species and seasons, between or within sessions, and reflective work on attachment, place, body and control. Move on when the client reports a felt relationship with at least one place or practice and can link it to the treatment goals.
  • Phase C, transition and integration: meaning-making around missed or incomplete transitions, optional referral to a nature-based programme or rite-of-passage provider, and debriefing. Move on when gains are carried into daily life without the therapist.
  • Phase D, consolidation and ending: relapse plan, continuing practices, community links.

Format: individual or group, indoors with between-session practice, or partly outdoors (see walk-and-talk and outdoor therapy entries in this family) [synthesis].

3. Guiding principles

  • Attribute the theory; do not assert it. Present the developmental thesis as Shepard's argument. Practical meaning: say "Shepard argued…", and let the client decide what fits [synthesis; rule from source framing].
  • Never use "arrested" or "immature" as a label for a client. The thesis is a cultural critique, not a diagnosis. Practical meaning: frame missed experiences as unmet needs, not deficits of the person [synthesis].
  • Hope: the developmental impulse is still there. Shepard's publisher quotes his claim that the genuine impulse cannot be lost [source: UGA Press]. Practical meaning: work from curiosity and capacity rather than repair of damage [synthesis].
  • Attachment comes before separation. Caregiver attachment and then attachment to the earth precede healthy separation [source: Shepard & Morton 2007]. Practical meaning: assess and strengthen relational security before encouraging solitary or challenging nature experiences [synthesis].
  • Place matters. Shepard treated place as a grounding of being [source: Gable review]. Practical meaning: work with the client's actual local places, not idealised wilderness [synthesis].
  • Knowing by naming. Shepard posited a deep need for name learning and classifying [source: Shepard & Morton 2007, citing p. 137]. Practical meaning: concrete, specific attention (this tree, this bird) is preferred to general "nature" [synthesis].
  • Other species as teachers of otherness. Shepard's "Message from a Bear" calls animals our first lesson in otherness [source: CENSE]. Practical meaning: observation and respect for wild animals, never handling or feeding them [synthesis].
  • The wild within is to be met, not conquered. Self-identity requires coming to terms with the wild and uncontrollable within (p. 33) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007]. Practical meaning: emotion-acceptance stance toward impulses and feelings [synthesis].
  • Body and language are linked. Shepard tied how we feel about our bodies to how we use language (p. 86) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007]. Practical meaning: help the client find words for sensed bodily experience [synthesis].
  • Relinquish omnipotence. Mature development lets go of the infantile dream of omnipotence (p. 99) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007]. Practical meaning: work toward acceptance of limits and interdependence, not control [synthesis].
  • Question dualism. Shepard criticised an "implacable and irrational dualism" (p. 60) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007]. Practical meaning: explore splits (mind and body, self and world) in the client's thinking without imposing a worldview [synthesis].
  • Culture and accessibility. Many clients did not grow up with access to green space, or associate the outdoors with danger, racism, poverty or labour [synthesis]. Practical meaning: never romanticise; adapt to urban, indoor and disability-accessible options.
  • Safety first outdoors. Weather, terrain, ticks, allergies, hydration and access are checked qualitatively before any outdoor element, using the programme's published safety guidance [synthesis].
  • Competence and roles. Deliver only what you are trained for; a therapist who is also a nature guide or mentor manages a potential multiple relationship (APA Ethics Code Standard 3.05) [source: APA Ethics Code]; confidentiality and boundaries outdoors are agreed in advance [synthesis].
  • Client as author. Any practice or ritual of re-connection is designed with and owned by the client [synthesis].

4. Intervention inventory

Shepard's work is a theory and gives no clinical procedures; the procedures below translate its stated themes into therapist practice and are [synthesis] unless a source tag says otherwise. Each names the Shepard theme it draws on.

4.1 Suitability, safety and consent screening

  • Purpose / when: before any outdoor element or nature-based homework; at intake when a client asks for nature-based work [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Ask about physical health, mobility, allergies (pollen, insect stings, plants), medicines that affect heat tolerance or alertness, and whether the client's physician has advised limits on exertion; route any exertion questions to the physician or a qualified exercise professional and give no exercise targets. (2) Ask about fears and traumatic experiences linked to outdoors, animals, darkness, being alone, or particular places (including assault, racism or harassment in public spaces). (3) Screen current risk (suicidality, dissociation, psychosis, substance use, eating difficulties) and whether solitary outdoor time could raise risk. (4) Explain options (indoor, garden, urban park, outdoors with the therapist, external programme), and that the client may decline any element at any time. (5) Record consent, including for outdoor confidentiality limits.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Some of this work can happen outside, some can stay in this room. Before we choose, can I ask about anything that makes being outdoors, or around animals, difficult or risky for you?"
  • Watch for: idealised expectations of nature as a cure; hidden fears; physical conditions that need medical input; a wish to use solitary wild time to escape rather than engage. Working when the client can name what feels safe, what does not, and their right to stop.

4.2 Introducing the framework as an attributed lens

  • Purpose / when: when the client's concerns include disconnection, rootlessness, ecological distress or a sense of never having "grown up"; or when the client has read Shepard [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Summarise in plain words that Shepard, a human ecologist, argued development needs contact with the natural world through childhood and adolescence, and that modern life interrupts it [source: Kowinski review; Shepard & Morton 2007]. (2) Say clearly that this is a theory, not an established clinical finding. (3) Ask what resonates and what does not. (4) Agree whether to use it as a lens, and in what language.
  • Example language (illustrative): "One writer, Paul Shepard, argued that people need a living relationship with the land as they grow, and that many of us missed parts of that. It's a theory, not a test result. Does any of it fit your experience?"
  • Watch for: the client using "arrested development" against themselves or others; wholesale conversion to an ideology; dismissive rejection that then becomes a rupture. Working when the client engages critically and picks what is useful.

4.3 Developmental nature history

  • Purpose / when: early assessment; draws on Shepard's sequence of caregiver attachment, then attachment to the earth, then adolescent transition [source: Shepard & Morton 2007; Gable review].
  • Steps: (1) Walk through life periods: earliest memories of outdoor places, animals, weather and seasons; middle childhood roaming, play and named places; adolescence and any marked transitions; adulthood. (2) For each, ask who was with the client, whether it felt safe, and what was lost or forbidden. (3) Note displacement, migration, urbanisation, disability, poverty, caring duties and danger that shaped access. (4) Draw a simple timeline together. (5) Link themes to current difficulties in a tentative formulation.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Where did you spend time outside when you were about eight or nine? Who was there, and what was it like to come home?"
  • Watch for: trauma memories tied to places (pace and contain); grief for lost homelands; shame about having had little nature contact. Working when the client finds specific memories and links them, without self-blame, to the present.

4.4 Mapping attachment from caregivers to place

  • Purpose / when: when attachment insecurity and rootlessness co-occur; draws on the attachment-then-earth sequence [source: Shepard & Morton 2007; Gable review].
  • Steps: (1) Explore the client's early caregiving relationships in the usual way for your modality. (2) Ask whether any place, tree, animal or landscape functioned as a secure base or refuge. (3) Identify present-day places that feel steadying. (4) Plan small, regular contact with one such place as a support, alongside, not instead of, human relationships.
  • Example language (illustrative): "When home didn't feel safe, was there anywhere you went that did? A field, a tree, a corner of a park?"
  • Watch for: using places to avoid people; a refuge that was also a site of harm. Working when the client can draw on a steadying place and on people.

4.5 Returning to one place

  • Purpose / when: to build the relationship with place that Shepard treated as grounding for identity [source: Gable review]; between-session practice.
  • Steps: (1) Help the client choose one accessible, safe local place (a garden, a park bench, a window view if mobility or safety rules out going out). (2) Agree a realistic, client-set pattern of visits; give no time or frequency targets. (3) Invite open attention to what changes: light, plants, birds, sounds, weather. (4) Bring observations to session. (5) Review safety (lone visits, lighting, weather, ticks, terrain) using local park or programme guidance.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Rather than going somewhere special, could we pick one ordinary place you can get to easily, and see what you notice there over the coming weeks?"
  • Watch for: performance pressure; unsafe locations; the practice becoming another chore. Working when the client reports a sense of familiarity or belonging with the place.

4.6 Name learning

  • Purpose / when: to engage concrete attention and a sense of a known world; draws on Shepard's "deep human need for name learning and classifying" (Nature and Madness, n. 14, p. 137) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007].
  • Steps: (1) Invite the client to learn the names of a few plants, trees, birds or insects in their place, using a field guide, local wildlife group or app. (2) Encourage noticing distinguishing features before looking up a name. (3) Discuss what knowing a name changes in how the client relates to it. (4) Never encourage picking, tasting or handling unknown plants or fungi.
  • Example language (illustrative): "You mentioned the birds outside your flat. Would you be curious to find out what two or three of them are called, and see whether that changes how you see them?"
  • Watch for: perfectionism or collecting as compulsion; foraging risk. Working when the client describes the local world as more familiar and specific.

4.7 Observing other species

  • Purpose / when: to explore otherness, respect and relationship; draws on Shepard's "Message from a Bear", which calls animals our first lesson in otherness [source: CENSE].
  • Steps: (1) Invite quiet observation of wild animals at a respectful distance (garden birds, insects, urban wildlife). (2) Ask what the client noticed about the animal's own life. (3) Explore what the encounter evoked (envy, tenderness, fear, kinship). (4) Set boundaries: no handling, feeding or approaching wildlife; follow local wildlife and park guidance. For work with domestic or therapy animals see the animal-assisted family.
  • Example language (illustrative): "What did you notice the crow doing that had nothing to do with you?"
  • Watch for: animal phobias or trauma with animals; projection that overrides observation. Working when the client can hold the animal as other and still feel connected.

4.8 Meeting the wild within

  • Purpose / when: for clients at war with their own impulses, anger, sexuality or vitality; draws on Shepard's view that self-identity requires "coming to terms with the wild and uncontrollable within" (p. 33) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007].
  • Steps: (1) Identify the feelings or urges the client experiences as uncontrollable. (2) Explore their function and history. (3) Use your modality's acceptance or emotion-regulation methods to make room for them without acting on them harmfully. (4) Optionally use nature imagery the client offers (weather, animals, rivers) as metaphor, letting the client choose it.
  • Example language (illustrative): "If this anger were part of the weather rather than a flaw in you, what kind of weather would it be, and what does it need?"
  • Watch for: romanticising harmful behaviour as "wild"; risk to self or others (assess and act on risk in the usual way). Working when the client can feel strong states with less fear and more choice.

4.9 Bridging body and language

  • Purpose / when: for clients disconnected from bodily experience; draws on Shepard's link between how we feel about our bodies and how we use language (p. 86) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007].
  • Steps: (1) During a quiet moment outdoors or by a window, invite attention to sensations (air, ground, temperature as felt, sound). (2) Ask the client to find their own words for what they sense. (3) Notice evaluative or alienated language about the body and explore it. (4) Keep any outdoor element gentle and non-strenuous; no exertion or exposure targets.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Without judging it, what word would you give the feeling in your feet right now?"
  • Watch for: dissociation, body shame, eating-disorder cognitions (screen and refer to an eating-disorder service or registered dietitian as needed). Working when the client's body language becomes more precise and less hostile.

4.10 Working with omnipotence and control

  • Purpose / when: for perfectionism, control struggles, grandiosity or despair at limits; draws on Shepard's claim that the "dream of omnipotence is an infantile dream" that should diminish with maturity (p. 99) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007].
  • Steps: (1) Identify where the client expects to control what cannot be controlled (other people, outcomes, the body, the climate). (2) Use observation of natural processes the client cannot direct (growth, decay, weather) as shared examples, if the client finds them apt. (3) Separate what is in the client's influence from what is not, using your modality's tools. (4) Work toward acceptance and interdependence.
  • Example language (illustrative): "The garden didn't wait for you to be ready. What would it be like to treat some of your life that way?"
  • Watch for: the client hearing "infantile" as an insult (never use the word about them); fatalism. Working when the client tolerates uncertainty with less distress.

4.11 Exploring splits and dualisms

  • Purpose / when: when the client's thinking is organised around sharp splits (mind versus body, people versus nature, civilised versus wild); draws on Shepard's critique of an "implacable and irrational dualism" (p. 60) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007].
  • Steps: (1) Notice splits in the client's language. (2) Ask what each side protects. (3) Explore experiences in which both sides were present. (4) Respect the client's religious and philosophical commitments; this is exploration, not persuasion (use the DSM-5-TR Cultural Formulation Interview and its spirituality, religion and moral traditions module where faith is central [uncertain: not verified]).
  • Example language (illustrative): "You describe your mind and your body as if they were on opposite teams. Has there been a time they felt like the same team?"
  • Watch for: imposing an ecological worldview; conflict with the client's faith. Working when the client holds more nuance.

4.12 Reviewing the adolescent transition

  • Purpose / when: for clients who feel they never crossed into adulthood or whose adolescence was disrupted; draws on Shepard's view of adolescence as a time to "become whole at a new level of consciousness" (p. 68) [source: Shepard & Morton 2007].
  • Steps: (1) Explore what adolescence was like: separations, mentors, rites or their absence, recognition by adults. (2) Name what was missing or harmful, and what was achieved. (3) Grieve losses. (4) Identify what recognition or responsibility the client now wants, and how they might seek it (community roles, mentoring others, a client-designed marker of transition, see 4.21). (5) If the client is interested in a structured rite of passage, see 104 (wilderness rites of passage) and XI 096 (vision quest), and prepare as in 4.18.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Was there a moment when the adults around you recognised you as no longer a child? What would you have wanted that moment to be?"
  • Watch for: hazing or abusive initiations in the history (assess, cross-refer Domain XVI, do not describe); shame; family conflict. Working when the client can tell a coherent story of the transition and feel agency now.

4.13 Developmental wheel mapping (Plotkin's model)

  • Purpose / when: for clients who want a structured developmental map; uses Bill Plotkin's model, which is distinct from Shepard's [source: Plotkin 2008 excerpt; Brussat review].
  • Steps: (1) Describe Plotkin's eight stages as he names them (for example "The Innocent in the Nest", "The Explorer in the Garden", "The Wanderer in the Cocoon") and his pairing of a nature task and a culture task in each stage, attributed to him [source: Brussat review; Plotkin 2008 excerpt]. (2) Invite the client to consider where they see themselves, without ranking. (3) Explore which nature and culture tasks feel unfinished. (4) Set small goals for each.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Bill Plotkin, who founded the Animas Valley Institute, suggests each life stage has a task with the natural world and a task with one's culture. Which of those feels more unfinished for you?"
  • Watch for: using the stage as a judgement; spiritual concepts the client does not share. Working when the map helps the client name next steps.

4.14 Ecological grief and ambivalence

  • Purpose / when: for climate anxiety and ecological grief; Shepard's publisher describes the book as tracing an ambivalence in which we both appreciate nature and "seek to plunder, alter, and control" it [source: UGA Press].
  • Steps: (1) Validate distress as a response to real losses. (2) Explore the client's own ambivalence (love of nature alongside participation in harm) without moralising. (3) Separate grief, guilt and fear. (4) Identify meaningful action and community. (5) Offer groups such as the Climate Psychology Alliance or Good Grief Network as their organisers describe them [uncertain: not verified].
  • Example language (illustrative): "It makes sense to grieve what's being lost. Can we look at how much of what you feel is grief, how much is guilt, and how much is fear?"
  • Watch for: hopelessness and suicidal thinking (assess in the usual way; crisis resources: 988 in the US, Samaritans 116 123 in the UK and Ireland); activism burnout. Working when the client can feel grief and still act and rest.

4.15 Parent and family consultation on children's nature contact

  • Purpose / when: when working with parents, or with child and adolescent clients; draws on Shepard's argument (as a reviewer summarises it) that contact with nature from early childhood through adolescence is essential to healthy development [source: Kowinski review].
  • Steps: (1) Ask what outdoor play and nature contact the child has. (2) Explore barriers (safety, time, money, housing, screens, disability). (3) Agree small, family-led steps, framed as play rather than prescription. (4) Address safeguarding and supervision appropriate to age. (5) Never present the child's difficulties as caused by lack of nature; assess and refer for developmental or mental-health concerns in the usual way.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Some writers argue children need time to roam and play outside. What would be realistic for your family, given everything you're juggling?"
  • Watch for: parental guilt; delaying assessment of real developmental needs; unsupervised risk. Working when the family finds achievable contact and the child enjoys it.

4.16 Setting up outdoor sessions

  • Purpose / when: when therapist and client choose to meet outdoors [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Agree confidentiality limits: being seen or overheard, meeting people the client knows, what to do if that happens. (2) Agree boundaries: no touch except with consent asked first and the right to stop; travel arrangements; who carries what. (3) Plan for weather, terrain, accessibility, ticks, allergies and hydration qualitatively, with a wet-weather or indoor alternative. (4) Agree how to end if the client becomes distressed. (5) Check professional insurance covers outdoor work. (6) See the walk-and-talk and outdoor therapy entries in this family; avoid water-based activity (see 022 and X 196 for water risks).
  • Example language (illustrative): "If we bump into someone you know, how would you like me to handle it?"
  • Watch for: blurred roles (it is still therapy); physical fatigue; unplanned disclosures in public. Working when the client feels safe and the setting supports the work.

4.17 Referral and collaboration with nature-based providers

  • Purpose / when: when a client wants more than therapy can offer (nature mentoring, guided programmes, green social prescribing, see 009 and 015) [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Clarify the client's aims. (2) Research the provider's training, safety policies, insurance, screening and whether it is therapy or not. For example, the Animas Valley Institute states its mentoring is offered directly by trained guides and "is not administered by the Animas Valley Institute office", and contrasts its wholeness focus with psychotherapy's [source: Animas Valley Institute]. (3) With consent, share relevant information. (4) Agree roles: who handles risk, who the client contacts in crisis.
  • Example language (illustrative): "This programme isn't therapy, and that may be part of its value. Let's check what support they offer if something difficult comes up, and how we'll stay in touch."
  • Watch for: providers making clinical claims; unscreened intensive or solitary experiences; the client dropping therapy abruptly. Working when the roles are clear and the client feels supported in both.

4.18 Preparing a client for a programme or rite

  • Purpose / when: before a client attends a nature-based retreat, mentoring process or rite of passage [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Review the programme's own information on content, safety and screening. (2) Discuss intentions and expectations. (3) Identify triggers and a plan for distress, including contacts. (4) Check medical clearance where the programme requires it, without advising on medicines. (5) Plan the return: time, people and the first session after.
  • Example language (illustrative): "What are you hoping happens, and what would you do if it got harder than expected?"
  • Watch for: grandiose expectations; pressure from others to attend; undisclosed risk. Working when the client goes with realistic hopes and a plan.

4.19 Debriefing and integration

  • Purpose / when: after a programme, rite or significant nature experience [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Invite the story in the client's own words. (2) Ask about difficult moments and any harm. (3) Identify meanings and commitments. (4) Translate them into daily practices and relationships. (5) Monitor for a let-down after return.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Tell me what happened, and then let's look at what you want to bring back into your ordinary week."
  • Watch for: destabilisation, dissociation or unusual experiences that need assessment; coercive or harmful group practices (cross-refer the relevant harm accounts). Working when the experience becomes part of a continuing life rather than an isolated peak.

4.20 Working with the client's meaning of nature

  • Purpose / when: throughout; for clients for whom land carries spiritual, cultural or ancestral meaning [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Ask what nature, land or particular places mean in the client's family, culture or faith. (2) Use the Cultural Formulation Interview where relevant [uncertain: not verified]. (3) Respect Indigenous and religious understandings as the communities hold them; do not borrow ceremonies. (4) Collaborate with the client's religious or community leader if the client wishes.
  • Example language (illustrative): "In your family, what does the land back home mean?"
  • Watch for: cultural appropriation by therapist or programme; conflict between Shepard's frame and the client's tradition. Working when the client's own meanings lead.

4.21 Client-authored marker of reconnection

  • Purpose / when: to mark a transition or recommitment (e.g. after 4.12 or 4.19) [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Invite the client to design a simple, safe personal marker (planting something, returning to a place from childhood, writing a letter to a place). (2) The client chooses its form, place and witnesses. (3) Check safety and legality (land access, no fires or water entry). (4) Reflect on it afterwards.
  • Example language (illustrative): "If you wanted to mark this change in some way that's yours, what might it look like?"
  • Watch for: the therapist designing it; borrowed ceremonies; unsafe locations. Working when the client experiences it as their own.

5. Handling problems

The sources do not address clinical problems; all guidance below is [synthesis].

  • Client feels judged as "immature". Repair immediately: acknowledge the theory's language can sound like a verdict, restate that it is a cultural critique of how societies raise people, not a label for them, and drop the term. Return to the client's own words.
  • Client rejects the framework. Treat it as one optional lens. Continue with the client's goals using the practical elements they find useful (place, attention, attachment) without the theory, or set it aside entirely.
  • Romanticising nature or hunter-gatherer life. Gently explore what the ideal protects against; bring in real limits and the client's actual circumstances; avoid confirming claims about "original" human nature as fact.
  • Ideological absorption. If the client adopts primitivist or anti-civilisation views that isolate them or justify harm, explore function and consequences; assess risk to self or others; keep therapy focused on the client's wellbeing and relationships.
  • Stuck: no access to nature. Use window views, house plants, urban wildlife, natural materials indoors, memory and imagery; address practical barriers; consider green social prescribing (015) or community gardens.
  • Non-adherence to between-session practice. Explore meaning (another obligation, shame, fear, fatigue, depression); shrink the task; let the client set it; use behavioural-activation framing (see II 040) without exercise or duration targets.
  • Overwhelm or trauma activation outdoors. Stop, ground, move to a safer spot or indoors; review triggers; revise the plan; return to stabilisation before further outdoor work.
  • Grief for lost places or homelands. Treat as grief: name the loss, allow mourning, explore continuing bonds with the place, connect to diaspora community.
  • Ecological despair or suicidal thinking. Assess risk using standard practice; safety plan; crisis resources 988 (US) and Samaritans 116 123 (UK and Ireland); balance action with rest and connection.
  • Physical safety incidents (ticks, stings, falls, weather). Follow first-aid and programme guidance, seek medical help as needed, document, and review the risk plan; do not continue outdoor work until the plan is updated.
  • Confidentiality breach outdoors. Follow the pre-agreed plan; debrief in the next session; offer to move indoors.
  • Rupture over boundaries outdoors (touch, informality, dual roles). Name it, take responsibility, return to agreed boundaries; if the therapist is also the client's guide or mentor in another setting, review the multiple relationship against APA Ethics Code Standard 3.05 and consider separating roles.
  • Harm from an external programme. Believe and assess; support reporting where appropriate; cross-refer the wilderness and troubled-teen harm account (025) and Domain XVI where hazing or coercion is involved.
  • Children and young people. Safeguarding first; consent from parents or carers and the young person's assent; supervision appropriate to age; never let a nature-based plan delay assessment of developmental, learning or mental-health needs.
  • Spiritual or religious conflict. If the client's distress centres on faith, the DSM-5-TR "Religious or Spiritual Problem" may be named (coded Z65.8 in ICD-10-CM, which lists religious or spiritual problem under its Includes notes) [source: ICD-10-CM Z65.8, Unbound Medicine]; DSM-5-TR wording [uncertain: not verified]. Offer collaboration with the client's religious leader if they wish.
  • Therapist's own enthusiasm. Supervision helps when the therapist's own love of nature or of Shepard's ideas pushes the work beyond the client's goals.

Sources

← Previous · XV-002Psychoecology and the wilderness effect (Greenway)Next · XV-004 →Abram's phenomenology of the more-than-human world