1. Introduction
Version followed: the methods as their sellers and promoters describe them (the US lifestyle company Goop's jade and quartz "eggs" as reported in the 2018 California settlement coverage; vaginal steaming as promoted by retail suppliers and practitioner-training businesses such as Steamy Chick and its Peristeam Hydrotherapy Institute), set against gynaecology and public-health statements. The psychotherapist works alongside this method and never performs, sells, prescribes or recommends either practice. The intervention inventory (section 4) is the therapist's own work with a client who uses, is considering, or has been harmed by them.
Vaginal steaming (also "V-steaming", "yoni steaming"; promoters' term "peristeam hydrotherapy") means sitting or squatting over hot water infused with herbs, usually with a cloth wrapped around the lower body to hold the steam in. Promoters attribute to it hormone balancing, "uterine detox", faster postpartum recovery, fertility, menstrual and reproductive health, energy, pain and stress relief. Gynaecologists state there is no scientific evidence for these claims and that steam reaches only the outer vagina, not the cervix or uterus. [source: Cleveland Clinic; Live Science; eLotus biography of Keli Garza]
Jade ("yoni") eggs are egg-shaped stones (jade, rose quartz and others) placed in the vagina. Goop sold them from January 2017 with claims that they tightened the pelvic floor like Kegel exercises, cultivated "sexual energy", cleared "chi pathways", balanced hormones, regulated menstrual cycles and improved bladder control, and that they were a closely guarded secret of ancient Chinese royalty or temple concubines. [source: MinnPost; KFF Health News summarising the New York Times and Washington Post]
Core idea of change, as promoters hold it: steaming is said to cleanse, warm and "detoxify" the womb; the egg is said to train the pelvic floor and move sexual or life energy (qi/chi). These are attributed claims within the practices' own frameworks. Evidence status (one line): no scientific evidence supports any of the claimed health benefits, and burns and infection risks are documented or warned of by gynaecologists. [source: Cleveland Clinic; Africa Check; MinnPost]
For the psychotherapist, change happens through a non-judgemental conversation that surfaces what the client hopes these practices will do (fertility, intimacy, control of symptoms, feeling clean, identity), connects the client safely to gynaecological or pelvic-health care, and addresses shame, anxiety, trauma or relationship pressure that may drive use. [synthesis]
2. Framework
2a. The practices as published
- What a client experiences (vaginal steaming). Sessions take place at home with a purchased kit, or in spas, wellness studios or with a "vaginal steam facilitator". The client sits over a steaming herbal infusion, clothed from the waist up and wrapped below; facilitators commonly use intake forms and postpartum waivers. Steaming is also a long-standing traditional practice in parts of Africa and Asia (see below). No technique, herbs, temperatures or durations are given here. [source: Cleveland Clinic; Live Science] [uncertain: facilitator intake and waiver practice not verified]
- What a client experiences (jade eggs). The client buys a stone egg, sometimes with a drilled hole and string, and inserts it vaginally, often with promoted "practices" or courses. No insertion or wear instructions are given here. [source: MinnPost] [uncertain: string and course details not verified]
- Who practises or sells it. Lifestyle brands (Goop's endorsement of steaming in 2015 popularised it in North America); retail suppliers; spas; doulas, acupuncturists and other wellness practitioners. Keli Garza is reported as owner of Steamy Chick, described as the largest US distributor of vaginal steam supplies, and founder of the Peristeam Hydrotherapy Institute, which trains practitioners; she has taught an introductory continuing-education course framing steaming within Chinese medicine on the acupuncture platform eLotus. [source: Live Science; eLotus biography]
- Traditional context. A WHO-supported multi-country study of vaginal practices (Indonesia, Mozambique, South Africa, Thailand; household survey of 3,610 women in 2006–2007) found such practices common and motivated variously by hygiene, femininity, health, sexual pleasure and keeping a partner's commitment; the authors concluded they are "not as rare, exotic, or benign" as assumed. Steaming in these settings is reported for wellness, identity, postpartum recovery, vaginal tightening and beauty. An ancient Greek "fumigation" practice tied to the "wandering womb" belief is cited as a Western antecedent. [source: Hull et al. 2011 abstract; WHO 2012 brief page; Cleveland Clinic]
- Regulation and licensing. No jurisdiction among the US, UK, Canada or Australia is known to license steaming facilitators or to have authorised jade eggs for any health use [uncertain: not verified]. Health claims for both are subject to advertising and consumer-protection law: in 2018 Goop paid USD 145,000 in civil penalties in a California consumer-protection case over unsubstantiated claims for its jade and rose-quartz eggs and a flower-essence blend marketed to help prevent depression; Goop said it settled over the claims, not the products [source: KFF Health News, citing the New York Times and Washington Post]. The case was brought by the California Food, Drug, and Medical Device Task Force, a group of ten county district attorneys' offices including Orange and Santa Clara, and filed in Napa County Superior Court; the judgment also requires refunds on request for the three products bought between 12 January and 31 August 2017, and bars Goop from efficacy claims without competent and reliable scientific evidence and from selling misbranded, unapproved or falsely advertised medical devices [source: Orange County District Attorney press release, 4 September 2018].
- Regulatory status (one line): consumer products and unregulated services; health claims have been the subject of consumer-protection enforcement in California.
- Evidence status (one line): no scientific evidence for claimed benefits; ACOG does not recommend steaming; the NHS advises the vagina cleans itself. [source: Africa Check; Cleveland Clinic]
2b. The psychotherapist's work alongside it [synthesis]
This is not a stand-alone treatment; it is a strand within ongoing therapy, revisited as needed.
- Ask and record: routine, neutral enquiry about complementary and body practices, including intimate ones. Move on when use is known and recorded.
- Understand: the client's meaning, hopes, explanatory model and cultural or relational context. Move on when you can state in the client's words what they want from the practice.
- Check for risk: burns, infection signs, delayed medical care, pregnancy or postpartum status, pelvic symptoms, coercion, young people. Any red flag moves straight to coordination or urgent advice.
- Decide and coordinate: values-based decision-making; with consent, liaison with the GP, gynaecologist or pelvic-health physiotherapist.
- Address psychological drivers: genital shame, health anxiety, sexual pain, trauma, body image, partner pressure, cross-referring to Domain II.
- Review: revisit at natural points (after medical appointments, postpartum, after new symptoms).
3. Guiding principles
- Never perform, sell, prescribe or recommend. You do not advise on steaming or eggs, their herbs or stones; you route health questions to medical care. [synthesis]
- Curiosity without judgement. Shame stops disclosure; neutral questions keep the door open. (APA Principle E: respect for dignity, self-determination and cultural difference.) [source: APA Ethics Code]
- Culture is not pathology. Traditional vaginal practices carry identity and meaning; explore them respectfully while still naming physical risk. [source: Hull et al. 2011] [synthesis]
- Attribute, do not adjudicate. Describe qi, "womb detox" or "sexual energy" as the practice holds them; neither affirm them as fact nor mock them. [synthesis]
- Physical symptoms go to physical care. Prolapse, discharge, itching, pain, bleeding, odour, incontinence or fertility concerns need a doctor or pelvic-health physiotherapist. Practical meaning: every symptom mentioned triggers an offer to help the client get seen. [source: Cleveland Clinic; Africa Check; NICE NG210]
- No touch, no examination, no technique talk. The therapist does not touch the client's body for this work and discusses intimate anatomy only in clinical, non-explicit terms. [synthesis]
- Stay within competence. Sexual-health and pelvic-pain work beyond your training is referred or supervised (APA 2.01). [source: APA Ethics Code]
- Base judgements on established knowledge (APA 2.04): psychoeducation draws on gynaecological and public-health sources, not on marketing. [source: APA Ethics Code]
- No conflicts of interest. Do not sell or refer to businesses in which you have a stake (APA 3.06). [source: APA Ethics Code]
- Cooperate with other professionals with consent (APA 3.09; 4.05 for disclosures). [source: APA Ethics Code]
- Autonomy with safety. Adults may choose; your job is that the choice is informed, free of coercion, and does not delay needed care. [synthesis]
- Trauma-informed stance. Intimate-health conversations can evoke sexual trauma; offer choice and control over pace and words. [synthesis]
4. Intervention inventory
All interventions below are the psychotherapist's own work. Sources for the facts used are cited; procedures are [synthesis] unless stated.
4.1 Routine, non-judgemental enquiry and recording
- Purpose / when: at intake and reviews, and whenever a client mentions wellness routines, fertility, postpartum recovery, pelvic or sexual symptoms, or "detox". Intimate practices are rarely disclosed unless asked about neutrally. [synthesis]
- Steps: (1) Normalise: say you ask everyone about health practices outside medicine. (2) Ask open questions about anything they use for intimate, menstrual or pelvic health, including products bought online or at spas. (3) Ask how often in general terms, from whom, and who else knows (doctor, partner, family). (4) Do not ask for or discuss technique. (5) Record in the notes: practice, source (shop, practitioner, family tradition), reason, any symptoms, whether the doctor knows. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "Lots of people use things outside medicine for their periods, fertility or pelvic health: steams, stones, herbs, cleanses. Is anything like that part of your routine? I'm asking so I understand, not to judge."
- Watch for: embarrassment, minimising, or checking your face for disapproval; slow down and thank them. It is working when the client volunteers details and later updates you unprompted. [synthesis]
4.2 Exploring meaning, hopes, expectations and explanatory model
- Purpose / when: after disclosure, to understand why this practice and why now. Draws include feeling clean or "detoxed", fertility hope, postpartum recovery, wanting to feel tight or desirable, control over symptoms, distrust of or bad experiences with gynaecology, cultural or family tradition, community or influencer identity, and partner expectations. [source: Hull et al. 2011; Cleveland Clinic; MinnPost] [synthesis]
- Steps: (1) Ask what they hope it will do and what that would mean for their life. (2) Ask how they understand the body problem (their explanatory model: e.g. a "cold" or "dirty" womb, blocked energy, a weak pelvic floor). (3) Ask where they learned it (relative, practitioner, brand, social media). (4) Ask what medical care has offered and how that felt. (5) Reflect the underlying need (to conceive, to feel in control, to feel clean, to please a partner) in their words. (6) Note any belief that the body is dirty or shameful for later work (4.7). [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "What did you hope the steaming would change for you?" "When you picture it working, what's different?" "What have doctors said so far, and how was that for you?"
- Watch for: guilt about not conceiving or about "letting the body go" after birth; distrust of medicine rooted in dismissive or traumatic past care. Working sign: the client separates the goal (e.g. a comfortable pelvic floor) from the method. [synthesis]
4.3 Accurate, attributed information on request
- Purpose / when: when the client asks what you know, or holds a claim that could lead to harm (e.g. that steaming treats prolapse, or that an egg regulates hormones).
- Steps: (1) Ask permission before sharing. (2) Attribute claims to their source and offer what gynaecological bodies say: there is no scientific evidence for steaming's claimed benefits; ACOG does not recommend it; the NHS says the vagina cleans itself; steam reaches only the outer vagina; a gynaecologist has called the claim that jade eggs balance hormones biologically impossible; the ancient-Chinese-origin story was investigated in museum collections and described as a modern marketing myth; a California case penalised Goop for unsubstantiated egg claims. (3) Name the risks gynaecologists describe (4.6). (4) Do not prescribe an alternative product; route to the doctor or pelvic-health physiotherapist. (5) Leave room for the client's view. [source: Cleveland Clinic; Africa Check; MinnPost; KFF Health News]
- Example language (illustrative): "Would it help if I shared what gynaecologists have said about it? You can take it or leave it." "The people selling it say X; the doctors I've read say Y. What do you make of that?"
- Watch for: arguing or lecturing, which increases defensiveness. Working sign: the client asks questions back or plans to raise it with a doctor. [synthesis]
4.4 Supporting an informed, values-based decision
- Purpose / when: when the client is choosing whether to start, continue or stop, or is weighing a practice against medical care (e.g. surgery or physiotherapy for prolapse). No published decision aid specific to these practices is cited here [uncertain: not verified].
- Steps: (1) Clarify the decision and who else has a say. (2) List the client's values (natural approach, safety, fertility, cost, intimacy, cultural belonging). (3) Help them gather medical information from their clinician on options and risks. (4) Check the decision is theirs, not a partner's, seller's or group's. (5) Agree a safety plan if they continue: symptoms that mean stop and seek care (4.6). (6) Document the discussion. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "What matters most to you in deciding this?" "If you did carry on, what would tell you it's time to stop and get checked?"
- Watch for: your own urge to persuade; decisions that delay recommended medical care; a client who feels judged by either side. Working sign: a decision the client can explain in their own values. [synthesis]
4.5 Coordinating with the doctor, gynaecologist or pelvic-health physiotherapist
- Purpose / when: whenever there are pelvic, menstrual, urinary, sexual-pain or fertility symptoms, pregnancy or postpartum status, or the client is using a practice in place of care. The Canadian burn case report concluded that health care providers need to know about alternative therapies to help patients make informed choices. [source: Live Science on the JOGC case report]
- Steps: (1) Ask consent to share specific information (APA 4.05). (2) Encourage the client to tell their GP or gynaecologist what they use. (3) With consent, write or call: practice used, reason, symptoms, psychological factors (anxiety, trauma, shame) that may affect examinations or adherence. (4) For pelvic-floor problems (prolapse, incontinence, sexual dysfunction, pelvic pain), suggest asking about supervised pelvic floor muscle training by a physiotherapist or other trained professional, which NICE recommends. (5) Help the client prepare for appointments (questions list, chaperone request, how to stop an examination). (6) Follow up afterwards. [source: NICE NG210; APA Ethics Code 3.09, 4.05] [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "Would it be OK if I let your GP know you've been using a steam for the prolapse symptoms, so they can talk it through with you?" "Would it help to practise how you'd tell the physio you want to go slowly?"
- Watch for: fear of being shamed by clinicians; past traumatic examinations. Working sign: an appointment booked and attended. [synthesis]
4.6 Risk recognition and response
- Purpose / when: any session where steaming or egg use is mentioned.
- Risks as clinical sources state them:
- Burns to delicate vulvar and vaginal tissue from steam; a documented case of second-degree burns to the vagina and cervix. [source: Live Science; Cleveland Clinic]
- Infection: altered vaginal pH and bacterial balance, bacterial vaginosis or yeast infection, contaminated equipment; for jade eggs, porous stone acting as a carrier of bacteria and a warned risk of toxic shock syndrome. [source: Cleveland Clinic; MinnPost; Africa Check]
- Pelvic-floor strain, pelvic pain and pain with sex from continuous or incorrect clenching to hold an egg. [source: MinnPost]
- Pregnancy: heat exposure may cause complications, so pregnant people are advised to avoid steaming. [source: Cleveland Clinic]
- Delayed care: using steaming for a diagnosed condition (the case report involved prolapse; surgery was then delayed by the burn). [source: Live Science]
- Coercion: practices motivated by a partner's sexual expectations or commitment. [source: Hull et al. 2011] [synthesis]
- Children and adolescents: any such practice on a minor is a safeguarding question. [synthesis]
- Financial: expensive products, courses or "facilitator" certifications. [synthesis]
- Steps: (1) Ask about current symptoms: pain, burning, blisters, unusual discharge or odour, itching, bleeding, fever or feeling very unwell, or an object that cannot be removed. (2) Fever and feeling very unwell with an inserted object, severe pain or burns: advise urgent medical assessment the same day (emergency services if severe). [synthesis; toxic shock warning per MinnPost] (3) Other symptoms: advise GP or sexual-health clinic. (4) Pregnant or postpartum: encourage telling the midwife or obstetrician. (5) Minors or coercion: follow safeguarding and adult-protection procedures. (6) Document advice given. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "Since you mentioned burning, I'd like you to get checked today. Can we look at how you'll get there?"
- Watch for: reluctance to seek care because of embarrassment; that is a cue to address shame (4.7) quickly, not to wait. [synthesis]
4.7 Genital shame, "cleanliness" beliefs, health anxiety and somatic presentations
- Purpose / when: when use is driven by a belief that the genitals are dirty, smell or are "loose", by repeated checking or cleansing, or by persistent worry about pelvic or reproductive health despite reassurance. Use established approaches for health anxiety and somatic symptom presentations; see Domain II. [synthesis]
- Steps: (1) Map the cycle: trigger (sensation, odour worry, partner comment), belief, safety behaviour (steaming, cleansing, inserting), short-term relief, long-term doubt. (2) Psychoeducation from medical sources: the vagina cleans itself; perfumed products and internal cleansing can disrupt its balance. (3) Encourage one medical assessment to rule out infection or other causes, then work on reducing reassurance-seeking and cleansing rituals. (4) Address shame with compassion-focused or cognitive work on body image. (5) Screen for eating-disorder, body-dysmorphic or obsessive-compulsive features and refer as needed. [source: Africa Check citing NHS; Cleveland Clinic] [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "It sounds like the worry about being 'not clean' comes back even after you steam. Shall we map what keeps that loop going?"
- Watch for: symptoms that genuinely need medical care being labelled anxiety; always ensure assessment first. Working sign: less checking and cleansing, less distress. [synthesis]
4.8 Sexual pain, pelvic symptoms and trauma-informed care (no touch)
- Purpose / when: when an egg or steaming is used to manage pain with sex, low desire, incontinence, prolapse or postpartum changes, or when pelvic issues connect with sexual trauma.
- Steps: (1) Ask about pelvic symptoms and sexual function in plain clinical terms, with permission and the option not to answer. (2) Screen gently for trauma history; let the client set pace and vocabulary. (3) Refer pelvic and sexual-pain problems to gynaecology and pelvic-health physiotherapy; NICE describes supervised pelvic floor muscle training and advises clinicians to discuss and plan for the psychological impact of pelvic floor symptoms. (4) Offer psychological work for sexual pain, anxiety about examinations, and trauma within your competence (APA 2.01). (5) Touch boundary: the therapist does not touch the client's body or demonstrate any pelvic exercise; all work is verbal. If any body-based exercise (e.g. breathing, grounding) is used, it is hands-off, explained first, consented to before and during, and stoppable at any time; nothing is sexual or genital. Intimate examinations belong to medical clinicians, who should offer a chaperone and document consent according to their professional bodies [uncertain: chaperone guidance not verified]. (6) Help the client prepare to assert choice in examinations (asking to stop, asking for a chaperone or a different clinician). [source: NICE NG210; APA Ethics Code] [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "You can tell me as much or as little as you want about this. We can use whatever words feel OK." "A pelvic-health physiotherapist is the specialist for this kind of muscle problem. Would you like help working out how to ask for a referral?"
- Watch for: dissociation, freezing or flushing during the conversation; pause, ground, and give control back. Working sign: the client reaches specialist care and feels able to set limits there. [synthesis]
4.9 Cultural, family and partner context
- Purpose / when: when steaming or other vaginal practices are part of family or community tradition, postpartum customs, or a partner's sexual expectations. The multi-country study found sexual motivations (pleasure, keeping a partner's commitment) common at some sites and femininity and health at others. [source: Hull et al. 2011]
- Steps: (1) Ask what the practice means in their family or community. (2) Distinguish freely chosen tradition from pressure (from partner, in-laws, elders). (3) Ask whether they would continue if no one else expected it. (4) If coercion or intimate-partner abuse emerges, move to safety assessment and safeguarding or domestic-abuse procedures. (5) Where the client wishes to continue a tradition, focus on harm-avoidance by seeking medical advice about their symptoms, not on technique. [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "In your family, what does steaming after a birth mean?" "If your partner never mentioned it, would you still want to do it?"
- Watch for: your own cultural assumptions; any sign of fear of a partner. [synthesis]
4.10 Commerce, influencers and group dynamics
- Purpose / when: when the client has spent heavily, is training as a "facilitator" or seller, or is in an online community promoting these practices. Sellers' sites present customer case studies and lifestyle-brand stories (e.g. ancient-royalty origin claims) as support. [source: eLotus biography; MinnPost]
- Steps: (1) Explore money spent and pressure to buy more or recruit. (2) Explore what belonging to the community gives them. (3) Help them evaluate claims using who benefits financially. (4) Manage your own conflicts of interest: never sell or refer to businesses you benefit from (APA 3.06). [source: APA Ethics Code] [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "What has the community given you? And has it cost you anything, money or otherwise?"
- Watch for: shame about money spent; loss of community if they step back. [synthesis]
4.11 Supporting a client who has been harmed
- Purpose / when: after burns, infection, pain or delayed treatment linked to these practices.
- Steps: (1) Ensure medical care first. (2) Normalise: the client acted on marketing or tradition, often in good faith. (3) Work on self-blame, regret, medical trauma and any effect on sexuality and intimacy. (4) Support the client in reporting if they wish (4.12). [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "You were trying to look after yourself with the information you had. What do you need now?"
- Watch for: avoidance of follow-up care; anger at self or seller turning into depression. [synthesis]
4.12 Reporting routes
- Purpose / when: misleading health claims, injuries from products or services, or practitioners exceeding scope.
- Steps: (1) Explain the client's options; reporting is their choice unless law or safeguarding requires otherwise (APA 4.05). (2) Misleading advertising: in the US, consumer-protection enforcement can be taken by state and county prosecutors, as in the 2018 California Goop case [source: KFF Health News]; the FTC (US), the Advertising Standards Authority (UK), and equivalent consumer bodies in Canada and Australia handle advertising complaints [uncertain: not verified for these products]. (3) Product injuries: the national product or device regulator (FDA, MHRA, Health Canada, TGA) [uncertain: product classification not verified]. (4) A regulated health professional promoting or performing these practices: their licensing board; a psychologist colleague: informal resolution first, then ethics committee or board where substantial harm is likely (APA 1.05). (5) Children: safeguarding services. [source: APA Ethics Code] [synthesis]
- Example language (illustrative): "If you wanted to, there are bodies that look at misleading health claims. Would you like to know more about that option?"
- Watch for: pressure on the client to report or not report; respect their choice except where safeguarding applies. [synthesis]
5. Handling problems
All guidance in this section is [synthesis] unless a source is given.
- Client becomes defensive ("You think I'm stupid"). Repair: acknowledge, return to their goals, and ask permission before any information. "I'm sorry it came across that way. I'm interested in what you're hoping for, not in judging it."
- Client will not see a doctor because of past dismissive or traumatic gynaecological care. Validate; explore what made it bad; help find a different clinician, a chaperone, a trauma-informed service or a female clinician if wanted; rehearse saying "stop". Do not substitute your reassurance for an assessment.
- Client continues despite symptoms (burning, discharge, pain). State your concern clearly and once, give urgent-care advice (4.6), document, and keep the relationship open. Adult choice is respected, but risk advice is not withheld.
- Client uses steaming instead of planned treatment (e.g. for prolapse). Explore fears about surgery or physiotherapy; with consent, liaise with the clinician (4.5). The documented burn case led to delayed prolapse surgery. [source: Live Science]
- Client asks you which herbs, stones or methods are safe. Decline to advise; explain that it is outside your role and route to the doctor or pharmacist; continue to explore meaning.
- Client is pregnant, trying to conceive, or postpartum. Encourage telling the midwife or obstetrician; note heat-exposure warnings in pregnancy. [source: Cleveland Clinic]
- Overwhelm or dissociation when discussing intimate topics. Pause, ground, give control of pace and words, and offer to return later; consider trauma-focused work within competence.
- The topic arises in couples work. See each partner separately to check for coercion before exploring jointly.
- A young person discloses use or is made to undergo a practice. Follow safeguarding procedures; assess consent and assent; involve appropriate adults and services. Never name minors in records shared outside the service.
- Rupture over cultural respect. Acknowledge the cultural meaning; separate respect for tradition from concern about specific symptoms; seek cultural consultation if needed.
- Client is a facilitator or seller. Explore livelihood, identity and financial stakes; avoid becoming a customer or referrer; consider whether a dual relationship is developing (APA 3.05). [source: APA Ethics Code]
- Therapist's own reactions (disgust, amusement, or enthusiasm). Notice and take to supervision; both ridicule and endorsement damage the work.
Harm account
What was actually done
- 2015, steaming popularised. Vaginal steaming gained wide attention in North America after the actress Gwyneth Paltrow endorsed it through Goop in 2015; it was presented as a spa-style cleansing and hormone-balancing treatment. [source: Live Science; Cleveland Clinic]
- January 2017 onward, jade eggs. Goop sold jade and rose-quartz vaginal eggs (reported price USD 66 for jade) with claims of pelvic-floor tightening, hormone balance, menstrual regulation, bladder control, "sexual energy" and clearing "chi pathways". A 2017 Goop Q&A titled "Jade Eggs for Your Yoni" presented them as a practice of concubines in ancient Chinese temples; a companion flower-essence blend was marketed as helping to prevent depression. Customers were told to insert the egg and hold it; no insertion details are given here. [source: MinnPost; KFF Health News citing the Washington Post and New York Times]
- 2018, enforcement. In September 2018 Goop agreed to pay USD 145,000 in civil penalties in a California consumer-protection case over unsubstantiated claims for the eggs and the flower-essence blend; reports said Goop must now have competent scientific evidence for efficacy claims, and Goop stated it settled over the claims, not over defects in the products [source: KFF Health News; MinnPost]. The case was brought jointly by ten county district attorneys' offices, including Orange and Santa Clara, through the state's Food, Drug, and Medical Device Task Force [source: Orange County District Attorney 2018].
- Origin claim tested. Gynaecologist Jennifer Gunter and archaeologist Sarah Parcak searched four major museum collections (Freer Gallery, Metropolitan Museum, Cleveland Museum of Art, Asian Art Museum), reviewing over 5,000 jade items, and found no vaginal jade egg; they concluded the ancient-Chinese claim "should be considered a modern marketing myth" (Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery; reported in the press from late October 2018; journal issue details [uncertain]). [source: MinnPost; BuzzFeed News 2018]
- 2019, documented burn. A 62-year-old woman in Canada recently diagnosed with vaginal prolapse, and awaiting surgery, used vaginal steaming believing it might help. She presented to the emergency department with second-degree burns to the vaginal membranes and cervix, was treated with antibiotic ointment and dressings changed regularly, and her prolapse surgery was postponed until healing. The case, reported by Dr Magali Robert (University of Calgary) in the Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada, was described as the first documented case of burns from vaginal steaming. [source: Live Science]
How it caused harm
- Thermal injury: steam close to thin vulvar and vaginal tissue causes burns; the documented case involved second-degree burns extending to the cervix. [source: Live Science; Cleveland Clinic]
- Delayed or disrupted care: a person used steaming for a diagnosed structural condition and the resulting injury delayed surgery. [source: Live Science]
- Infection: steam and herbs can alter vaginal pH and protective bacteria, risking bacterial vaginosis and yeast infection; shared or unclean equipment can introduce bacteria. Porous stone eggs can carry bacteria; gynaecologists warned of bacterial vaginosis and potentially fatal toxic shock syndrome. [source: Cleveland Clinic; MinnPost; Africa Check]
- Musculoskeletal harm: holding an egg encourages continuous clenching; a gynaecologist reported that overdone or incorrect pelvic-floor contractions cause pelvic pain and pain with sex. [source: MinnPost]
- Pregnancy: heat exposure may cause complications. [source: Cleveland Clinic]
- Psychological and financial harm: marketing that frames the genitals as needing detox or tightening may reinforce genital shame and anxiety; money is spent on unproven products and courses; misinformation (e.g. hormone or depression claims) may divert people from effective care. [synthesis]
- Most at risk: people with prolapse, incontinence, pelvic pain or infertility seeking non-surgical options; pregnant and postpartum people; people with distrust of or trauma from gynaecological care; people pressured by partners or tradition. [source: Live Science; Cleveland Clinic; Hull et al. 2011] [synthesis]
Recognising it today
- Names and rebrandings: "V-steam", "yoni steam", "peristeam hydrotherapy", "womb detox", "yoni eggs", crystal or rose-quartz eggs, "Taoist" or "ancient" feminine practices. [source: Cleveland Clinic; eLotus biography; KFF Health News]
- Phrases and rationales: "balances hormones", "regulates your cycle", "cleanses the womb", "fixes prolapse", "boosts fertility", "clears chi", "awakens sexual energy", "ancient royal secret", evidence offered as customer case studies or testimonials. [source: MinnPost; eLotus biography; Cleveland Clinic]
- Settings: spas and wellness studios, online shops, social media, doula and postpartum packages, continuing-education courses for complementary practitioners, facilitator certification. [source: eLotus biography; Live Science]
- Red flags in a colleague's or service's practice: a therapist recommending, selling or hosting steaming or egg sessions; combining them with psychotherapy; touching clients' pelvic area or demonstrating internal exercises; framing pelvic symptoms as energy blockage without medical referral; affiliate links or commissions. [synthesis]
- How legitimate care differs: pelvic-floor problems are assessed by a clinician; NICE recommends supervised pelvic floor muscle training by a physiotherapist or other trained professional who checks the ability to contract and relax and tailors the programme; intravaginal devices or vaginal cones are considered only as clinician-directed adjuncts within that care, not as stand-alone products sold with energy or hormone claims. [source: NICE NG210]
What to do instead and how to help those harmed
- Safer alternatives (via clinicians, not recommended by the therapist): GP or gynaecology assessment of pelvic, menstrual, discharge or fertility concerns; pelvic-health physiotherapy and supervised pelvic floor muscle training for prolapse, incontinence and sexual dysfunction; pessaries or surgery where a clinician advises; sexual-health clinics for infection concerns; plain-water external washing as gynaecologists advise. [source: NICE NG210; Cleveland Clinic; Africa Check]
- Assessment of affected clients: current symptoms and whether medical care has been received; trauma responses to the injury or to examinations; shame, regret, self-blame; effects on sexuality and relationships; money spent; whether partner, family or group pressure was involved. [synthesis]
- Treatment: trauma-focused and compassion-focused work for medical trauma and shame; CBT approaches for health anxiety (Domain II); sexual-health and couples work within competence; support for attending follow-up care. [synthesis]
- Ethical, reporting and legal duties: avoid harm and act within competence (APA 3.04, 2.01); no sales or referral conflicts (APA 3.06); share information only with consent or as law requires (APA 4.05); safeguard minors and adults at risk; support the client to report misleading claims or injuries (4.12); address colleagues' harmful practice informally first, then via ethics bodies or boards where substantial harm is likely (APA 1.05). [source: APA Ethics Code]
Sources
- Woman Gets Second-Degree Burns from 'Vaginal Steaming' (Live Science, 2019)
- Gwyneth Paltrow's Goop Settles 'Unsubstantiated' Vaginal Egg Health Claims For $145,000 (KFF Health News Morning Briefing, 2018)
- Vaginal jade eggs not only useless but potentially harmful (MinnPost, 2018)
- Vaginal steaming (Cleveland Clinic Health Essentials)
- No evidence steaming your vagina is good for you (Africa Check, 2021, updated 2022)
- Keli Garza, instructor biography (eLotus)
- A multi-country study on gender, sexuality and vaginal practices (WHO, 2012)
- Hull T, et al. (2011). Prevalence, motivations, and adverse effects of vaginal practices in Africa and Asia: findings from a multicountry household survey. Journal of Women's Health 20(7):1097–1109 (ANU research portal abstract)
- NICE NG210: Pelvic floor dysfunction: prevention and non-surgical management (2021)
- Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct (American Psychological Association)
- Cited through the above: Robert M., case report of vaginal steaming burns, Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada (abstract page, as linked by Global News), 2019 [uncertain: full citation not verified]; Gunter J., Parcak S., jade egg origins, Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery, reported 2018 [uncertain: title and issue not verified].
- Press release on the Goop settlement (California FDMD Task Force), Orange County District Attorney (4 September 2018)
- Report on the Canadian vaginal-steaming burn case study, Global News (13 August 2019)
- Report on Gunter and Parcak's search of 5,000 jade objects, BuzzFeed News (30 October 2018)