Anabaptist Gelassenheit

1. Introduction

Version followed: the 16th-century Anabaptist understanding of Gelassenheit as Mennonite historians present it (C. Arnold Snyder, Vision, 2004; Walter Klaassen and Robert Friedmann as discussed by Daniel Rempel, Conrad Grebel Review, 2020), and the contemporary Old Order Amish communal value as the Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies (Elizabethtown College) describes it, drawing on Kraybill and colleagues. Present-day Mennonite devotional uses (Clymer 2017; Suderman 2013) are noted where they differ.

What it is. Gelassenheit (German; roughly "yieldedness", "letting go", from lassen, to leave or let) is a spiritual disposition, not a single technique. Snyder glosses it as "yieldedness, abandonment, resignation, and complete acceptance of what God wills" and calls it a paradoxical "doing" that is "a surrender of doing, a surrender of control" [source: Snyder 2004]. Friedmann noted up to fifteen possible English renderings; "yieldedness" became the scholarly standard [source: Rempel 2020]. The Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online, as quoted by Clymer, lists self-surrender, resignation in God's will, self-abandonment, readiness to suffer for God and inner peace [source: Clymer 2017]; modern German dictionaries give "serenity" or "calmness" first [source: Clymer 2017].

Roots. Early Anabaptists took the term from late-medieval German mystical writing (Meister Eckhart, Johann Tauler, the Theologia Deutsch) but moved it from the cloister into ordinary, public, communal life [source: Rempel 2020, summarising Klaassen]. Carlstadt, Hans Denck, Thomas Müntzer, Hans Hut, Michael Sattler, Ulrich Stadler and Pilgram Marpeck all used it [source: Rempel 2020]. Among the Old Order Amish today it is described as the core value of the society: yielding oneself to a higher authority, with self-surrender, submission, contentment and a calm spirit, set against individualism [source: Amish Studies, Communal Values].

How change happens (as the tradition holds it). In the tradition's account the main obstacle to God's presence is the person's own stubborn will; when the will is yielded, God (or Christ living in the believer) acts, and discipleship, nonviolence and community follow from that inner surrender rather than from effort alone [source: Snyder 2004; Suderman 2013]. This is a theological claim held by the tradition, not a psychological mechanism. For the psychotherapist, Gelassenheit is something the client may live by: a source of meaning, calm and community, and sometimes a lens through which distress, abuse or scrupulosity is misread. The therapist's work is to understand and support it client-led, not to teach it [synthesis].

2. Framework

The sources give no therapeutic protocol, phases, session counts or manual for Gelassenheit; it is a lifelong orientation "from repentance until death" [source: Snyder 2004]. Two frameworks are relevant.

A. The tradition's own arc (as Snyder describes early Anabaptism).

Repentance and humility: recognising one's sinfulness and helplessness before God, and renouncing "the world" understood as the fallen order [source: Snyder 2004].
Inner yielding (spiritual baptism): surrender of the will to God; Leonhard Schiemer linked spiritual baptism with complete surrender [source: Snyder 2004].
Public covenant (water baptism): a public pledge to live by Christ's rule that binds the believer to fellow members (Hubmaier) [source: Snyder 2004].
Life tested in community: mutual admonition, preparation for the Lord's Supper, and the ban (Matt. 18:15–18) [source: Snyder 2004].
Baptism of blood: readiness to suffer, historically under persecution [source: Snyder 2004; Clymer 2017]. These are a theological sequence, not stages a therapist moves a client through.

B. The therapist's frame alongside it [synthesis]. No source gives session numbers; use whatever length the presenting problem's evidence-based treatment requires.

Phase 1, assessment and meaning: learn what Gelassenheit means in this client's community (Old Order, conservative, mainstream Mennonite, Hutterite, Bruderhof or other) and life; screen for abuse, coercion, scrupulosity, depression and contemplative difficulties. Move on when you and the client share a description of how yielding helps and where (if anywhere) it hurts.
Phase 2, integration: with explicit consent, use the client's own language of yielding, patience and humility inside the treatment you are already giving; collaborate with clergy if the client wishes. Move on when the client can tell, in their own terms, healthy yielding from compelled silence or self-erasure.
Phase 3, consolidation: relapse prevention phrased in the client's tradition; agreed routes to pastor, deacon, spiritual director or community support.

3. Guiding principles

Gelassenheit is the client's, not the therapist's. Practical meaning: you do not teach, prescribe or grade yieldedness; you ask how the client and their church live it [synthesis; competence framework in Vieten et al. 2013].
Attribute, do not adjudicate. Practical meaning: speak of "what you believe God is asking" rather than stating or dismissing it [synthesis].
Yielding is active, not passive. Practical meaning: Friedmann and Rempel insist it is not a passive principle; distinguish chosen surrender from helplessness or depression [source: Rempel 2020].
Noncoercion. Practical meaning: Rempel names noncoercion as intrinsic to Gelassenheit; any "yielding" extracted by threat, violence or shaming is outside the tradition's own ideal and is a safety issue [source: Rempel 2020].
Community is central. Practical meaning: in Amish teaching the community's welfare ranks above individual rights and its accumulated wisdom above one person's opinion; do not frame goals purely as individual self-assertion [source: Amish Studies, Communal Values].
Humility and obedience are paired virtues in Old Order life. Practical meaning: expect lines of obedience (children to parents, wives to husbands, members to leaders, ministers to bishop) and respect them, while still assessing for harm [source: Amish Studies, Communal Values].
Forgiveness is not reconciliation or staying. Practical meaning: survivors may forgive and still leave or seek accountability; do not let forgiveness language override safety [source: Griffith 2023; Kampen 1994].
Power can distort yieldedness. Practical meaning: historically, leaders demanded humility from members they did not practise themselves; listen for one-sided demands [source: Snyder 2004].
Faith may be a resource while church structures are an obstacle. Practical meaning: Kampen's participants found personal faith helpful and church responses harmful; support both, separately [source: Kampen 1994].
Role boundaries. Practical meaning: you are not a minister, bishop, confessor or spiritual director; refer for theological questions [synthesis].
Cultural humility and competence. Practical meaning: Vieten et al. set out 16 basic spiritual and religious competencies across attitudes, knowledge and skills; build knowledge of Anabaptist history before interpreting [source: Vieten et al. 2013, abstract].
No health claims. Practical meaning: Gelassenheit is not presented as treatment for any illness; its calm and acceptance are spiritual goods in the tradition, with no clinical trial evidence specific to it in the sources consulted [synthesis].

4. Intervention inventory

The inventory has two parts. Part A sets out the elements of Gelassenheit as the sources describe them, with how a therapist can work with each when the client brings it; these are the tradition's practices, used client-led and only with consent. Part B is the therapist's own clinical work alongside. No source gives a session protocol; all step sequences for the therapist are [synthesis] unless tagged otherwise.

A1. Humility and recognising one's need of God

Purpose (tradition): the starting point of yieldedness: honest recognition of one's helplessness and need for God, with humility rather than self-reliance [source: Snyder 2004]. Hubmaier pictured the sinner as a wounded person surrendering to Christ the physician [source: Snyder 2004]. In Amish life, rejection of pride (attention-seeking dress, ornament, display) is a daily expression [source: Amish Studies, Communal Values].
When to use: when the client describes humility as a value they want to live by, or when it is being confused with worthlessness.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask what humility means in their congregation and family, and what it looks like on an ordinary day. (2) Ask what pride means to them and how they notice it. (3) Separate, in their words, humility before God from contempt for self (e.g. "I am nothing" said in despair). (4) If depressive self-devaluation is present, treat the depression with the indicated therapy, using humility language only where it supports self-care (e.g. accepting help as humility).
Example language (illustrative): "In your church, what's the difference between being humble and feeling worthless? Which one is this week more like?"
Watch for: pervasive guilt, hopelessness or self-loathing labelled as humility; suicidal thinking (assess under current standards). Working: client can name humility as freeing and still accept care.

A2. Yielding the will: "standing idle" and letting go of control

Purpose (tradition): the core movement: giving up one's own control so God can act. Marpeck spoke of standing idle, "as dead in ourselves"; Snyder: "We must learn to stop doing" [source: Snyder 2004]. Rempel stresses this is active surrender, a yielding to God's prior action, not passivity [source: Rempel 2020].
When to use: anxiety, worry, over-control, perfectionism, caregiver strain, situations that cannot be changed (illness, loss), when the client finds yielding meaningful.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask how the client practises letting go (prayer, silence, Scripture, hymns such as those of the Ausbund used in some communities [source: Snyder 2004 cites an Ausbund hymn]). (2) Map what is in the client's hands and what they entrust to God, in their words. (3) Link worry-reduction or acceptance techniques from the client's existing treatment to this map, with consent. (4) Check that "letting go" does not include giving up safety, medical care or legal protection.
Example language (illustrative): "You said Gelassenheit means letting God carry what you can't. What part of this is yours to do this week, and what part are you handing over?"
Watch for: yielding used to justify not seeking medical care or staying in danger; resignation as depressive helplessness (loss of energy, interest, hope). Working: less rumination, steadier mood, client still takes the actions that are theirs.

A3. Detachment from "creatures"

Purpose (tradition): detaching from created things so as to cling to God. Klaassen includes wealth, institutions and even church programmes among "creatures" and describes "the renunciation of all attempts to impose our own solutions" [source: Rempel 2020, quoting Klaassen].
When to use: materialism or status stress, compulsive striving, grief over possessions or roles, over-attachment to a plan.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask what the client holds too tightly and what holding it costs. (2) Explore what their tradition says about holding things loosely. (3) Pair with values-based behavioural work if it is part of the client's treatment. (4) Distinguish detachment from emotional numbing or withdrawal from relationships.
Example language (illustrative): "If the farm or the job is a 'creature' in the old sense, what would holding it more loosely look like, without neglecting it?"
Watch for: detachment used to avoid grief, emotional shutdown, or dissociation. Working: client grieves and still values what was lost.

A4. Patience: waiting on God

Purpose (tradition): one of Klaassen's four measures of Gelassenheit: patience, waiting on God for outcomes [source: Rempel 2020].
When to use: uncertainty (diagnoses, legal processes, family estrangement), impatience-driven conflict, chronic conditions.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Name the waiting situation. (2) Ask how their tradition helps people wait (prayer, community visits, hymns). (3) Agree on what active steps belong alongside waiting. (4) Review at the next session.
Example language (illustrative): "Waiting on God and doing nothing sound alike from outside. From inside, how are they different for you?"
Watch for: waiting that delays needed action (safety, treatment); worsening anxiety. Working: tolerance of uncertainty grows, with necessary steps still taken.

A5. Renouncing wrath and resentment

Purpose (tradition): Klaassen's measure of giving up wrath and resentment toward the world [source: Rempel 2020].
When to use: anger and rumination after hurt; client wants to forgive.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Validate the hurt and the anger as information first. (2) Ask what renouncing resentment means in their tradition and what it does not require (e.g. silence about harm, contact with the person). (3) If the hurt involves abuse, follow B4 before any forgiveness work. (4) Use the client's chosen forgiveness or anger-processing approach, at their pace.
Example language (illustrative): "You can let go of bitterness and still say clearly that what happened was wrong. Does your faith allow both?"
Watch for: pressure (from self, family or leaders) to forgive quickly; suppressed anger turning to depression or somatic complaints; forgiveness used to keep someone in contact with an abuser [source: Griffith 2023; Kampen 1994]. Working: anger is felt and named; forgiveness, if chosen, is not coerced.

A6. Nonresistance: living without weapons

Purpose (tradition): Klaassen lists living without weapons as a measure of Gelassenheit; Suderman links it to rejecting violence and hierarchy [source: Rempel 2020; Suderman 2013].
When to use: client's moral identity, conscientious stances, conflict at work or with neighbours, moral injury.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Respect the stance as a moral commitment. (2) Separate nonviolence toward others from not protecting oneself or children: ask how their church handles seeking help from police, courts or shelters. (3) If the client has acted against the stance (e.g. in self-defence, military service), explore moral injury and guilt, and offer clergy consultation.
Example language (illustrative): "Your church's peace teaching is about not harming others. Does it also say you must not protect yourself or your children?"
Watch for: Kampen found that peace theology led abused women to "turn the other cheek" and that this increased their vulnerability [source: Kampen 1994]. Working: the stance is held without the client sacrificing safety.

A7. Baptismal covenant, mutual admonition and community discernment

Purpose (tradition): believer's baptism as a public pledge to live by Christ's rule and a covenant with fellow members; members' lives are tested by mutual admonition, before the Lord's Supper, and through the ban (Matt. 18:15–18) [source: Snyder 2004]. These are communal rites led by the congregation and its ordained leaders, not therapy tasks.
When to use (therapist): when baptism, communion preparation, admonition or the ban is part of the client's distress or support.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask who leads these rites in their church and what the client's standing is. (2) Explore the meaning: belonging, accountability, fear. (3) If the client faces discipline or exclusion, assess loss, shame, isolation and suicide risk under current standards. (4) Do not advise on whether to submit to discipline; help the client clarify their own values and options, and offer clergy contact if wanted.
Example language (illustrative): "Before communion your congregation looks at how members are living. What is that time like for you this year?"
Watch for: scrupulous over-confession before communion (see B5); social isolation after exclusion; pressure on minors to commit (safeguarding: follow local child-protection procedures). Working: the client experiences community accountability as support or can make an informed choice about it.

A8. Servanthood, mutual submission and "being with"

Purpose (tradition): Suderman describes Gelassenheit expressed as serving rather than ruling, walking with the least, putting others first and mutual submission in a non-hierarchical community [source: Suderman 2013]. Rempel applies it to intellectual disability as "being with" rather than "doing for" people [source: Rempel 2020].
When to use: caregiving, family life, church service roles, burnout among helpers.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask whom the client serves and who serves them; check whether submission is mutual. (2) Name signs of depletion. (3) Reframe receiving help and rest as part of mutual service, if the client agrees. (4) Plan concrete supports, including church mutual aid if available.
Example language (illustrative): "Mutual submission goes both ways. Who in your life yields to you, or helps carry your load?"
Watch for: one-way submission (only women, only the young, only members) [source: Snyder 2004 on leaders demanding humility they did not show]; caregiver exhaustion. Working: the client accepts some help without guilt.

A9. Contemplative ways into Gelassenheit (contemporary Mennonite)

Purpose (tradition): some contemporary Mennonites cultivate Gelassenheit, understood as serenity, through inner work on the source of restlessness, prayer, meditation, dream work and contemplative walking; the writer describes a change over years, not quickly [source: Clymer 2017].
When to use: client already practises or wishes to explore contemplative prayer within their tradition.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask what they practise and who guides them. (2) Support the practice as theirs; for guidance, refer to a spiritual director or pastor within their tradition. (3) Screen for contemplative difficulties (B6) if practice is lengthy or intensive. (4) Keep practice separate from therapy homework unless the client asks to link them.
Example language (illustrative): "You mentioned walking prayer helps you settle. Would it help to talk about how it fits with what we're doing here, or would you rather keep it separate?"
Watch for: anxiety, depersonalisation or intrusive memories arising during silent practice (B6). Working: practice is calming and the client reports more ease.

A10. Communal Gelassenheit in Old Order life: humility, obedience, contentment, calm

Purpose (tradition): in Amish society Gelassenheit means yielding to a higher authority, with self-surrender, submission, contentment and a calm spirit; obedience runs along lines of family and church authority; salvation is spoken of as a "living hope" within an obedient life of the faith community [source: Amish Studies, Communal Values].
When to use: Plain clients and former members; when individualistic therapy goals clash with communal values.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask about community, church district and family expectations, including any rules about technology or contact with outsiders that affect therapy (telehealth, phone use). (2) Frame goals in shared, communal terms where the client wants. (3) Ask whether the client wants family or a church leader involved, and on what terms. (4) Ask about preferred language (many Plain clients speak a German dialect at home) [uncertain: not verified].
Example language (illustrative): "Rather than what you want for yourself alone, what would be good for you and your family together?"
Watch for: obedience to authority masking abuse or coercion; isolation of the client from outside help; your own bias toward individualism. Working: treatment fits the community's frame and the client stays engaged.

B1. Assessing what Gelassenheit means in the client's life

Purpose: to understand the client's tradition, community and use of yieldedness before any intervention [synthesis].
When to use: at intake with any client from an Anabaptist background (Amish, Mennonite, Hutterite, Brethren, Bruderhof, other Plain or former members), and whenever surrender, submission or humility language appears.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask which church or community, and whether the client is a baptised member, seeker, or former member. (2) Ask what Gelassenheit (or yielding, submission, humility) means to them and how it helps. (3) Ask where it has been hard or used against them. (4) Use the DSM-5-TR Cultural Formulation Interview and its supplementary module on spirituality, religion and moral traditions to structure the enquiry [uncertain: not verified]. (5) Record the client's own terms and use them.
Example language (illustrative): "Some people from Anabaptist churches talk about Gelassenheit or yielding. Is that a word that matters to you? What does it mean in your life?"
Watch for: guardedness about outsiders; the client testing whether you will mock or try to change their faith. Working: the client corrects or expands your understanding.

B2. Consent and client-led integration (spiritually integrated psychotherapy)

Purpose: to bring the client's yieldedness into therapy only as far as they choose [synthesis; cross-refer Domain VII, spiritually integrated psychotherapy].
When to use: after B1, when the client says their faith is relevant to the problem.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask explicitly whether they want faith language used in sessions. (2) Agree on limits: you will not interpret Scripture or doctrine. (3) Translate standard treatment tasks into their terms where they fit (e.g. acceptance as yielding, values as discipleship), checking with the client each time. (4) Review the arrangement periodically. Vieten et al.'s competencies (attitudes, knowledge, skills) are a framework for this work [source: Vieten et al. 2013, abstract].
Example language (illustrative): "Would it help to talk about this in your church's language, or would you rather we keep therapy and faith apart?"
Watch for: the client deferring to you as an authority; your own religious or secular views steering the work. Working: the client leads the faith content.

B3. Using published secular adaptations alongside

Purpose: acceptance- and compassion-based treatments overlap with yielding and patience in practice, though not in belief [synthesis].
When to use: when an acceptance-based method is indicated for the presenting problem and the client is comfortable with it.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Choose the evidence-based treatment for the presenting problem (cross-refer Domain II: MBSR, MBCT, MSC, CFT; Domain VII: contemplative and spiritually integrated psychotherapy). (2) Explain the method's secular origin honestly; some Plain or conservative clients may object to practices with Buddhist roots. (3) Offer it in neutral terms, or let the client link it to their own yielding if they wish. (4) Do not present Gelassenheit itself as a clinical technique.
Example language (illustrative): "This exercise comes from a secular programme. Some people find it fits with what their church teaches about yielding; others prefer to keep it separate. What feels right to you?"
Watch for: discomfort with meditation as foreign to their faith; any sense that you are replacing their practice. Working: the client uses the skill and reports no conflict with their faith.

B4. Telling healthy yieldedness from coerced submission or abuse

Purpose: to protect clients when submission, nonresistance or forgiveness teachings are used to keep them in harm.
When to use: any sign of domestic violence, sexual abuse, child abuse, spiritual abuse or coercive control.
Background: in Kampen's interview study of nine formerly abused Mennonite wives, teachings on submission, obedience, love and forgiveness kept women in abusive marriages; peace theology led them to "turn the other cheek"; they blamed themselves and denied the abuse; pastors' advice tended to blame them; personal faith helped while the church was an obstacle [source: Kampen 1994]. A Mennonite seminary scholar describes the "weaponization of forgiveness and reconciliation" and writes that forgiveness "doesn't mean anyone has to stay" with an abuser [source: Griffith 2023]. Rempel names noncoercion as part of Gelassenheit [source: Rempel 2020].
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Screen privately for violence and coercion; never with the partner or a church leader present. (2) Make a safety plan. (3) Distinguish, in the client's own frame, yielding to God from compelled submission to a person who is harming them. (4) Separate forgiveness (inner, optional, the client's) from reconciliation and from staying. (5) Follow mandatory-reporting and child-protection duties in your jurisdiction. (6) Support the client's faith as a resource even if the church response has been harmful; offer an outside pastor or advocate if they want one.
Example language (illustrative): "Yielding to God is something you choose. Being made to submit to someone who hurts you is not the same thing. Where does what's happening at home fit?"
Watch for: minimisation, self-blame, fear of exclusion, pressure from family or leaders. Working: the client names the harm and uses safety resources.

B5. Scrupulosity: confession, communion preparation and ERP with faith-leader collaboration

Purpose: to recognise and treat OCD that has attached to self-examination, confession, admonition or worthiness for communion.
How it presents: persistent worry that a thought or act is sinful; avoidance of religious practice or fixation on minor details; faith driven by fear, guilt and shame rather than meaning and peace; a demand for absolute certainty; long delays before help-seeking [source: IOCDF, For Faith Leaders].
Steps: (1) Assess for OCD with a standard interview [synthesis]. (2) Explain the difference between faith practice and compulsion: prayer for support differs from prayer done to escape the fear of not praying [source: IOCDF]. (3) With the client's consent, involve a pastor or minister: the clinician helps the client practise faith freely while the leader indicates what healthy practice looks like in the tradition [source: IOCDF]. (4) Build graded exposure to avoided religious situations (the IOCDF gives the example of approaching church step by step) and reduce reassurance-seeking [source: IOCDF]. (5) Ask leaders and family not to give repeated reassurance, re-pray or re-bless on demand, or loosen standards to accommodate symptoms [source: IOCDF]. (6) Use exposure only with informed consent, a clear rationale and contraindications checked (e.g. active suicidality, acute psychosis) [synthesis].
Example language (illustrative): "Your minister agrees that you've confessed what needed confessing. The urge to confess again is the OCD asking for certainty. Let's practise not answering it."
Watch for: confession or admonition becoming endless; avoidance of communion; reassurance loops with leaders. Working: less time on rituals and a return to worship from meaning rather than fear.

B6. Contemplative difficulties and adverse effects

Purpose: to recognise and manage difficulties when a client practises extended silent or meditative prayer (A9). Meditation-related research is mostly on Buddhist-derived practice; its application to Anabaptist contemplative prayer is [synthesis].
Background: the Varieties of Contemplative Experience study (Lindahl et al. 2017, PLOS ONE) interviewed over 100 Western Buddhist meditators and teachers and mapped challenges across perceptual, affective, cognitive, somatic, sense-of-self and social domains, examining influencing factors and remedies [source: Cheetah House VCE page]. The systematic review by Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (83 studies) found adverse events in 65% of studies, a mean prevalence of 8.3%, most often anxiety, depression and cognitive anomalies, and noted they can occur without prior mental illness [source: PubMed 32820538]. Cheetah House offers meditation-safety training, consultations and clinician resources [source: Cheetah House VCE page].
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask about practice intensity and any retreats; screen for trauma history, psychosis, bipolar disorder and dissociation before intensive retreats. (2) If difficulties arise, reduce dose (shorter or less frequent silent practice), shift to active, eyes-open or communal forms (hymn singing, walking, service), and use grounding. (3) Trauma-sensitive mindfulness principles (Treleaven) offer adaptations such as choice, open eyes and anchoring attention outside the body [uncertain: not verified]. (4) Differentiate spiritual crisis from psychosis, mania, depression or dissociation without pathologising faith; DSM-5-TR lists a religious or spiritual problem as a focus of clinical attention, code Z65.8. (5) With consent, coordinate with the client's spiritual director or pastor.
Example language (illustrative): "Sometimes long silent prayer stirs things up. Let's try shorter times, maybe walking or singing instead, and see if things settle."
Watch for: panic, depersonalisation, intrusive memories, sleep loss, mood elevation, unusual beliefs beyond the community's norms. Working: symptoms ease with dose reduction and grounding.

B7. Referral and collaboration with ministers, deacons, bishops and spiritual directors

Purpose: to route theological and community questions to those authorised to answer them.
When to use: questions about doctrine, church discipline, communion, baptism or forgiveness; scrupulosity treatment (B5); contemplative guidance (A9).
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask whether the client wants contact and with whom. (2) Obtain written consent stating what will be shared. (3) Agree roles: the minister addresses faith, you address mental health. (4) Check for safety first: where the leader is implicated in harm or has dismissed abuse, do not involve them; offer an outside advocate or another pastor [cf. Kampen 1994; Griffith 2023].
Example language (illustrative): "That's a question for your minister rather than me. Would you like to ask them, or would it help if we talked together with your permission?"
Watch for: confidentiality leaks in small communities; leaders steering treatment. Working: clear, separate roles and a client who feels supported by both.

B8. Exclusion, leaving and religious trauma

Purpose: to support clients facing church discipline or the ban, or who have left an Anabaptist community.
When to use: former members; members under discipline; young adults deciding about baptism.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Assess losses: family contact, livelihood, language, community. (2) Assess suicide risk under current standards. (3) Respect the client's choice to stay, return or leave; do not push either way. (4) Support practical needs (education, documents, work) and connections to former-member support where the client wishes. (5) Treat trauma, if present, with an evidence-based approach, separating the client's faith from harm done in its name.
Example language (illustrative): "Leaving, staying and going back are all choices people make. What matters most to you right now?"
Watch for: grief mistaken for depression only; anger at God or self-blame; isolation. Working: the client builds support and a coherent account of their story.

B9. The therapist's own position, boundaries and roles

Purpose: to keep the therapy relationship clear.
Steps [synthesis]: (1) Reflect on your own views on submission, authority and religion before working with Plain or Anabaptist clients. (2) Self-disclose your faith or lack of it only if it serves the client. (3) Avoid dual relationships (e.g. treating someone from your own congregation; acting as minister or spiritual director). (4) Follow your profession's ethics code on competence, multiple relationships and respect for religion [synthesis]. (5) Seek consultation on unfamiliar communities; build knowledge per the attitudes, knowledge and skills domains in Vieten et al. 2013.
Example language (illustrative): "I'm not here to teach you about faith. I'm here to help with the anxiety. Your minister can help with the faith questions."
Watch for: your own individualism or anti-authority bias; over-identification. Working: the client trusts you without seeing you as a church authority.

5. Handling problems

The sources do not address therapy problems directly; the guidance below is [synthesis] except where tagged.

Yielding that is really depression or helplessness. Sign: "it's God's will" said with flat mood, withdrawal and loss of hope. Response: assess and treat depression; ask, in the client's terms, whether this feels like the active surrender their tradition describes (Friedmann and Rempel insist it is not passive) or like giving up [source for the distinction: Rempel 2020].
Submission used to stay in danger. Sign: abuse minimised as a cross to bear or a call to forgive. Response: safety first (B4); separate forgiveness from staying [source: Griffith 2023; Kampen 1994]; report as the law requires.
Pressure to forgive quickly. Sign: the client says leaders or family expect reconciliation. Response: validate anger; forgiveness is the client's choice and timeline; do not join the pressure (B4, A5).
Stuck in therapy because goals feel prideful. Sign: the client resists self-focused goals or assertiveness as pride or self-will. Response: reframe goals communally (what helps the family or church), as service, or as stewardship; drop language of self-actualisation [source for communal priority: Amish Studies, Communal Values].
Non-adherence to homework. Sign: tasks not done. Response: check for conflict with work rhythms, technology rules, church calendar or a sense that the task is "doing" rather than yielding; simplify and adapt; ask rather than assume.
Resistance to an outsider. Sign: guardedness, short answers. Response: acknowledge you are an outsider; ask the client to teach you; be clear about confidentiality and what you will not share with the church.
Rupture over faith. Sign: the client feels judged for submission or obedience values. Response: name and repair; restate that you will not try to change their faith; check whether a therapist from or familiar with their tradition would suit them better.
Client wants you as spiritual guide. Sign: asks you to rule on sin, forgiveness or church discipline. Response: decline gently and refer (B7, B9).
Scrupulosity mistaken for devotion. Sign: endless confession, repeated questions to the minister, avoiding communion. Response: assess OCD; ERP with consent and faith-leader collaboration (B5) [source: IOCDF].
Distress during silent prayer or retreat. Sign: panic, unreality, intrusive memories. Response: dose reduction, active and communal forms, grounding, differential assessment (B6) [source: Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica; Cheetah House].
Leader dynamics. Sign: one-sided humility demands from leaders. Snyder records this historical pattern [source: Snyder 2004]. Response: support the client's own discernment; avoid speaking against the church; involve an outside advocate where harm is present.
Confidentiality in small communities. Sign: fear that others will know. Response: discuss what is shared and how; plan discreet scheduling; be careful with joint sessions with leaders or family.
Children and young people. Sign: minors facing discipline, harsh correction or pressure around baptism. Response: follow child-safeguarding procedures in your jurisdiction; obtain consent from guardians and assent from the young person; never let community processes replace statutory protection [synthesis].
Former member longing to return. Response: explore both pull and fear; respect any choice; plan for loss either way (B8).
Your own bias. Sign: feeling an urge to "free" the client from obedience or, conversely, to endorse submission uncritically. Response: supervision and consultation; review Vieten et al.'s competencies [source: Vieten et al. 2013].

Sources

Web sources:

Books and works cited through the web sources above:

Kraybill, D. B., Johnson-Weiner, K. M., & Nolt, S. M. (2013). The Amish (cited by the Amish Studies page).
Kraybill, D. B. (2001). The Riddle of Amish Culture (cited by the Amish Studies page).
Lindahl, J. R., et al. (2017). The varieties of contemplative experience: A mixed-methods study of meditation-related challenges in Western Buddhists. PLOS ONE. (cited by Cheetah House)
Walter Klaassen and Robert Friedmann on Gelassenheit, as discussed by Rempel 2020.
Treleaven, D. Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness [uncertain: not verified].
DSM-5-TR: Cultural Formulation Interview; religious or spiritual problem, Z65.8.
ICD-10-CM Z65.8, Other specified problems related to psychosocial circumstances (includes 'Religious or spiritual problem'), https://www.unboundmedicine.com/icd/view/ICD-10-CM/945432/all/Z65_8___Other_specified_problems_related_to_psychosocial_circumstances
Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online entry on Gelassenheit, as quoted by Clymer 2017 [uncertain: not verified].

← Previous · XIII-219Shaker laboring worship (historical)Next · XIII-221 →Christian theosophy (Böhme)